April 4 Flashcards
What did Serpell (1986) point out?
“While developing affectionate relationships with companion animals is natural and universal… humans are also motivated to use and kill animals”
What are the 3 groups categorized by animal-human interactions
- Companion animals
- Wild animals
- Utility animals
What are the goals of animal welfare legislation?
Reflect ethical concerns of society; protect animals from cruelty/treatment that is detrimental to their welfare
Why legal protection for animals?
- Sentience
- Animal protection is a right
- Promotes positive human behaviour
Examples of supranational agreements
- European union treaties
- World trade organization rules
Purpose of a law (7)
- Protecting species/environment
- Banning activities
- Prohibiting cruelty
- Controlling methods of production
- Improving animal welfare
- Protecting or improving public health
- Improving animal health
Examples of international wild animals legislation
- CITES (convention of international trade in endangered species 1975)
- International convention for the regulation of whaling (1946)
- convention on migratory species (1983)
World Organization for Animal Health (OIE)
Fight animal disease at a global level; improving health worldwide (180 member countries)
World Trade Organization (WTO) rules on animal welfare
- Legally binding trade agreement - encourages free international trade
- Products must be treated equally whether imported or locally produced
(ex. ban use of battery cages but cannot restrict import of eggs from batter cages)
Timeline of European Animal Welfare Legislation
1952: European Union establishes
1958: Treaty of Rome (no agreements on animal welfare)
1999: Treaty of Amsterdam (protocol on protection and welfare of animals; first time animals regarded as having feelings, can suffer)
2009: Treaty of Lisbon (animals are sentient beings)
3 federal laws that apply to welfare of food animals in Canada
- Health of Animals Act
- Meat Inspection Act
- Criminal Code (not husbandry practices)
How to differentiate science and religion?
Science = natural world
Religion = natural and supernatural
Christian views on animal care
- Humans superior
- Changing to “stewardship”
- Avoid cruelty and treat with kindness, but not sacred, no significant right to life, can be used for human benefit
- Thomas Acquinas
Islam attitudes towards animal care
- Superior to animals but…
- Animals should not be treated badly for hunting pleasure, animal fighting or act unnaturally
- Only kill when necessary
Promotes kindness for living creatures