12- biparental care Flashcards
what is biparental care and what % of all bird species have biparental care?
- what arises?
both M and F raise offspring
80%
- conflict between parents over provision of biparental care
why is biparental care a problem? (4)
- parental care is costly
- current investment should be traded off against future survival + reproduction as predicted by life history theory
- costs are borne individually + benefits shared
- tragedy of the commons
how is biparental care a problem for blue tits?
increased parental care can result in reduced adult survival
what is houstan and davies sealed bid model? (5)
- parental effort evolves through time
- 2 parents feed brood of chicks
- each parent has optimal response to partners effort
- if one parent invests a lot then the other doesn’t need to
- eventually ESS is reached evolutionarily
what are the 3 other possible outcomes of the houstan and davies sealed bid model?
- M best response may always be less than F (ESS of only F caring)
- M best response higher than F (ESS of M caring only)
- where both M and F provide care is unstable so either M only or F only care
describe the penduline tit sexual conflict over care as studied by Van dijk et al 2012 ()
- one or both parents desert during egg laying
- 50-70% F only care
- 5-20% M only care
- 30-40% both parents leave
- if lots of F in pop M often desert as likely to find another mate
what did Nakagawa et al 2007 discover about the element of repeatability in how much is invested?
M house sparrow parental effort repeatable within + between years across diff breeding attempts
- M have fixed investment
what did MacColl and Hatchwell 2003 discover about the element of repeatability in how much is invested?
- in long tailed tits parental effort is heritable so to some extent genetically determined
- parents can adjust effort according to circumstances so care may vary and sealed bid is less likely
is an individual’s effort fixed?
no
in most species what do parents vary their effort in relation to?
- nestling age
- brood size
- food supply
- number of carers
what was McNamara et al other biparental care model? (4)
negotiation model
- parents respond to each other over optimal investment in real time
- negotiation rules evolve over time
- more inclusive of potential influences on parental effort
- recognises parents adjust provision rate
what do both biparental care models predict?
that stable biparental care evolves only when one parent compensates incompletely for reduced effort by partner
using empirical studies to test prediction of incomplete compensation list the 5 main types of experiments
- removal experiments
- meta analysis of experimental studies
- handicapping experiments
- testosterone experiments
- nestling playback experiments
what is Markman et al 1996 removal experiment of orange tufted sunbirds?
- M removed from nest
- widowed F increased effort + visitation rate
- compensation incomplete (less food provided)
- reduction in total effort affected health of brood
what was harrison et al 2009 meta analysis of 54 experimental studies? (3)
- empirical support for theoretical prediction of incomplete compensation
- increase in partners effort to compensate not enough so total care is less
- variable results so could be full, partial or no compensation according to sex
describe the alternative experiment to mate removal to test for incomplete compensation, describing examples for both blue tits and european starlings
handicapping experiments: reduce effort of one parent and other incompletely compensates
- small weights or ties feathers on birds to handicap
a) blue tits: no compensation for reduced care by handicapped partner
b) european starlings: weights attached to reduce visitation rate, both sexes compensated equally to increase visitation for partners lower work rate . ability to compensate limited by larger broods with lower visit rates per chick due to increased brood size
give and example for testosterone experiments to test for incomplete compensation
M treated with testosterone which reduced care and F compensate
e.g. dark eyed junco: F compensate completely for reduced M effort, increase effort greater than reduction in M effort