Abnormal Flashcards
Reliability & Validity of diagnoses
Rosenhan 1973
Lipton & Simon 1985
Rosenhan (1973) Aim
To determine psychiatry hospital’s ability to detect sanity
Rosenhan (1973) Experiment
Naturalistic Observational Study
Rosenhan (1973) Participants
- 8 sane people
- 3 psychologists, 2 doctors
Rosenhan (1937) Method
- each participant called various psychiatric hospitals
- they claimed they were hearing voice with negative commands
- they answered every question honestly except name and address
- once admitted to hospital they stopped their ‘symptoms’ acting normal/sane
Rosenhan (1973) Results
- all admitted to hospital
- 7 diagnosed SZ, 1 bipolar
- never discovered
- all classified as “in remission” not sane
- oral acquisitive syndrome
- average 19 days stay 7-52 range
- over 70% of psychiatrists & nurses ignored the participants when asked for request
Lipton & Simon (1985) Aim
- investigate reliability of diagnoses
Lipton & Simon (1985) Participants & Experiment
- 131 PATIENTS
- 7 external clinicians to reevaluate their diagnoses
- field experiment
Lipton & Simon (1985) Method
- 7 clinicians re-evaluated and diagnosed the patients from a different psychiatric hospital to determine the reliability
Lipton & Simon (1985) Results
- only 18% of patients originally had SZ had been re-diagnosed
- 50 patients diagnosed w/ mood disorder after reevaluation
- only 15 had originally received a mood disorder prior
DSM-I year & characteristics
- 1952
- based on psychoanalytic traditions
- finding causes to abnormal behaviour (reliant on interpretation)
DSM-II year & characteristics
- 1968
- still heavily psychoanalytical
- but moving towards objectivity
- pre Rosenhan (1973)
DSM-III year & characteristics
- 1980
- post Rosenhan
- shift towards objectivity
- describing psychological disorders through observable symptoms
- hardcore medical and biological approach to classifying mental illness through ‘medical checklist’
- 265 disorders
DSM-IV year & characteristics
-1994
- post Lipton&Simon
- reduce overdiagnosis from prior DSM
- included clinical significance criteria
DSM & Homosexuality
- disorder from 1952-1973
- quietly removed
- psychological disorders are cultural deviations
- DSM is ethnocentric social norms
- pathologising deviant behaviour as mental illnesses
DSM Expansion
- ADD in 1980
- ADHD in 1987
- to include women
- expansion NOT born from observed and unaccounted abnormality
- further diagnoses otherwise ‘normal’
people - invalid diagnoses of mental abnormality
ICD , countries , publisher , full name
- international classifications of diseases
- world health organisation
- europe
DSM , countries , publisher , full name
- diagnostic and statistical manual
- American Psychiatric Association
- USA, UK, Australia
CCMD , countries , publisher , full name
- chinese classification of mental disorders
- china
Purpose of classification systems
- reliable & valid method of diagnosing psychological disorders
- range of psychiatrists arrive at the same diagnosis with same symptoms
- minimising cultural, clinical, biases & subjectivity
- psychological experience of patient corresponds to diagnosis received