Issues And Debates Flashcards
Free will and determinism
What does free will suggest
As human beings we are essentially self determining and free to choose our thoughts and actions
Free will and determinism
What doesn’t free will deny
There may be biological or environmental forces that’s may influence our behaviour but we are able to reject these forces as masters of our own destiny
Free will and determinism
Which approach advocates free will
Humanistic
Free will and determinism
What is determinism
View that an individuals behaviour is shaped or controlled by internal or external forces rather than an individuals will to do something
Free will and determinism
What are the 5 types of determinism
Hard
Soft
Biological
Environmental
Psychic
Free will and determinism
What does hard determinism suggest
All human behaviour has a cause and in principe it should be possible to identify these causes and implied free will is not possible
Free will and determinism
What us hard determinism comparable with
Aims of science to uncover causal laws that govern thoughts and actions
Free will and determinism
What does hard determinism assume
Everything we think and do is dictated by internal or ext3rnal forces we cannot control
Free will and determinism
What is the problem about hard determinism for some people
Too extreme
Free will and determinism
What approach can be seen as hard determinism
Behaviourist
Free will and determinism
What’s soft determinism
Acknowledges that all human action has a cause but there’s some room for manoeuvre
People have the conscious mental control over way they believe
Free will and determinism
What approaches is soft determinism
Cognitive
Social learning theory
Free will and determinism
What is biological determinism
Behaviours and characteristics thought to have physiological or neurological basis due to processes which are not under conscious control
Free will and determinism
What approach has biological determinism
Biological
Free will and determinism
What is environmental determinism
Behaviour caused by features of environment and agents of socialisation
Experience of choice merely sum total of reinforcement contingencies that have acted upon us although think were acting independently
Free will and determinism
Which approach has environmental determinism
Behaviourism
Free will and determinism
What is psychic determinism
Sees human behaviour as determined an directed by unconscious conflicts we cannot control
Drives and instincts
Free will and determinism
Which approach has psychic determinism
Psychodynamic
Free will and determinism
What it’s important about determinism for science
Scientific emphasis on causal explantions
Free will and determinism
What is needed examine a psychological phenomenon a psychologist must do what?
Develop theory followed by a prediction of what might happen (hypothesis )
Use empirical methods top test hypothesis
If significant, considered to indicate that there’s causal explanation
Free will and determinism
How can causal factors be proved
If one factor changes a a behaviour in an experiment when all other factors a are controlled then the original factor must be responsible for the change
Free will and determinism
When can causation be established
If research carried out in a scientifically rigorous way
Free will and determinism
How is determinism and causation linked
Behaviour is caused (determined) by something not within the individuals control
Free will and determinism AO3
Strengths for determinism and against free will
Consistent with aims of science
Neurological studies
Free will and determinism AO3
How is it good for science
Notion that human behaviour is orderly and obeys laws places psychology on equal footing with other more established sciences
Free will and determinism AO3
What has prediction and control of human behaviour led too
Development of treatments therapies and behavioural interventions that have benefited many eg to control and manage schizophrenia
Free will and determinism AO3
What casts doubts on concept of free will
Experience of mental disorders like schizophrenia where sufferers experience a total loss of control over their thoughts
Free will and determinism AO3
Why is this a strength
In terms on mental illness behaviour would appear to be determined by
Free will and determinism AO3
What are the neurological studies of and what have they revealed evidence of
Decision making
Evidence Against free will
Free will and determinism AO3
Which study
Chun Siong soon et al
Free will and determinism AO3
What did chun siong soon et al demonstrate
That brain activity that determines the outcome of simple choices, may predate our knowledge of having made such a choice
Free will and determinism AO3
What have researchers found
Activity related to whether to press a button with left or right hand occurs in brain up to ten second as before participants report being consciously aware of making a decision
Free will and determinism AO3
What does this show
Even our most basic experiences of free will are decided and determined by our brain before we become aware of them
Free will and determinism AO3
Case for freewill an. Against determinism
Hard determinist stance not consistent with how legal system operates
Research support
Free will and determinism AO3
What would happen in court of law
Offenders held morally accountable for actions
Free will and determinism AO3
What would hard determinists argue
Individual choice is not the cause of behaviour
Free will and determinism AO3
How is determinism unfalsifiable
Based on idea that causes of behaviour will always exist even though may not have been found wrong so impossible to prove wrong
Free will and determinism AO3
What does this suggest
Determinist approach to human behaviour may not be seen as scientific as it first appears
Free will and determinism AO3
Research support opener
Everyday experiences gives the impression that we are constantly excercising free will through the choices we make on any given day
Gives face value,iditly to compete of free will
Free will and determinism AO3
What does research suggest
People who have internal locus of control believing that they have a high degree of influence over events and their own behaviour tend got be more mentally healthy
Free will and determinism AO3
Research example
Robert et al
Free will and determinism AO3
What did Robert et al find
That adolescents with a strong belief in hard determinism, who thought their lives were decided by events outside of their control were significantly at a greater risk to develop depression
Free will and determinism AO3
What did this suggest
That even f we don’t have free will the fact that we think we do may have a positive impact of mind and behaviour
Free will and determinism AO3
What us the interactionist positions for determinism
Soft determinism
Free will and determinism AO3
What us the interactionist positions
May provide us with best compromise in free will determinism debate
Free will and determinism AO3
Idiographic and nomothetic
What does idiographic mean
Attempts to describe nature of individual
Idiographic and nomothetic
How are people studied in idiographic research
As unique identities each with subjective experiences motivations and values
Idiographic and nomothetic
What data is asssociated with idiographic
Qualitative
Idiographic and nomothetic
What research methods would be used in idiographic
Case studies unstructured interviews and pother self report methods
Idiographic and nomothetic
Sample size in idiographic research
Very small, 1 or two people
Idiographic and nomothetic
What is idiographic research central aim
Describe richness of human experience and gain insight into persons unique was of viewing world
Idiographic and nomothetic
What approach show idiographic research
Humanism
Psychodynamic
Idiographic and nomothetic
Why is humanism idiographic
Roger and Maslow only interested in documenting conscious experience of individual and rather than scientifically more interested with investigating unique experiences
Idiographic and nomothetic
Why is psychodynamic approach often labbeled as idiographic
Use of case study method when detailing lives of his patients however Freud assumed he had identified universal laws of behaviour
Idiographic and nomothetic
What is the main aim of nomothetic research
Produce general laws of human behaviours and provide benchmark against which people can be compared classified and measured
Idiographic and nomothetic
What can be done as a result of general laws for behaviour from nomothetic research
Future behaviour can be predicted controlled or treated
Idiographic and nomothetic
What data type is associated with nomethiec research
Quantitative
Idiographic and nomothetic
Sample size for nomothetic research
Large numbers of people in order to establish way in which people are similar or differ
Idiographic and nomothetic
Research methods for nomethic
Scientific methods eg experiment or controlled observation
Idiographic and nomothetic
Nomothetic research tends to be a feature of those approaches that are what
Reductionist determinist and employ scientific method as of investigation
Idiographic and nomothetic
What is don’t to make nomethic research scientific
Hypothesis formulated tested under controlled conditions and finding generated from large numbers of people or animals and tested for statistical significance
Idiographic and nomothetic
What approaches are nomethics
Behavioursim
cognitive
Biological
Idiographic and nomothetic
How is behaviourism nomothetic
Skinner and behaviourists studied responses of hundreds of rates cats and pigeons etc in order to develop laws of learning
Idiographic and nomothetic
How is the cognitive approach nomothetic
Able to infer the structure and processes of human memory be measure in the performeance of large sample of people in lab tests
Idiographic and nomothetic
How is the biological approach nomothetic
Conducted brain scans on countless human brains to make generalisations about localisation of funtion
Idiographic and nomothetic
2 for idiographic approach and against nomothetic
In-depth rich detail data
Loses whole person
Idiographic and nomothetic
What a data does idiographic produce
Through qualitative methods provides complete global account of individual
Idiographic and nomothetic
How does this complement the nomothetic approach approach
By shedding further Light on general laws or indeed by challenging such laws
Idiographic and nomothetic
What might a single case generate
Hypothesis for further study
Idiographic and nomothetic
Example for brai damaged individuals
Findings may reveal important insights about normal functioning which may contribute to overall understanding of
Idiographic and nomothetic
Why has nomethetic appprach been accused of losing the whole person
Preoccupation on general laws prediction and control
Idiographic and nomothetic
Example for schizophrenia
Knowing 1% lifetime risk of developing schizophrenia tells us little about what life is like for someone who is suffering from the disorder
Idiographic and nomothetic
What has happening in lab stdueid
Participants treated as a series of scores or results rather than individual so subjective experience of situation is ignored
Eg tests of memory
Idiographic and nomothetic
Why is this a weakness for nomothetic
In search for generalities may sometimes overlook richness of human experience
Idiographic and nomothetic
2 for nomethic approach and against idiographic
Nomethic More scientific
Idiographic rearch more narrow and restricted
Idiographic and nomothetic
How is nomethic more scientific
Mirrors those employed under natural sciences testing under standardised conditions using data sets that provide group averages statistical analyssis prediction and control
Idiographic and nomothetic
What have scientific processes enabled psychologists to do
Establish norms of typical behaviour arguably giving discipline of psychology greater scientific credibility
Idiographic and nomothetic
What do supporters of idiographic approach have to recognise
Narrow and restricted nature of their work
Idiographic and nomothetic
What is one of the criticisms of Freud
That many of his key concepts such as Oedipus comple were largely developed from detailed study of a single case eg little hans
Idiographic and nomothetic
What is implications of using a single case
Meaningful generalisations cannot be made without further examples as no adequate baseline to compare bejabvioru
Idiographic and nomothetic
Why is unscientific nature of methods used in idiographic bad
Conclusions rely not subjective interpretation of researcher leading to bias
Idiographic and nomothetic
What is the interaction between them
Rather then seeing them as mutually exclusive alternatives is possible to consider same issue or topic from both perspectives depending on nature of research
Idiographic and nomothetic
Example of research into gender development for interaction
Attempts to establish general patterns of behaviour sitting along side case studied of atypical development
Holism and reductionism
What is Holism
Advocates to look at whole person rather than one specific part to explain behaviour
Holism and reductionism
What is the view of Holism
Any attempts to break up behaviour and experience is inappropriate as these can only be understood by analysing person or behaviour as a whole
Holism and reductionism
Why does Holism not believe in reductionism
Don’t deny influence of genetics or biochemistry but feeel human behaviour is far more complex so is necessary to take a step back from the detail and consider the person from a less reductionist level
Holism and reductionism
What approach advocates Holism
Humanistic psychologists who saw successful therapy as bringing all aspects fo the whol reason
Holism and reductionism
What levels of explantion does Holism draw on
Higher levels such as social groups and cognition as social context is important in terms of influence
Holism and reductionism
What is reductionism
Belief that human behaviour s best explained by breaking it down into smaller constituent parts
Holism and reductionismw
When is a behaviour reductionist
When a single explantion or cause is suggested
Holism and reductionism
What are the types of reductionism
Biological
Environmental
Holism and reductionism
What is biological reductionism
Attempts to explain behaviour using biological systems eg genetics physiology of body or brain or biochemistry
Holism and reductionism
Why is it called biological reductionism
In terms of levels of explaintion it is as reductionism as psychology goes
Holism and reductionism
What does biological determinism not take into account
Higher levels of explanation such as leaned associations and influence of other pope
Holism and reductionism
What is environmental reductionism
Simplifies behaviour to stimulus response action ‘leaned associations’
Holism and reductionism
Who is environmental reductionism advocated by
Behaviourist theorists
Holism and reductionism
What is an example for explantion of environmental reductionism
Classical Conditioning
Holism and reductionism
What are levels of explantion
Suggests there are different ways of viewing the same behaviour some more reductionist then others
Holism and reductionism
What are the lower levels of explantions
More reductionist and fundamental
Holism and reductionism
What are higher levels of explantion
More holistic multivariable
Holism and reductionism
Example of low levels of explantions
Biochemistry
Cellular biology
Holism and reductionism
Example of middle levels of explantion.
Cognitions and emotions
Leaned associations
Holism and reductionism
Example of higher levels of explantions
Social cognition
Social groups,family etc
Holism and reductionism
What can different about the levels of explantion
Amount of research evidence to support suggestion
Holism and reductionism
What is best way to apply levels of explanation
No one explanation in isolation can be taken as correct and therefore several explanations at several levels would be more appropriate
Holism and reductionism AO3
Strength for reductionism
Often forms basis of scientific research
Holism and reductionism AO3
Why does reductionism for basis of scientiifc research
In order to create operationalised variables its necessary to break target behaviours down into constituent part to make it possible to conduct experiments or record observations in a wat which is meaningful and reliable
Holism and reductionism AO3
How does the behaviourist approach demonstrate this
How complex learning can be broken down to simple stimulus response links within the lab