A8 PRINCIPLES OF HEALTH & SAFETY LAW Flashcards
8.1 SOURCES OF LAW
1
8.1 COMMON LAW: NATURE AND DEVELOPMENT, JUDUCUAL PRECENDENT
What established the common law duties of employers?
Principally Wilsons & Clyde Coal Company Ltd v English 1938.
8.1 STATUTE LAE: EUROPEAN DIRECTIVES AND REGULATIONS, UK ACTS OF PARLIAMENT AND REGULATIONS. PRESCRIPTIVE AND GOAL SETTING LEGISTLATION
1
8.1 TYPES OF LAW
CRIMINAL LAW: PURPOSE , SANCTIONS
BURDEN OF PROOF
Remedy sought:
Criminal law:
Punishes through fines or imprisonment.
Criminal law:
Proved guilty beyond reasonable doubt.
8.1 TYPES OF LAW
CIVIL LAW: PURPOSE, TYPES OF REMEDY
BURDEN OF PROOF
Remedy sought:Civil law:
Seeks restitution for wrong done in the form of damages for losses suffered.
Civil law:
Determined on the balance of probabilities
8.2 ABSOLUTE AND QUALIFIES DUTIES
ABSOLUTE
CASE
Summers (John) & Sons v Frost 1955
Damaged thumb on unguarded grinding machine.
Mr frost was operating a power driven grinding machine when his thumb got trapped between the guard and the grinding wheel. The house of lords ruled breach of statutory duty as machine not guarded.
Details
• Frost injured whilst using grinding wheel
• Factories act imposed absolute duty to guard dangerous parts of machinery
Decision
• Breach of statutory duty
• The duty to provide fencing which absolutely prevented any part of any person coming into contact with dangerous parts
• Absolute must be done
Absolute duty - Breach of statute
Occurs when then risk of injury is so high that injury is inevitable unless safety precautions are taken
‘Must’ and ‘Shall’
It may still be defended using, for example, the argument that ‘all reasonable precautions all all due diligence’ were taken (only The Electricity at Work Regs and The Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regs)
8.2 ABSOLUTE AND QUALIFIES DUTIES
PRACTICABLE
CASE
Adsett v K&L Steelfounders ltd 1953
Details
• Adsett contracted pneumoconiosis from silica dust whilst employed by the dependents
• The employers installed a dust extractor as soon as they thought of it/had knowledge of it after Adsett became ill
• Adsett claimed
• Claim failed as was not known at the time
Must be taken in the light of current knowledge/
technology
Employer must ensure, so far is reasonably practicable, that any control measure is maintained in an efficient state (if the duty is technically possible or feasible then it must be done, irrespective of any difficulty, inconvenience or cost)
8.2 ABSOLUTE AND QUALIFIES DUTIES
REASONABLY PRACTICABLE
CASE
Edwards v National Coal Board 1949
ine legislation required mine owners to take “reasonable practicable” steps to ensure all travelling roads in coal mine were safe.
A section of road roof gave way killing Mr Edwards.
NCB were found liable as cost of making safe was not great when compared to the risk.
(time, trouble or money)
Reasonable. Prac. – risk of accident weighed against measures necessary to eliminate the risk – absolute duty – must prove it was not reasonably practicable
If the risk of injury is very small compared to the cost, time and effort required to reduce the risk , then no action is necessary
It is important to note that money, time and trouble must ‘grossly outweigh’ not balance the risk
Clearly needs a risk assessment
‘suitable and sufficient’
8.3 ROLE OF THE EUROPEAN UNION
INFLUENCE AND ROLE OF THE EUROPEAN UNION
1
8.3 ROLE OF THE EUROPEAN UNION
ITS MAIN INSITUTIONS
HOW THEY AFFECT UK HEALTH AND SAFETY LEGISLATION
1
8.3 ROLE OF THE EUROPEAN UNION THE STATUS AND PROCEDURE FOR THE CREATION OF INSTRUMENT IN EU LAW TREATIES REGULATIONS DIRECTIVES DECISIONS
1
8.3
DIRECTIVES - ROLE OF PARLIAMENT, COUNCIL AND COMMISSION IN THE CO-DECISION PROCEDURE AND THE SIGNIFICANCE OF QUALIFIED MAJORITY VOTING. DISTINCTION BETWEEN DIRECTIVES MADE UNITER ARTICLE 95 AND ARTICLE 137 OF THE TREATY OF ROME. SOURCES OF INFORMATION ON PENDING EU LAW. UK LAW IN RESPONSE TO EU DIRECTIVES
1
8.3
THE ROLE OF THE EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE *ECJ) AND PROCEDURE FOR REFERRING CASES: HOW DESICIONS OF THE ECJ AND ENFORCES THROUGH COURTS OF MEMBER STATES; EFFECT OF DECISIONS OF THE ECJ ON UK LAW
1
8.4 UK ACTS, REGULATIONS AND ORDERS
STATUS AND PROCEDURE FOR MAKING UK ACTS OF PARLIAMENT, REGULATIONS AND ORDERS
1
8.4
ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - THE FUNCTIONS OF GREEN AND WHITE PAPERS, PROGRESSIONOF A BILL THROUGH PARLIAMENT
1