3 - The role of peers: Should Peers be Considered a Risk or Protective Factor? (L3, Laninga-Wijnen & Veenstra, Prinstein & Giletta) Flashcards
Why are peers important? (Q)
During adolescence:
- More time spend with peers
- Risk behavior often takes place in the company of peers
Assumptions (not direct true!!):
1. Similarity in risk behavior is due to peer influence (bad friends, bad influence)
2. Peer influence is often taking place because peers pressure each other to act in a certain way
3. Peer influence is one of the most important predictors of adolescent behavior
Why are adolescents often similar to their peers (e.g., friends) in risk behaviors? (Q)
- Selection effect: tendency to affiliate with similar peers (e.g. gender, age, ethnicity, behavior)
- Influence effect: tendency for peers to become more similar over time
- Multiple social network studies: young individuals become more similar to their friend over time (e.g. aggression, drinking behavior, marijuana use etc)
What type of peer influence is most likely? (Q)
- More evidence for imitation or conforming to popularity norms (probably because of anticipated rewards)
- Moreover, influence is often reciprocal
Type of influence ramains unclear.
Under which conditions is peer influence most likely? (Q)
??
1. More time spend with peers: bad friends-bad influence
? 2. Risk behaviors often take place in the company of peers
What are the four theories about influence in general? (HC)
- Evolutionary theories
- Drastic neurological changes in social brain in adolescence
- Socio-strcutural changes make “fitting in” adaptive because it enhanes compatibility (influence-compatibility model)
- Theory specific for risk behavior: maturity gap and dual taxonomy model
Explain the theory about drastic neurological changes in social brain in adolescence (HC)
Importance of status and affection. Prefrontal is cognitive, more slowly developing. The gap between limbic and prefrontal causes that adolescents have more attention for status than making safe choices.
Explain the theory about sociostructural changes make ”fitting in” adaptive because it enhances compatibility (influence-compatibility model, HC)
Peer interacting becomes more complex during the lifetime. If you have peers around you, its divides savety.
Explain the theory about specific for risk behavior: matury gap - dual taxonomy model (HC)
- Moffit argued that there is gap between biological and social maturity; adolescence are not allowed to do some grown-up stuff like voting. They rebel to the adult things, to show that they aren’t children anymore.
- Driven by the increase in antisocial behaviors (i.e., delinquency) in adolescence
What do newer studies show about peer influence? (HC)
Social network analyses.
- Complete networks are analyzed, control for structural tendencies (classrooms for example)
- Distinguish selection from influence
What are two possible processes that underlie similarity in peers? (HC)
- Selection effects: tendency to affiliate with similar peers (e.g. gender, age, ethnicity, media and leisure preferences, school performance, externalizing behavior, health risk behavior)
- Influence effects: tendency for peers to become more similar over time
Support for both processes.
What is the definition of peer pressure? (HC)
“the explicit verbal encouragement/offering of a substance (e.g., alcohol), accompanied by coercion, teasing, or insulting if the person does not accept the offer”
What are four types of influence? (HC)
- Peer pressure
- Imitation
- Norms
- Mutual reinforcement
What do quantitative studies about peer pressure related to substance use show? (HC)
- Relation ≠ causation
- Peer pressure measure (incidence) is not valid, nor reliable
(questionnaires)
What do qualitative studies about peer pressure related to substance use show? (HC)
- No peer pressure but internal self-pressure?
- Young people indicate that peer pressure is not accompanied by coercion, teasing or bullying/insulting
- But: social desirability?
(interviews)
Explain conscious and unconscious imitation (HC)
- Conscious: because of anticipated reward or sanction (Social Learning Theory). When you observe somebody who is drinking alcohol and having fun, than the adolescent will drink alcohol to have fun.
- Unconscious (Perception-Behaviour Link). Sip rate. People have (almost) the same sip rate when drinking.
What was the most important reason in the ‘smoking in the van’ study why adolescents would smoke? (HC)
Imitation.
What is positive peer pressure? (HC)
Influence towards lower risk behavior if peers discourage it (verbally or nonverbally).
What are Peer norms (HC)
Peer norms reflect a certain level of consensus on what behaviors are expected or typical in a classroom
Which different types of norms do we have? (HC)
- Descriptive norms (what is majority doing, what is common)
- Injunctive norms (what is appropriate, how should one behave?)
- Popularity norms (in particular high-status peer set the norm)
What is the informational social influence and what leads this to? (HC)
??
- Beliefs that the group is better informed
- Need for accuracy
- Leads to private acceptance
Opzoeken of dit klopt.
What is the normative social influence and what leads this to? (HC)
- Desire to fit in, fear of being ridiculed
- Need for social acceptance
- Leads to public compliance
Opzoeken of dit klopt.
What are the results of the meta-analysis study about sexual risk behavior and the different types of norms? (HC)
- Strongest role for descriptive norms, followed by injunctive norms. It was most important that adolescents knew on average what was happening in their peer group.
- Minor role for peer pressure (in sexual activity only), and this role disappeared after controlling for selection
How strong is the effect of peer influence according to Gilletta et al.? (HC)
- Peer influence is consistent and robust predictor of adolescence behavior. Internalizing and externalizing. Did not include social network analysis.
- However, effect size is small. Most longitudinal studies have a big time gap between the metingen. Large heterogeneity.
- Significant heterogeneity
Thus… “perhaps peer influence effects may not be as powerful as researchers have often assumed
What are three individual characteristics that makes peer influence more or less likely? (HC)
- Personality
- Self-control
- Peer status
What does research say about personality and the influence of peers? (HC)
Role of conscientiousness:
- More likely to behave like their friend with low conscientiousness