24: Custodial Sentences Flashcards
Custodial sentences =
1) a sentence of imprisonment,
2) a sentence of detention
3) a sentence of custody for life
4) a sentence of detention in a young offender institution
5) a detention and training order.
Sentence of imprisonment does NOT include
include contempt of court.
Who cannot be sentenced to imprisonment?
Ds under 21 years old
When may a D be committed to prison for a period before his case is disposed of??
if D is under 21 and is:
- remanded in custody
- committed in custody for sentence; or
- sent in custody for trial
He may be committed to prison for a period before his case is disposed of.
Max Custodial sentence = INDICTMENT
2 years. (Doesn’t apply for Common law offences)
Test for Custodial sentence:
“so serious that neither a fine alone nor a community sentence can be justified for the offence”
Mags Min prison sentence =
5 days
Mags Max prison sentence =
6months (one offence), 12 months (aggregate tr offences)
6 month time limit doesn’t apply for imprisonment for non-payment of fine. This applies for YO.
Instead of imprisoning, Mags MAY
order detention within court-house/police station, until an hour, not later than 8pm when order made. It shall not operate D of reasonable opp to get home that day.
What is the max custodial sentence in the Mags
Summary offence in Mags:
6 months
What is the max custodial sentence in the Mags
Criminal damage –
Maximum aggregate –
3 months
Maximum aggregate – 6 months
Mags limited to 6 months with summary offence. Judge can
activate suspended sentence for 6 months, so 12 months total.
RESTRICTIONS ON CUSTODIAL SENTENCE = TEST
offence must be so serious that neither fine nor community sentence can justify offence.
Court MAY pass Custodial Sentence where D:
fails express willingness to comply with requirement in CO, like:
- mental health treatment requirement
- drug rehabilitation requirement
- alcohol treatment requirement
When the court passes a Custodial Sentence other fixed by law, it must be for:
shortest term to commensurate seriousness of offence.
When considering the shortest term to commensurate seriousness of offence (FOR Custodial Sentences), the court should take into account:
- The licence; or
Post-supervision requirements that may be imposed
Where offence so serious only CS justified, but remainder offences no, CS can be
passed for lesser offences, but should run concurrently.
A Suspended Sentended is to be treated as
imprisonment
Two or more offences – when convicted 2 or more, court must consider what if they as associated?
seriousness of the sum,
Two or more offences – when convicted 2 or more, when will the court consider seriousness of the sum,?
provided they are “associated”.
An offence is “associated” with another if:
- D is convicted in same proceedings + sentenced at same time
- D admits commission in proceedings + requests court take into consideration
Totality principle =
where consecutive sentences imposed, MUST ensure total time served is commensurate with seriousness of overall offending.
Calculating time served = Account MUST be taken of
time spent prior conviction/ sentence.