3.2 Psychology of foreign policy decision making Flashcards
This model suggests that the individual possesses all the relevant information, stipulates a goal, examines the relevant choices and makes decisions that best achieves the goal.
Rational Model
Are individuals rational decision-makers?
No. They can be overwhelmed with information
What factor impact the decision maker?
Personal experiences
What three steps do the decision maker take when receiving incoming information?
Select, organize and evaluate incoming information
What model is the most typical, common way to understand foreign policy decision-making?
The Rational Actor Model (ALLISON’s Model 1)
What is the Rational actor model based on?
Certain assumptions about the individual psychology of leaders as human beings
Three steps to how a rational leader should take a decision
- Order preferences in a logical way, assesing pros and cons
- Choose the optimal option that maximizes gains and minimizes loss
- Constantly use of reliable information to update preferences
8 steps in the rational decision-making process
- Identify the problem
- Establish decision criteria
- weigh decision criteria
- generate alternatives
- evaluate alternatives
- Choose the best alternative
- Implement the decision
- Evaluate the decision
What is the description of the human rationality according to psychology and neuroscience
limited and imperfect
Three group information-processing mechanisms
- Mirror image
- Satisficing
- Groupthink
The tendency of individuals and groups to see one’s opponent the opposite of characteristics seen in oneself. The opponent is viewed as hostile and uncompromising, while one’s self is viewed as friendly and compromising
Mirror image
Example of mirror image
The cold war: the US was friendly and the Soviets were evil
Today: Western democracies are friendly while Islamic regimes are evil
The tendency for groups to search for a “good enough” solution rather than an optimal one
Satisficing
Example of satisficing
NATOs decision to bomb Kosovo in 1999 in an attempt to stop the ethnic cleansing of the Albanian Kosovars
The tendency for small groups to form a consensus and resist criticism of that core position, often disregarding contradictory information. The dynamics of the group include the illusion of invulnerability and unanimity, excessive optimism, the belief in their own morality.
Groupthink
An example of Groupthink
The opponents of an American attack on Cuba was left out of the planning for the Bay of Pigs operation
What does cognitive psychology say about human rationality?
Human beings do not decide according to a rational model
What is bounded rationality?
- We do not seek the best choice, only one that is sufficient to satisfy us
- We prefer the most practical option: fewer resources, easy to implement, acceptable for everyone involved
Type of person:
- Exhaustively seek the best
- Compare decisions with others
- expend more time and energy
- Unhappier with outcomes
Maximizers
Type of person:
- accept good enough
- Don’t obsess over other options
- Can move on after deciding
- Happier with outcomes
Satisficers
Neuroscience is discovering that many decisions are not the result of a conscious thought process, but…
pre-conscious neurological processes
What are the emotional responses?
- We feel before we think
- We act before we think
- Emotions are quick and relatively inflexible
- Cognition is slower but more flexible
What are the 6 facts that were discovered when FPAs studied leaders’ perceptions and misperceptions of the international environment?
- Leaders get incomplete and inaccurate information
- Signaling: the original meaning of the information is lost when interpreted by the receiver
- Misinformation, propaganda, and deception
- Political culture and strategic culture
- Learning from past events modifies future perceptions
- Violation of norms means an elevation of threat perception from the rest of the members of the international society
What is the security dilemma of a defensive strategy?
A defensive strategy can be perceived as offensive by others
if the leaders of a country break the social contract by not protecting their own population, the population can also break the social contract by overthrowing the government.
Rosseau’s social contract