Attatchement Flashcards
what is attachment
- an emotional bond between 2 people, e.g child and primary caregiver
- the bond has to be a two way process that endures over time- lasts forever
define the term reciprocity
- responding to an action with another action ( response doesn’t have to be mirrored)
- e.g tickling- laughing
- ‘turn taking’ - respond to one another
define the term interactional synchrony
- when two people interact with each other they tend to mirror one another’s facial and body movements. This can include imitating emotions as well as behaviour
what experiment did Meltzoff + Moore propose (reciprocity)
- they wanted to investigate reciprocity between infants and their caregivers
- controlled observation
- used 6 babies (12-27 days)
- 12 babies (16-21 days)
- model displaced 1 of 3 expressions (tongue out, mouth open, pursed lips)
- dummy was removed and babies expression was filmed
- results found babies young as 2 weeks showed an association between the expression or gesture
what are the weaknesses of research into infant and caregiver interaction
1) lacks internal validity, don’t know if infant activity is genuine or if it’s a random outburst of behaviour
counter point: research shows infants made little response with stimulating objects suggesting they have a specific social response to humans
2) development importance- observing behaviour doesn’t tell us its importance. Therefore unsure if reciprocity and synchrony are important for a child’s development
counter point: Isabella et al found achievement of interactional synchrony predicted development of good quality attachment
what is a strength of research into infant and caregiver interaction
Filmed observations:
- usually filmed in a lab, other activity that may distract child can be controlled
- researchers are unlikely to miss key behaviours
- more than one researcher can observe, baby doesn’t know they are being observed
- reliability and validity are increased
what are the 4 stages of attachment proposed by Shaffer + Emerson
stage 1- indiscriminate attachment, baby doesn’t care who caregiver is, responds to all
stage 2- beginnings of attachment, learns to distinguish primary and secondary caregiver, still accepts care from anyone
stage 3- specific attachment, looks to particular figures for security, shows stranger + separation anxiety
stage 4- multiple attachments, baby is able to form several attachments and becomes independent
what are the weaknesses of the stages of attachment by Shaffer + Emerson
-unreliable: data is based on mothers reports, social desirability, want to be seen in a positive light
-problems with stage model: some cultures have different orders of attachment, therefore judging them and reflects badly on them
what is a strength of the stages of attachment by Shaffer + Emerson
- has external validity, observations were made during ordinary activities and reported to researchers
- means highly likely that the participants behaved naturally while being observed
what did Lorenz(1935) find in his Geese study
-through imprinting, the goslings followed Lorenz around, and the control group followed their real mother.
- sexual imprinting, choose to m ate with same object they imprinted with
Evaluate Lorenz’s geese study
(strength with counterpoint)
- Guiton et al imprinted new-born chicken onto yellow rubber gloves, As theory predicts, they tried to mate with the gloves
- However, imprinting may not be permanent as Guiton found when the chickens socialised with other chickens they were able to engage in normal social behaviour, so imprinting is reversible.
Explain Harlow’s monkey study with findings
- suggested attachment is not based on a ‘feeding bond’ as predicted by the learning theory
- 2 monkeys, one wrapped in soft cloth, the other in plain wire with milk bottle
- monkeys spent longer with soft cloth when scared regardless where milk bottle was
- therefore, monkeys don’t form attachments with figure who feeds them, but to the one offering contact comfort
Evaluate Harlow’s monkey study (weaknesses)
- confounding variables: head shape of monkey was different, soft cloth looked more realistic to a monkey. Decreases internal validity as no longer measuring what intended to measure, attached to head shape instead
- can’t generalise to humans: can’t say for certain that humans will react in the same way
- ethical issues: motherless monkeys develop abnormally. socially abnormal- froze when approached by other monkeys. sexually abnormal: didn’t show normal mating behaviour
what did Shaffer and Emerson find on primary attachment with the role of the father
- only 3% of cases the father was the primary caregiver
- in 27% of the cases the father was joint first with the mother
What did Grossmann find in his longitudinal study (role of father in attachment)
- looked into both parent’s behaviour and its relationship with to the child’s quality of attachment into their teens
- the research found that attachment with the father was less important than the quality of attachment with mother
- therefore fathers may be less important for long-term emotional development
why aren’t fathers said to be suitable to be primary caregivers
1) not psychologically equipped, less oestrogen in men which plays a role in interpersonal skills
2) sensitive responsiveness
3) fathers are ‘playmates’ not caregivers
what is research support for the idea that fathers are not caregivers they are ‘playmates’ (Geiger)
- Geiger found that a fathers play interactions were more exciting in comparison to a mothers
- the mothers were more affectionate and nurturing
what is research support for the idea that fathers are not psychologically/biologically/socially equipped for nurturing attachment
- Hrdy found that fathers were less able to detect low levels of infant distress compared to mothers
- fathers aren’t capable of showing sensitive responses so aren’t equipped
- also less oestrogen,
What are the assumptions of the Learning Theory in attachment
-we learn to form an attachment through classical and operant conditioning based on food.
- the baby forms an association between mother (NS) and pleasure of being fed (UCR)
- results happiness when mother is present
what is the role of operant conditioning in the Learning theory of attachment
crying leads to a response from caregiver (e.g feeding), as long as caregiver provides correct response, crying is reinforced because it produces a pleasurable response