Attachment Flashcards
Attachment
What is attachment
Enduring two way emotional tie to a specific person normally between parent and child which develops in set stages within a fairly set timetable
Attachment
What is altricial
Born at a relatively early stage of development so need to form, attachment bond with adults who will protect and nurture them
Attachment
Who can attachment be provided by
Anyone who provides comfort and safer but is usually mother
Caregiver infant interactions
What behaviours do people display for attachment
Proximity to primary caregiver
Separation distress
Stranger anxiety
Secure baser behaviour
Caregiver infant interactions
What is proximity to primary care giver
People try to stay physically close to those whom they are attached to
Caregiver infant interactions
What is separation distress
People are distressed when an attachment figure leaves their presence and show pleasure when they’re reunited
Caregiver infant interactions
What is stranger anxiety
Distress in prescience of unknown individuals
Caregiver infant interactions
What is secure base behaviour
Even when independent of attachment figure we tend to make regular contact with them infants display secure based behaviour when they regularly return to their attachment figure while playing
Caregiver infant interactions
Why are interactions between care giver and infant important
Develop and maintain their attachment bond and have important function for their social development
Caregiver infant interactions
What are two features of caregiver infant interaction named on spec
International synchrony
Reciprocity
Caregiver infant interactions
What is interactional synchrony
Temporal coordination of micro level social behaviour
Caregiver infant interactions
What is international synchrony in caregivers and infant
Infant move bodies/react in time with the rhythm of carers spoken language to create kind of turn taking to sustain communication
Caregiver infant interactions
What’s international synchrony know as
Conversation dance
Mirror each other in terms of facial and body movements
Caregiver infant interactions
Why is it believed international synchrony is important
For development of mother infant attachment
Caregiver infant interactions
What is reciprocity
Carer infant interaction is two way when each Pearson responds to other signal and elicits a response resulting in turn taking
Caregiver infant interactions
How often to mother pickup on ans respond to infant alertness
Two thirds of the time
Caregiver infant interactions
Why is reciprocity important
Results in mutual behaviour help to strengthen attachment bond
Caregiver infant interactions
Two other interaction s
Bodily contact
Caregiverese
Caregiver infant interactions
What is physical contact
Physical interactions between crater and infant helps for. The attachment bonds especially in period after birth
Caregiver infant interactions
What is caregiverese
Adults who interact with infant use a modified form of vocal language which aids communication between carer and infant
Caregiver infant interactions
What does caregiverese do
Strengthens attachments bond
Caregiver infant interactions
2 strengths
Controlled observations capture fine detail
Increasing understanding
Caregiver infant interactions
Good about observations
Observations of mother infant interactions are generally well controlled procedures with both mother and infant Beijing filmed from multiple angles
Caregiver infant interactions
What does this ensure
Very fine details of behaviour can be recorded and later analysed
Caregiver infant interactions
What s good for studying babies
Baby don’t know or care they’re being observed so behaviour doesn’t change in response to controlled observations
Caregiver infant interactions
Why is this a strength
Means reaserch has high validity
Caregiver infant interactions
What has reasch increased importance of
Research into importance of caregiver infant interaction as increased our understanding of how strong attachments can be made
Caregiver infant interactions
What is good about understanding more
Can more effectively advise and facilitate parent particularly in early weeks after birth
Caregiver infant interactions
Why is this a strength
Can lead to stronger relationships in future
Caregiver infant interactions
2 weaknesses
Hard to know whats happening when observing infants
Socially sensitive reaseach and economics implications for working mothers
Caregiver infant interactions
What do many studies show
Same patterns of interactions by observations between mothers and infants
Caregiver infant interactions
What is the however
What is being observed is merely hand movement or changes in expression
Caregiver infant interactions
What’s difficult to be certain
What is taking place from an infants perspective as babies cannot communicate inferences must be drawn
Caregiver infant interactions
What is bad about inferences
Subjective not objective
Caregiver infant interactions
Why is this a weakness
Cannot really know for certain that behaviours seen in mother infant interactions have a special meanings
Caregiver infant interactions
Why is research into mother infant interaction socially sensitive
Because it suggest that children may be disadvantaged by particular child bearing practices
Caregiver infant interactions
Who in particular could research impact
Mothers who return to work shortly after a child is born as restricts opportunities for achieving interactional synchrony
Caregiver infant interactions
Why is missing interactional synchrony bad
Argued to be important in developing attachment
Caregiver infant interactions
What des this suggest
Mothers should return to work too soon which has sociallly sensitive implications
Caregiver infant interactions
What have research finding suggested
Mothers should delay return to work could have economic implications
Maternity cover needed mother not receiving wage spending less in local economy etc
Schaffer and Emerson key study
what was the aim
investigate process of how early developments formed
investigate whether there was a distinct pattern of formation common to all infants
identify and describe distinct stages by which attachments form
Schaffer and Emerson key study
what was the length
longitudinal study
Schaffer and Emerson key study
what was the sample
60 new born babies from working class area of Glasgow
Schaffer and Emerson key study
what did they do
babies and mothers visited at home every month for first year and again at 18 months
observations and interviews conducted
question about whom infants smiled at responded to and who caused distress etc
attachment measured in two ways
Schaffer and Emerson key study
what were the two ways to measure attachment
separation protest
stranger anxiety
Schaffer and Emerson key study what was the separation protest way of measuring attachment
assessed through several everyday situation eg infant left alone in room, outside shops etc
Schaffer and Emerson key study
what was the stranger anxiety way of measuring attachment
assessed by researcher starting each home visit by approaching the infant to see if this distressed them
Schaffer and Emerson key study findings
when did most infants start to show separation protest when parted from their attachment figure
6-8 monthss
Schaffer and Emerson key study findings when did stranger anxiety start to show
about a month after started to shown separation protest
Schaffer and Emerson key study findings
what did strongly attached infants have
mothers who responded ton their needs quickly and gave more opportunities for interaction
Schaffer and Emerson key study findings
what did weekly attached infants have
mothers who responded less quickly and gave fewer opportunities for interaction
Schaffer and Emerson key study findings
when did most infants go on to develop multiple attachments
at 18 months around 87% has atleast two attachments
Schaffer and Emerson key study findings
how many infants prime attachment wasn’t main carer
39%
Schaffer and Emerson key study
what is conclusion
pattern of attachment formation common to all infants suggest process is biologically formed
Schaffer and Emerson key study
what was concluded about how easily attachments made
more easily made wit those who display sensitive responsiveness rather than those spending the most time with child
Schaffer and Emerson key study conclusion for multiple attachments
norm and of similar quantity
Schaffer and Emerson key study
what did Schaffer suggest
nothing to suggest nothing can be shared by several people
Schaffer and Emerson key study AO3
3 evaluation points
generalisability
validity
reliability
Schaffer and Emerson key study AO3
what was good for sample
size of 60 babes and carers was good as large volume of data on each participant
Schaffer and Emerson key study AO3
what is limitation of the sample
all families were from the same district and social class in the same city at a time over 50 years ago
Schaffer and Emerson key study AO3
what are cultural and historical significance
child rearing practices vary from one culture to another and one historic period to another
Schaffer and Emerson key study AO3
why is this a limitation
results doen generalise
Schaffer and Emerson key study AO3
how was the data collected
by direct observation or self report from mother
Schaffer and Emerson key study AO3]what is bad about these sources of data collection
prone to bias and inaccuracy
Schaffer and Emerson key study AO3
what is a strength of study
mundane realsim
Schaffer and Emerson key study AO3
how does it have mundane realism
was conducted under everyday conditions in the families own home doing ordinary activities
Schaffer and Emerson key study AO3
how does the behauoruf of babies affect
unlikely to be affected by presence of observers
Schaffer and Emerson key study AO3
what does this mean for conclusions
drawn about formation of attachments can be seen as having high external valdity
Schaffer and Emerson key study AO3
comment on reliability
large individual differences in when attachments formed
casts doubts on processs of attachment formation being exclusively biological
stages of attachment development
what are they based off
information gathered on developing attachments by Emerson and Schaffer
stages of attachment development
what are stages called
preattachment stage /asocial
indiscriminate attachment
specific attachment
multiple attachment
stages of attachment development
when is preattachment stage
0-3 months
stages of attachment development
what happens in preattchmanet stage
baby learns to separate people from objects
from 6 weeks baby prefers humans over objects
stages of attachment development
how is this demonstrated
smiling at peoples faces
doesn’t have any string preferences about who cares for it
stages of attachment development
when is the indiscriminate attachment
3-8 months
stages of attachment development
what happens in indiscriminate attachment
baby display more observable social behaviour and begin to discriminate between familiar and unfamiliar people smile at known
stages of attachment development
do babies shown separation anxiety or stranger anxiety in indiscriminate attachment
not usually still accept comfort from any adult
stages of attachment development
why is behaviour therefore indiscriminate
not different towards any one person
stages of attachment development
when is specific attachment
8 months onwards
stages of attachment development
what happens in specific attachment
stay close to particular people, become distressed when separated from them and happy when they return
stages of attachment development
do babies show stranger anxiety in specific attachment
avoid unfamiliar people and protest if strangers try to handle them
stages of attachment development
what is the adult that the baby has formed a specific attachment to called
primary attachment figure
stages of attachment development
who is the primary attachment figure
adult who offers ,most interaction and responds to baby’s signal
stages of attachment development
when is multiple attachments
9 months onwards
stages of attachment development
what happens in multiple attachments
infant extends attachment behaviour to multiple attachments with other adults with whom they regularly spend time with
stages of attachment development
what are secondary attachments
strong emotional ties with other major care givers but not primary ones
stages of attachment development
what might be true of different attachments
have different functions and strengths
stages of attachment development
is there a limit for number of attachments
no
stages of attachment development
which attachment is strongest
mother figure
stages of attachment development AO3
4 weaknesses
problems with studying asocial stage
conflicting evidence on multiple attachments
problems with studying multiple attachments
behavioural measure of attachment may be too simplistic
stages of attachment development AO3
what is the problem with babies at asocial stage age
have poor coordination and are immobile
stages of attachment development AO3
why odes this make it difficult to study
difficult to make any judgements about them based on observation of behaviour as not much observable behaviour
stages of attachment development AO3
what does this mean for studying this age
Childs feeling or cognitions are not highy social and evidence cannot be relied on
stages of attachment development AO3
what is conflicting about ,multiple attachments
clear that children become capable of forming multiple attachments but is unclear when
stages of attachment development AO3
what does some research indicate for multiple attachments
most babies form attachments t a single carer before forming multiple attachments
stages of attachment development AO3
what is said non research in collectivist cultures
where multiple caregivers is the norms suggests that Abbie’s can form multiple attachments from the onset
stages of attachment development AO3
why is this a problem
theories cannot and generalised to all may be cultural relativism
stages of attachment development AO3why is it hard to asses mulitple attachment
just because baby gets distressed when an individual leaves the room doesnt necessarily mean that an individual is a true attachment figure
children have playmates swell as attachment figures which may lead to distress if they leave
stages of attachment development AO3
why is this a problem
doesnt signfy attachment
can’t distinguish between behaviour shown towards secondary attachment fingers and play mates
stages of attachment development AO3
how was Schaffer and Emerson able to carry out scientific study of attachment
because used simple behaviours
stages of attachment development AO3
what simple behaviours did emmerson ad Schaffer use to measure attachment
stranger anxiety and separation anxiety
stages of attachment development AO3
what do some critics say od these behaviour as a measurement
too crude and may be other factors and behaviours which they should’ve taken into account
stages of attachment development AO3
why is this a limitation
questions validity of stages whether they truly measure attachment
Role of father
traditionally how have children been raised in past
father playing minor role in parenting
children raised by married couples with working fathers
Role of father
how has society changed
now norm for mothers to have job
men now having bigger role in parenting then before
Role of father
what did bowlby believe
children have one primary attachment figure usually mother but could be father
Role of father
how have many researchers seen the role of father
as less of a caregiver ands more of a playmate fathers often more exciting unpredictable and physical than mothers
Role of father
what happens when mother cannot be main care giver
develop ability to have sensitive responsiveness and be nurturing
suggested when father take on role of main care giver the adopt behaviours more typical of mothers
Role of father]what did emmerson and Schaffer find
majority of babies become attached to mother first around. 7 months
few week or months after form secondary attachments eg to father
Role of father
how many infants form an attachment to father by 18 months
75%
Role of father
what was this shown by
infants protesting when father walked away
Role of father
what three factors gave been identifies to affect relationship between fathers and children
degree of sensitivity
marital intimacy
supportive coparenting
Role of father
what is degree if sensitivity
more secure attachments found when fathers show more sensitivity to children’s needs
Role of father
what is marital intimacy
degree of intimacy a father has within his relationship with his partner affects the type if attachment he will have with his children
Role of father
what is supportive coparenting
amount of support a father gives his partner to care for children affects type of attachment he will have with his children
Role of father AO3
2 strengths
research support
positive influence
Role of father AO3
what is the research support
grossman
Role of father AO3what did Grossman find
fathers as secondary attachment figures had an important role in Childs development
quality of the fathers play was related to the quality of adolescent attachments
Role of father AO3
what does this suggest
fathers have a different role in attachment to do with play and stimulation rather than nurturing
Role of father AO3
what do children with secure attachments to fathers go on to do
have better relationships with peers less problem behaviour and are able to regulate emotions
Role of father AO3
what does this illustrate
positive influence fathers can have on developmental outcomes
Role of father AO3
weaknesses
inconsistent findings on fathers
Role of father AO3
why is research in this area confusing
researchers interested in different questions
Role of father AO3
what are some interested in
understanding role of father as secondary attachment figures and tend to see fathers behaving differently from mothers and having a distinct role
others are concerned with the father as a primary attachment figure
Role of father AO3
what has been found about fathers as primary attachment figure
can take on maternal role
Role of father AO3
why is this a problem
cannot simply answer what the role is
Animal studies
why are some studes done on animals
for ethics or pracitcal reasons
Animal studies
why are animal studies more practical
animals breed faster and researcher are interested in seeing results across more than one generation of animals
Animal studies
why can animal studies be done
bassi that there was a biological continuity between humans and animals
Animal studies
what have researchers been interested in
relationship between infant animals and their mothers
Animal studies
what two do need to know
Lorenz
harlow
Lorenz
what animal did Lorenz study
greylag goose
Lorenz
what is imprinting
form of attachment where bird species that are mobile from birth attach to and follow the first morning object they see
Lorenz
what is the critical period
when imprinting needs t take place
what happens if imprinting does not happen in critical period
chicks would not attach themselves to a mother figure
Lorenz
what was the aim
to investigate the mechanisms of imprinting where the youngsters follow and form an attachment to the first large moving object that they meet
Lorenz
what was the procedure
- Lorenz split a clutch of greylag goos eggs into two batches, one of which was hatched naturally by the mother and the other were hatched in an incubator with lorenzbeing first large moving object they see and recorded following behaviour
- Lorenz marked all gosling and placed them under upturned box, then removed box and recorded following behaviour
Lorenz
what was found immediately after birth
naturally hatched baby goslings followed their mother about whereas incubator hatched goslings followed Lorenz
Lorenz
what was found when released from upturned box
naturally hatched gosling went straight to mother and incubator hatchlings went to Lorenz showing no bond with natural mother
Lorenz
what was found for attachment bond
found to be irreversible
Lorenz
when did Lorenz note imprinting would only occur
between 4 and 25 hours
Lorenz
what would happened to the goslings that imprinted onto humans in the future
would attempt to mate to humans
Lorenz
what conclusion was made
imprinting is a form of attachment exhibited mainly by nidifugous birds whereby close contact is kept with first large moving object encountered
Lorenz AO3
2 weaknesses
generalisability to humans
some of lorenz observations have been questioned
Lorenz AO3
what was Lorenz interested in
imprinting in birds
Lorenz AO3
what have some of his founding influenced
understanding of human development
Lorenz AO3
why is there a problem generalising from birds to humans
seems mammals attachment
system is quite different from birds
Lorenz AO3
different between attachment in mammals and birds
mammalian mother show more of an emotional attachment to young than birds
mammals may also be able to form attachments at any time
Lorenz AO3
why is this bad
therefore not appropriate too generalise Lorenz ideas to humans
Lorenz AO3
what of Lorenz conclusions have been questioned
idea that imprinting has a permanent effect of mating behaviour
Lorenz AO3
research for this
guiton et al
Lorenz AO3
what did guiton et al find
chickens imprinting on yellow washing up gloves would try to mate with them as adults as predicted by Lorenz but with experience eventually learned to prefer mating to chickens
Lorenz AO3
what does this suggest
impact of imprinting on mating behaviour is not as permanent as Lorenz believed
Lorenz AO3
other evaluation point
reliablitiy
Lorenz AO3
what is good
has been replicated by other researchers which shows relioabilyt
Lorenz AO3
what have other researchers suggested
that critical period was not as fixed as Lorenz suggested
Lorenz AO3
what suggested this
duckling were kept in isolation were able to imprint after the suggested critical period
Lorenz AO3
what have others also suggested
imprinting is reversible with birds being able to return to their own species if introduced slowly
Harlow study
What animal did Harlow use
Rhesus monkeys
Harlow study
What was Harlow trying to see
Is attachments are primarily formed through food as explained by learning theory
Harlow study
What was the aim
To investigate learning theory by comparing attachment behaviour in baby monkeys given a wire surrogate mother producing milk with those given a soft towelling mother producing no milk
Harlow study
What was the procedure
- Two types of surrogate mother produced, harsh wire mother and soft towelling mother
Sixteen baby monkeys split into four conditions - Amount of time spent with each mother as well as feeding times recorded
- Monkeys were frightened by loud noise to test for mother preference during stress
- Larger cage was also used to test the monkeys degree of exploration
Harlow study
What were the 4 conditions
-cage containing wire mother producing milk and towelling mother no milk
-cage containing wire mother no milk and towelling mother producing milk
Harlow study
What were the findings for contact
Preferred contact with towelling mother when given choice regardless of whether she produced milk even stretched across to wire mother to feed whilst still clinging to towelling mother
Harlow study
Which were found to have signs of stress
Monkeys with only a wire surrogate had diarrhoea a sign of stress
Harlow study
What was found when frightened by a large noise
Monkeys clung to towelling ,mother in conditions where she was available
Harlow study
What was found in the larger cage conditions
Monkeys with towelling mother explained more and visited their surrogate mother more often
Harlow study
What was the conclusions
Rhesus monkeys have innate unlearned need for contact conform suggesting that attachment concerns emotional security more then food
Contact comfort is associated with lower levels of stress and a willingness to explore indicating emotional security
Harlow study
What critical period was found
Mother figure had to be introduced to an infant monkey within 90 days for attachment to form
Harlow study
What would happen if no attachment made in critical period
Attachment was impossible and damage done by early deprivation was irreversible
Harlow study
How did find consequences
Followed the monkeys who had been deprived of a real mother into adulthood
Harlow study
Which monkeys were found to be the most dysfunctional
Monkeys reared with wire mothers
Harlow study
What did maternally deprived monkey acts like as adults
More aggressive, less sociable , bred less often, unskilled at mating and as mother some neglected attacked and even killed their young
Harlow study AO3
2 strengths
Theoretical value
Practical value
Harlow study AO3
What jabbed the findings had an effect on
Psychologists understanding of human,an mother infant attachment
Harlow study AO3
What did Harlow show
Attachment doesn’t develop as a result of being fed by mother figure but from contact comfort
Harlow study AO3
Why is this a strength
Showed importance of the quality of early relationships for later social development including ability to hold down relationship and successfully raise children
Harlow study AO3
What has insight into attachment from Harlow research had
Important practical applications in a range of contexts
Harlow study AO3
What has it helped social workers to understand
Risk factors in child neglect and abuse and allow intervention to prevent it
Harlow study AO3
Why is this important in care of captive monkeys
Understand the importance for proper attachment figures for baby moneys in zoos and breeding programmes in the wild
Harlow study AO3
Comparisons of generalisability to Lorenz
Monkeys are much more similar to humans than Lorenz geese
Harlow study AO3
What do psychologists disagree on
Extent to which studied of non human primates can be generalised to humans
Harlow study AO3
What may be diffferent in attachment between humans and monkeys
Many other factors such as more complex emotions and parents life or situation
Harlow study AO3
Why is this a limitation
May be inappropriate to generalise findings of monkeys to humans
Harlow study AO3
Why is there severe criticism for ethics
Monkeys suffered greatly as a result of harlows procedures
Harlow study AO3
Comparison for generalisations l
Species considered similar enough to humans to be able to generalise the findings which mean as there suffering was presumably quite human like
Harlow study AO3
Was Harlow aware of suffering
Yes he referred to wire others as iron maidens which are medieval torture devices
Harlow study AO3
What is the counter argument
Research was sufficiently important to justify effects
Ainsworths strange situation
what was the aim
to be able to observe key attachment behaviours as a means of assessing the quality of a Childs attachment to a care giver
Ainsworths strange situation
what was it created to make sense of
collected earlier by ainsworth and to create a valid method to measure attachment
Ainsworths strange situation
how old were the infants being assessed
9-18 months
Ainsworths strange situation
what was videotaped
every aspect of behaviour being observed
Ainsworths strange situation
how many infants were observed
106
Ainsworths strange situation
what was the testing room
lab situation was unfamiliar (strange )
Ainsworths strange situation
what type of research method was it
controlled observation
Ainsworths strange situation
what type of behaviour sampling was used
time sampling
Ainsworths strange situation
how was time sampling used
every 15 second category of behaviour displayed was recorded and scored on an intensity
Ainsworths strange situation
what was it designed to measure
security of attachment a child displays toward a caregiver
Ainsworths strange situation
how did psychologists observe behaviour
two way mirror
Ainsworths strange situation
what behavioural categories were used to judge attachments
proximity seeking
exploration and secure base behaviour
stranger anxiety
separation anxiety
response to reunion
Ainsworths strange situation
proximity seeking as a behavioural category
infant with good attachment will stay fairly close to caregiver
Ainsworths strange situation
exploration and secure base behaviour as a behavioural category
goos attachent enables child to feel confident to explore, using caregiver as a secure base
Ainsworths strange situation
stranger anxiety as a behavioural category
one of sings of becoming closely attached is display of anxiety when stranger approaches
Ainsworths strange situation
separation anxiety as behavioural category
another sign of becoming attached is to protest at separation from caregiver