101 Lecture 2 Jan 29 Flashcards
Review of Pax Romana’s end
In-Class Writing!
.
Why did Rome fall? 3 questions
- Why did the West fall apart? Corollary: Was this because of internal or external pressures?
- Who were these barbarians?
- Does this transformation mark a gradual shift to another civilization or is it the beginning of an uncivilized “Dark Ages”?
.
410-480 Western Roman empire disintegrated
Dismembered by barbarian groups who were not intent on destruction. Wanted to be part of the empire. Except the Huns
.
476 conventional date for end of R. E
In that year a barbarian chieftain deposed a Roman emperor. What is new: this chieftan Odavacar deposed the child emperor Romulus Augustulus . Instead of installing a new emperor, O. Wrote to Constantinople and said I will be loyal to you and recognize you as the sole emperor. Symbolic, but no practical significance. Western empire now for all intents and purposes a collection of barbarian kingdoms
.
Severity?
One historian, Roger Collins, calls it _ merely _ the ‘breakdown of a government apparatus that could no longer be sustained”.
.
Could everything else continue in the absence of a state and a political order?
Loss of maintenance of law and peace if there is no longer a military and governmental structure.
.
Controversy over the amount of change: catastrophists and continuists
.
Catastroshists: 450 to 550 a catastrophe happened. More primitive, illiterate, and rural era. More warlike. Literature lost. More primitive architecture End of civic projects. Subsistence. Lessening of trade.
.
Continuists: changes dramatic but more surface. Survival of trade. Role of bishops as replacing Roman governors. Barbarian kings try to perpetuate Roman order. Taxes. Some civic projects. Not radically more barbarised than preceding 150 years.
.
250 to 600. What changed according to continuists is that the ancient world became the medieval world. The urban culture became more rural. Latin amalgamated to German. Pagan to Christian.
.
Key is that there who before had always been outside the empire are now in it
.
Simple answer to collapse: taken over by German confederations who came as military recruits. Allies, refugees.
Admired Rome.
Tens of thousands. Not that numerous
.
Changes in Roman Army
4th century tendency to get the more familiar barbarians into the army as recruits
.
370s Visigoths ask to be admitted as an allied army. Whole group will be federated.
Visigoths not a nomadic people
.
Once they crossed the frontier, Rome inept in feeding them. Visigoths rebelled. Not very new. What is new is that the emperor led an army to suppress than. He was defeated at battle of Adrionople. Emperor Valens killed. 378.
.
Defeat not immediately cataclysmic.
382 Visigoths recognised and allowed to settle in the Balkans as federati. Reasonably useful troops.
.
Barbarization of army. German generals. Magister militum. Powerful leaders of tribal groups. Power behind the throne.
.
Two of these were the Vandal Stilico and the Visigoth Alaric. A wanted territory, food and treasure from Rome. Visigoths starting to move into Greece and eventually would move into Italy. Stilico played a kind of game with Alaric trying to keep him in check in the name Of the Western emperor. Also negotiating with him.
.
Emperors moved from Rome to Milan to Ravenna, in the marshes. Ravenna the last capital Of the western empire.
Eventually Stilico executed by emperor and Alaric world invade and plunder Rome in 410. This is the Sack of Rome that shocked contemporaries
.
Where is the Roman army in all of this?
Curiosly absent in the history of the fifth century.
Not having or losing pitched battles. Supports the idea of internal collapse.
Maybe army indistinguishable from invaders.
.
Huns
450 united under the leadership of Attila
Eastern emperor defeated the Huns and discontinued tribute. Huns decided Constantinople too tough. Turn west for easier pickings.
.
Show up in Gaul in 450. Defeated by an army of Visigoths allied with the Romans.
Go to Italy. Sack cities in the northeast. No army confronts them.
Only one power willing to deal with Attila. The bishop of Rome. Leo I. Along with two senators goes north to remonstrate with Attila. 453. Attila died shortly after of a brain hemmorage. Huns quickly disintegrate.
.
Maps in atlas
.
Pope taking over of Roman imperial responsibilities. Important for future assertion of papal power and the way in which church starts to take over roles abandoned by the empire
.