Witnesses Flashcards
List (2)
Requirements for a witness to testify
- Has personal knowledge of the matter
- Oath or affirmation that they will testify truthfully
Can a child testify?
Depends on their capacity and intelligence as determined by trial judge but general yes
Can an insane person testify
Yes, as long as they understand they must testify truthfully and have capacity
Can a presiding judge testify at the current trial?
NO!
Can a presiding jury member testify?
NO!
List (4)
If there is an inquiry into a the validity of a verdict, what can a juror testify to?
- If extraneous prejudical info was improperly brought to jury’s attn
- If outside influence had bearing on any juror
- If there was a mistake on the verdict form
- If a juror makes a clear statement that they based their decisions on racial stereotypes or animosity to convict the criminal defendant and was a significiant motivating factor into juror’s decision
What is a Dead’s Man Rule?
In a civil case, an interested person cannot testify against a dead person about communications with that dead person
What’s the reason for DMR
Intent is to protect representatives or successors when testimony is being offered against the representatives or successors of the dead person’s interests
What type of cases are Dead Man Rules allowed in?
Civil case, meaning that they do not fall under the FRE!!
What makes a person interested?
If the stand to gain or lose by the judgement or if judgement can be used for or against them in a future case
When to apply a Dead Man’s Rule?
ONLY when the facts explicitly state that the jx has a DMR statute
Is there a Dead Man Rule in the Federal Rules?
NO!!!!!!!!!
ONLY use on state level IF the prompt says that the particular jx uses DMR!!
Are leading questions allowed?
generally YES on CROSS-EXAMINATION
on direct examination ONLY in certain circumstances
List (5), HAARE
When are leading questions on direct examination allowed?
- When witness is hostile
- When witness is an adverse party
- When witness is affiliated with an adverse party
- When witness needs help remembering
- To elicit preliminary or introductory info
What is cross-examination of a witness limited to?
- The questions are within the scope of direct examination + show that reasonable inferences can be drawn from making these cross-examination questions
- Matters that test the credibility of the witness
memorize list generally
What type of questions are NOT allowed?
- misleading
- compound - require one answer to multiple Qs
- argumentative
- conclusory
- cumulative
- unduly harassing
- embarrassing
- call for narrative answer
- call for speculation
- assume facts in evidence are improper
- assume facts in evidence are not permitted
What types of answers can be stricken (removed from record)?
Answers that:
- lack foundation
- non-responsive
When can a document be used by a witness to aid testimony?
to refresh their recollection
When can a document NOT be used by a witness to aid testimony?
To read from
Witness has to testify based on their current recollection
List (3)
If a witness uses a writing to refresh their present recollection while on the stand, what safe guards does the adverse party have?
- Have the writing produced at trial
- Cross-examine the witness about the writing
- Introduce portions or all of writing as long as related to witness’s testimony into evidence
If a witness uses a present writing to refresh their present recollection BEFORE taking the stand , what safeguards does adverse party have?
ONLY IF justice so requires:
- Have the writing produced at trial
- Cross-examine the witness about the writing
- Introduce portions of writing relating to witness’s testimony into evidence
2
What happens if the prosecution fails to produce or deliver a writing in criminal cases?
- Judge must strike witness’s testimony
- Declare mistrial if justice so requires