4.1.2 MEMORY Flashcards
who developed the cognitive interview
fisher and geiselman
name the four techniques used in the cognitive interview
report everything
reinstate the context
reverse the order
change the perspective
describe the report everything technique
the interviewer encourages the reporting of every single detail of the event without editing anything, witnesses should not leave anything out, even if they believe it to be insignificant or are not confident about it
describe the reinstate the context technique
mentally recreate the physical and psychological environment of the original incident, the aim is to make memories accessible through contextual and emotional cues
describe the reverse the order technique
events should be recalled in a different order from the original sequence, this is done to prevent expectations and prevents dishonesty
describe the change the perspective technique
witnesses are asked to recall the event from multiple perspectives, eg imagining how it may have appeared to other witnesses or the perpetrator, this is done to disrupt expectations and the effect of our own schema
which cognitive interview techniques apply to retrieval failure
report everything
reinstate the context
which cognitive interview techniques apply to schema
reverse the order
change the perspective
who developed the enhanced cognitive interview
fisher et al
outline the characteristics of the enhanced cognitive interview
eye contact
reducing anxiety
minimise distraction
witness speaking slowly
open ended questions
what is the purpose of the enhanced cognitive interview
to create a friendly relaxed environment which helps establish rapport and ultimately, recall more information
ao3: describe kohnken et al’s meta analysis findings
conducted a meta-analysis of 55 studies to compare the effectiveness with standard police interviews and found the ECI consistently provided more accurate information
ao3: describe kohnken et al’s findings in regards to the quality of the cognitive interview
found an 81% increase in correct information, but also a 61% increase in incorrect information
define anxiety
a state of emotional and physical arousal
what emotions are experienced during anxiety
worried thoughts, feelings of tension, increased heart rate, sweatiness
outline johnson and scott’s procedure
participants believed they were taking part in a lab study
low anxiety - overheard casual conversation, man walked out holding pen with greasy hands
high anxiety - overheard a heated argument, man walked out holding a knife with bloody hands
participants were asked to pick man out from a set of photographs
outline johnson and scott’s findings
low anxiety - 49% accurately chose
high anxiety - 33% accurately chose
outline the conclusion made from johnson and scott’s study
tunnel theory = enhanced memory for central events due to weapon focus.
outline yuille and cutshall’s procedure
study of a real life shooting in vancouver
shop owner shot a thief dead
21 witnesses - 13 took part in the study
interview 4-5 months after the incident and were compared with original police interviews
asked to rate how stressed they felt at the time of the incident
outline yuille and cutshall’s findings
witnesses were very accurate and there was little change in accuracy
some details such as age and height were less accurate
participants reporting high stress : 88% accurate
participants reporting low stress : 75% accurate
outline the work of deffenbacher
reviewed 21 studies of eye-witness testimony and noted contradictory findings, using the yerkes-dodson law
outline the yerkes dodson law
fight or flight - increased alertness and improved recall - optimal level of anxiety - beyond this, recall suffers drastically
ao3: outline pickels study into weapon focus
used a raw chicken, a handgun, a wallet, or scissors as hand held items in a hairdressing salon video
raw chicken : low anxiety high unusualness
a handgun : high anxiety high unusualness
a wallet : low anxiety low unusualness
scissors : high anxiety high unusualness
ao3 : outline the findings and conclusion of pickels study into weapon focus
eyewitness accuracy was significantly poorer in the high unusualness conditions (chicken and a handgun)
people focus on the weapon because they are surprised by what they see, rather than because they are scared
ao3 : outline christianason and hubinette’s study into the positive role of anxiety
interviewed 58 witnesses to bank robberies in sweden
some witnesses were directly involved (bank workers), some were indirectly involved (bystanders)
ao3 : outline the findings of christianason and hubinette’s study into the positive role of anxiety
recall was more than 75% accurate across all victims
the direct victims were even more accurate
define eyewitness testimony
the ability of the people to remember the details of an event, such as accidents or crimes which they themselves have observed
define misleading information
incorrect information given to the eyewitness usually after the event
name the types of misleading information
leading questions
post event discussion
outline loftus and palmer’s procedure
45 participants watched a video of a car accident and then were asked questions
critical question: about how fast were the cars going when they hit each other
five groups of participants
each group given a different verb for the critical question: hit, contacted, bumped, collided, smashed
outline loftus and palmer’s findings
the mean estimated speed was calculated for each participant group
speed estimates varied significantly
leading questions biased the eyewitness’s recall of the event
name the two reasons leading questions effect eyewitness testimony
response-bias explanation
substitution explanation
describe response-bias explanation
wording has no real effect on the participants memory
participants are encouraged to estimate a higher speed when the word smashed is used
describe the substitution explanation
question alters the participants memory of the event
participants are more likely to recall seeing broken glass when the word smashed is used