Wills and Probate Flashcards
What are the two tests English law applies in determining validity of a will?
Must accord with:
1. Internal law of the country in which it was executed
2. Country in which T was domiciled
3. Counrty in which T was a national at the time of: (a) execution or (b) death
2 requirements for testamentary capacity?
- At least 18 years old
- Has mental capacity
4-stage test for testamentary capacity?
- Nature and effects of making a will
- Extent of property
- Moral claims to which they ought to give effect
- No insane delusion that affects the disposition of property
When is testamentary capacity assessed? Exception?
At the time of execution.
Exception is where:
1. T had capacity when instructing his solicitor to prepare the will
2. Will is prepared according to T’s instructions
3. When executing the will, T understood he was executing a will for which he gave instructions, even if he did not have full capacity
Who bears the burden of proving testamentary capacity? (2 points)
- The person seeking to have the will admitted to probate (usually the executors) BUT
- If the will appears to be rational on its face, capacity will be presumed and the BoP will lie on those opposing the will to prove incapacity
When does the presumption of testamentary capacity not apply? How can this risk be avoided?
When T is not normally compos mentis (e.g. long-term mental disorder).
Can be avoided by following GOLDEN RULE: getting a medical practitioner to: (1) confirm T’s lucidity at the time of execution and (2) witness the will
Who bears the BOP with respect to T’s knowledge and approval? 2 points
- Executor bears the burden of proving T knew and approved of the will’s contents BUT
- If T had the mental capacity to make a will, he is presumed to have knowledge and approval as well and the opponents of the will must prove otherwise
When is the test of knowledge and approval applied?
At the time of execution OR at the time T instructs a professional to write his will
What is the easiest way to resolve doubts as to knowledge and approval?
Include an ATTESTATION CLAUSE
In the testamentary context, how does undue influence work (3 points)?
- Burden is on thePERSON CHALLENGING the will
- Confined to ACTUAL undue influence
- Confined to COERCION (force or threats)
4 formalities for a valid will under S.9 of Wills Act 1837?
- In writing
- Signed by T or another person in his presence and by his direction
- Appears T intended his signature to give effect to the will
- T acknowledges or makes the signature in the presence of two or more witnesses present at the same time
- Each witness either: (a) attests and signs the will or (b) acknowledges his signature in T’s presence
What is the implication where a will is written partly in ink and partly in pencil?
Presumption is that pencilled parts were not intended to be final and should not be admitted to probate unless there is evidence T intended them to be final
Precaution where another person signs the will in T’s place?
Must adapt ATTESTATION CLAUSE to reflect exactly what took place
What exactly are the witnesses required to witness?
- T acknowledging that the signature on the will is his OR
- That T is writing on the will
Witnesses must be present at the SAME TIME
2 formal requirements surrounding witnesses’ signature of the will?
- Must sign, or acknowledge their prior signature
- In T’s presence
What additional procedure is required where the will contains no attestation clause?
Must include an AFFIDAVIT OF DUE EXECUTION before admission to probate
3 rules to keep in mind when selecting witnesses?
- Minors can witness if they have mental capacity
- Witness must be mentally and physically present
- If beneficiary (or his spouse or CP) witnesses the will, he will LOSE HIS BENEFIT unless there are at least two non-beneficiary witnesses
3 requirements for external documents to be incorporated into the will?
- Existed when will was made
- Clearly identified in the will
- Referred to as existing at the time
What is a privileged testator? How long does privilege last?
Can make wills without any formalities - can even be made orally.
Privilege lasts even after T ceases to be a member
3 classes of privileged testators?
- Soldiers in actual military service
- Mariner or seaman at sea
- Naval or marine forces in actual military service
What is the status of a mutual will: (1) before the death of T1 and (2) after T1’s death?
(1) Contractual agreement
(2) Constructive trust imposed on T2 in favour of the intended beneficiaries, preventing T2 from reneging on her promise to T1
4 requirements for a valid mutual will?
- Two or more persons execute wills pursuant to an agreement
- Agreement is in writing IF concerns disposition of land
- Parties agree that survivor shall be bound by the arrangement
- First party dies
What happens to a mutual will if T1 dies but T2 remarries?
Mutual will is revoked by operation of law but trust remains intact and continues to bind T2
2 points regarding a signed alteration to a will?
- Rebuttable presumption that a signed alteration was made PRIOR TO EXECUTION AND VALID
- Signature must be OPPOSITE OR NEAR to the alteration, or in a MEMORANDUM REFERRING TO THE ALTERATION
2 points regarding an unsigned alteration to a will?
- Rebuttable presumption that a signed alteration was made AFTER EXECUTION AND INVALID
- Will only be valid if: (a) T + 2 witnesses initial the alteration or (b) entire will with the alteration is re-executed or confirmed by a codicil, provided it refers to the alteration
What is the rule when an unattested alteration or obliteration is made to a will? 2 scenarios
- If the original wording is still apparent by natural means, the ORIGINAL WORDING is admitted to probate
- If the original wording is no longer apparent by natural means, the wording is REVOKED and the will is admitted to probate with a BLANK SPACE in place of the obliteration
What is the effect of the doctrine of dependent relative revocation? 3 points
- Usual rule is that EXTRINSIC evidence and NON-NATURAL means cannot be used to decipher a will
- But such evidence / methods can be used if there is evidence that T DID NOT INTEND TO REVOKE THE ORIGINAL WORDING OR
- There is evidence that T only intended to revoke the will conditionally (e.g., if the later will was valid)
What is a codicil (2 points)? What formalities must be included for it to be valid?
- Testamentary instrument supplementing the terms of the existing will
- With the effect of republishing the will to which it expressly refers at the date of the codicil’s execution
All the same formalities as a will must be followed
When does revocation of a will take effect?
If absolute, immediately. If conditional, then upon fulfillment of the condition.
4 ways of revoking a will?
- Later will or codicil
- Written intention to revoke
- Destruction of will
- Marriage or civil partnership
2 ways for a later will or codicil to revoke an earlier will?
- Express revocation clause
- Impliedly, which will ONLY revoke to the extent of any INCONSISTENCY (i.e. unaffected parts of previous will remain valid)
When does a revocation by later will take effect? Exception?
When the subsequent will is EXECUTED. But if the subsequent will is VOID (e.g. T lacked capacity), it cannot revoke a previous will and the first will remains in effect.
What formalities must be followed to revoke an earlier will by written intention to that effect?
All the same formalities as a will (signed by T, 2 witnesses etc)
4 requirements to revoke a will by destruction?
- Act which completely obliterates the essence of the will
- Which completes all T intends to do by way of destruction
- In T’s presence and by his direction
- T intended to revoke the will by this act at the time of destruction
What evidential presumption is noteworthy with respect to revocation by destruction?
A will that (1) was last known to be in T’s possession but (2) cannot be found on T’s death, is rebuttably PRESUMED TO HAVE BEEN DESTROYED with the INTENTION OF REVOKING IT
What is the rule surrounding marriage / CPs and prior wills? Exception (4 criteria)?
- Marriage or registered civil partnership AUTOMATICALLY REVOKES any prior will
- UNLESS it is clear ON THE FACE of the will that it was made: (a) BEFORE (b) IN CONTEMPLATION of a PARTICULAR marriage or CP (c) to a PARTICULAR person (d) in the foreseeable future*
ExtrinSIC EVIDENCE IS NOT ADMISSIBLE
If a married T separates from his spouse, what is the effect on his will?
No effect if no divorce or annulment order is made
If a married T divorces his spouse or dissolves his civil partnership, what is the effect on his will? 3 points
- Treated as if former spouse DIED on the date of the decree absolute, PARTIALLY REVOKING THE WILL
- Any prior appointment of the former spouse as EXECUTOR/TRUSTEE and/or TESTAMENTARY GUARDIAN will be revoked absent contrary indication
- LEGACY WILL LAPSE and fall into the residue
Note: same principles apply for a VOIDABLE MARRIAGE
If a married T’s marriage is void, what is the effect on his will?
Marriage is treated as never having occurred, so the existing wills are not revoked
3 requirements to revive a revoked will?
- Written will or a codicil complying with ALL NECESSARY FORMALITIES
- Instrument shows INTENTION TO REVIVE the revoked document
- Instrument is IN EXISTENCE at the time (i.e. not destroyed)
What are the 3 situations where extrinsic evidence is admissible to help a court interpret a will?
- Any part of the will is MEANINGLESS
- Language in the will is AMBIGUOUS ON ITS FACE
- Evidence (other than of T’s intention) shows that language in the will is AMBIGUOUS IN LIGHT OF SURROUNDING CIRCUMSTANCES
What is the scope of rectification?
Limited to correcting LINGUISTIC MISTAKES that prevent the instrument from reflecting T’S TRUE INTENTIONS
2 situations when rectification can be granted?
Will does not effect T’s intentions as a result of
1. Clerical error
2. Failure to understand T’s instructions
Deadline for application for rectification? What happens if deadline not met?
6 months from grant of probate (failing which, court permission is required)
What is a “devise”?
Gift of land / realty
What is a “legacy”?
Gift of chattels / personalty
What is a specific legacy? Key defining attribute?
Where T specifies a PARTICULAR PIECE OF PROPERTY
Subject to ADEMPTION
What is a general legacy? Most common kind of property?
Gift that is NOT of specific property but is instead to be provided OUT OF T’S ESTATE
Gift of money or shares
What happens if T leaves a general legacy of 100 shares in BP, but owns no shares in BP?
Executor will have to use estate monies to purchase shares in BP
What is a demonstrative legacy?
General gift where T specifies a designated fund out of which the gift is to be provided
What are the 3 certainties required for a valid gift?
- Intention
- Subject matter
- Objects
Define ademption. What is the consequence?
A specific gift is destroyed, lost, substantially changed or lawfully changes hands by the time of T’s death. The gift will FAIL and B will NOT BE ENTITLED TO COMPENSATION.
What are 3 situations where a gift of specific shares will stand even though the underlying company has changed?
Where the shares change in form only e.g.:
1. Company changed name
2. Company liquidated but was amalgamated with a new company
Or 3. Where gift was disposed of without authority
2 principles governing abatement?
- General legacies abate before specific legacies
- Demonstrative gifts are not vulnerable to abatement
When are the contents of a legacy to be construed?
Will speaks at the DATE OF DEATH.