B: MEASURING CRIME Flashcards
CSEW
Crime survey for England and Wales
What does the Crime Survey for England and Wales show?
That crime is much higher than police figures suggest
Successes of the Crime Survey for England and Wales
Successful in developing special measures to estimate the impact of domestic abuse, stalking and sexual victimisation
Limitations of the Crime Survey for England and Wales
Victimless crimes will not appear
Only asked people over 16 in the past
Trends are only an estimate
75% response rate
Who created the Islington Crime Survey?
Jones and Young (1986)
What did the first Islington crime survey show?
1/3 of households had been touched by serious crime in the last 12 months
How many households affected by serious crime in the last 12 months? (ICS)
1/3
How did Young criticise victim surveys?
Accuracy relies on memory and honesty
Peoples thresholds may differ
Low response rate affects representativeness
People who have not been victims would not report- overestimation
Strengths of self report studies (3)
- Can give insight (qualitative)
- Longitudinal
- Can challenge view of ‘typical criminal’
Example of a self report study
The Cambridge Study- followed 411 South London boys 8-32, and the Edinburgh study of Youth Transitions- looked at gender differences
What did Campbell (1981) find in self report studies?
Levels of crime and deviance admitted to by g
females and males were much closer than police record figures suggest
Who carried out the Cambridge study?
Farrington et al
Target audience of self report studies
Young boys, and focus on minor crimes
3 weaknesses of self report studies
- Validity
- Ethics
- Attrition
West and Farrington (1977) on self report studies
Only 2% of unconnected boys admitted, compared to 94% of convicted