Wills Flashcards
Reciprocal Wills
When can an estate plan become an irrevocable contract?
Even if the parties to an estate plan do not expressly make an irrevocable contract, e.g., two testator’s providing for surviving spouse then children and a lawyer, a contract may still arise “as an implication from the circumstances and relations of the parties and what they have actually provided for by the instrument.”
Reciprocal Wills
What must the proponent of an irrevocable contract do to prove the contract?
- Establish by clear and convincing evidence that a contract was intended by the parties to bind them to the estate plan.
- If not explicit, use attorney testimony from the planning process and circumstantial evidence
- E.g., Reciprocal wills were contractual in nature and therefore can be specifically enforced in equity
Provision for omitted children when child not living or adopted when will made.
“if a testator executes a will that makes provision for a living child of the testator, a child born or adopted after execution of a testator’s will who is neither provided for nor expressly excluded by the will is entitled to the lesser of” (1) what they would receive under the laws of intestacy, and (2) the equivalent in amount to any bequest and devise to any child named in the will, and to the largest aggregate bequest/devise if there is more than one child named.
How does co-owned property pass when co-owners with rights of survivorship fail to survive one another?
The property passes in proportion to the number of co-owners. So two co-owners, half the property and that half will be an asset in each co-owner’s estate.
Is the omitted child statute implicated when the will refers to “children” generically and not by name?
No, the will is interpreted at the date of the decedent’s death, so “children” will include all children alive.
What are the requirements for a holographic will?
- (1) it is wholly in the testator’s handwriting; (2) it is signed by the testator, and (3) is proved by at least two disinterested witnesses familiar with her handwriting. The testator must also be 18 and have the requisite testamentary intent and capacity. The holographic will must be signed in such a manner as to make it manifest that the name is intended as a signature. Virginia law does not define what shall constitute a signature, and a first name, initials or even a mark can be sufficient, if that was an ordinary way for a testator to sign her name.
What does it mean for a disinterested witness to prove a holographic will?
Just means they can say that that is the testator’s handwriting.
How do disinterested witnesses attest to a non-holographic will?
A will not wholly in the testator’s handwriting is not valid unless the signature of the testator is made, or the will is acknowledged by the testator, in the presence of at least two competent witnesses who are present at the same time and who subscribe the will in the presence of the testator.
How can a testator revoke a will?
- If a testator with the intent to revoke a will or codicil, or some person at his direction and in his presence, cuts, tears, burns, obliterates, cancels, or destroys a will or codicil, or the signature thereto, or some provision thereof, such will, codicil, or provision thereof is void and of no effect.
- Another writing that satisfies the will requirements and expressly revokes all or part of a will or codocil
- Inconsistent terms in a document that satisfies the will requirements
How can a revoked will be revived?
- Once a will is revoked, the will cannot be revived unless it is re-executed with full testamentary formalities. A codicil is a later testamentary instrument that amends, alters, or modifies a previously executed will. A codicil must be executed with the same testamentary formalities as a will. The valid execution of a codicil that makes referenced to the revoked will would cause the will to be revived under the republication by codicil.
What is a disinterested witness?
Someone that is not a beneficiary under the will.
Who does the anti-lapse statute apply to?
- a gift could be saved under the anti-lapse statute so long as the predeceasing beneficiary was a grandparent or lineal descendant of a grandparent of the testator
What happens when a predeceasing will beneficiary is not covered by the anti-lapse statute?
- The gift lapses. The non-residuary gift will pass under the residuary clause. If there is not residuary clause then the gift will pass by intestacy (modified per stirpes).
Provision for omitted children when no child living when will made.
If a testator executes a will when the testator has no children, a child born or adopted after the execution of the testator’s will, or any descendant of his, who is neither provided for nor mentioned in the will is entitled to such portion of the testator’s estate as he would have been entitled to if the testator had died intestate.
Where should a will be probated? What about for a nursing home patient?
Under §64.2-443, the will should be admitted to probate in the jurisdiction where the decedent had a place of residence. For a patient in a nursing home, the place of legal residence is rebuttably presumed to be the same as it was before he or she became a patient.
overcome presumption by clear and convincing evidence
What effect does a contract have on a will that causes a breach of the contract? What if the parties are beneficiaries under the will?
It depends on the type of contract. If it is a contract to make a will, then the contract must be enforced if valid. The Wills terms will operate to the extent that they do not conflict with the terms of the contract. (this is major rule to learn).
If it is not a contract to make a will, for example a loan agreement, it does not directly affect the will. The person(s) harmed by the breach have a separate cause of action against the estate. They should name the estate and the devisee as defendants.
A contract action is an action at law, accompanied by a right to trial by jury. Assuming that the plaintiffs can prove their cause of action, since the terms of the will breach the terms of the written agreement, an issue that would need to be resolved is whether any contract claims would be offset by amounts received by the beneficiaries under the will.
How can you tell the difference between a regular contract and a contract to make a will?
Contract to make a Will will indicate a present intent to contract as to the disposition of a probate asset (“X would provide at her death”). Whereas a regular contract will promise something else (“after X’s death, the land will be sold”)
one is an intent to make a Will disposition, the other is just a promise that it will happen, not necessarily by Will.
General rule: what is the remedy for a breach of contract involving real property? So what result when there is a breach of contract to make a Will regarding real property?
- Specific performance
- “[E]quity can do what is equivalent to specific performance by compelling those upon whom the legal title has descended to convey or deliver the property in accordance with the terms of the agreement on the ground that it is charged with a trust in the hands of an heir, devisee, personal representative or purchaser with notice.” The holder of legal title becomes a constructive trustee for the benefit of the beneficiaries.
If a loan agreement says property will be sold to pay off the debt, and then a will devises that property, what result?
It depends on whether the debt was secured by the property. If unsecured, then the debt will be paid in the order of abatement (remainder, general, specific). So assuming the assets in the estate beside the specific devise can satisfy the claims and debts, then the specific devise will be untouched. However, if there are insufficient assets then debts are paid in the following order: [i] expenses of administration, [ii] family and homestead allowances, [iii] funeral expenses, debts and taxes with priority under federal law, [iv] medical and hospital expenses, [v] debts and taxes due Virginia, [vi] debts and taxes to localities, and [vii] all other claims.
If the debt is secured: Virginia does not recognize the exoneration of liens. The property would still be subject to the lien, unless the decedent specifically provided the estate’s assets will pay off the lien instead of the secured property.
When will contracts supersede valid wills?
only on terms where they conflict
Requirements for qualifying as the executor or administrator? Non resident?
- 18
- Legally competent
- must swear an oath before the clerk or judge that:
a. She will faithfully perform the duties to the best of her judgment;
b. If the will is in probate, that (to the best of her knowledge), the writing is the decedent’s last true will; and
c. If the decedent died intestate, that (to the best of her knowledge), the decedent left no will.
a nonresident fiduciary must (i) appoint a Virginia resident or the Clerk of Court to receive service of process on his or her behalf, and (ii) post a surety bond, unless a resident qualifies at the same time or the clerk waives surety under the provisions of §64.2-1411
a surety bond means a third party backs up the promise
Who can take a will to be probated?
Any interested person
Although a will need not be self-proving, what is required if there is no self-proving affidavit to probate the will?
at least one of the two witnesses must appear before the Clerk to verify the decedent’s signature and validity of the execution of the Will
If they are unavailable to testify and can show good cause for their unavailability, the witnesses may be able to substitute a sworn deposition in place of in-court testimony
What must the proponent of a will provide to admit the will to probate?
Present it to the clerk of the appropriate probate court. The proponent of the Will must also pay the appropriate fees, and if the proponent intends to qualify as personal representative of the estate, the proponent must provide a bond (with surety if a nonresident). Further, certain forms must be provided to the Clerk, namely, a Memorandum of Facts (about the decedent), a Probate Tax Return, and a List of Heirs.
Who Is Entitled to Inherit through Intestacy?
Begin with the suriviving spouse who receives…
one-third or 100 percent of the decedent’s personal estate, depending on whether the intestate decedent is survived by children or any other descendants from outside the marriage.
Who Is Entitled to Inherit through Intestacy?
If there is one or more surviving children or other descendants but no surviving spouse…
The surviving children or other descendants get 100% of the decedent’s personal estate
Who Is Entitled to Inherit through Intestacy?
No surviving spouse and no surviving children or other descendants—look to …
the intestate’s parents:
* Both parents are alive—the personal estate goes to the two parents;
* Only one parent is alive—the personal estate goes to that surviving parent.
Who Is Entitled to Inherit through Intestacy?
No surviving spouse, no surviving children or other descendants, and no surviving parent…
the intestate’s personal estate goes to the intestate’s siblings; if a sibling has predeceased the intestate, the child or other descendant of that sibling takes a share along with the surviving siblings
Who Is Entitled to Inherit through Intestacy?
No surviving spouse, no surviving children or other descendants, no surviving parent, no surviving sibling, and no surviving descendant of a sibling…
the laws of intestacy divide the intestate’s personal estate into two equal portions and assign one-half to the paternal side and one-half to the maternal side:
* The half for the paternal side is given to paternal relatives, following a specified order, and the half for the maternal side is given to material relatives, again following a specified order.
* If there are no paternal relatives, the paternal share goes to the maternal side; if there are no maternal relatives, the maternal share goes to the paternal side.
Who Is Entitled to Inherit through Intestacy?
No surviving spouse, no surviving children or other descendants, no surviving parent, no surviving sibling, and no surviving descendant of a sibling… the specified order:
- Grandfather and grandmother - or the survivorof the two, if one has already died;
- If there is no grandfather or grandmother, to uncles and aunts (and their descendants, the intestate’s cousins, if any uncle or aunt has died);
- If there are no grandparents, no uncles or aunts, and no descendants of uncles and aunts, to great-grandparents;
- If there are no grandparents, no uncles or aunts, no descendants of uncles and aunts, and no great-grandparents, to the brothers and sisters of the grandparents (and their descendants, if any of them has died)
The search keeps on going up the ancestral chain until a lineal ancestor is found who survives the intestate or who left a descendant who survives the intestate.
Special Rules about Children and Other Descendants
What are the first steps in determining whether a child born out of wedlock inherits from the biological parents?
First, apply the rules for adoption and assisted conception.
Special Rules about Children and Other Descendants
Who do adopted children inherit from? What if they were adopted as an adult?
- They inherit from the adopting parent(s). Cease to be child of biological parents unless adopting parent is spouse of biological
- Virginia law recognizes adult adoption for inheritance purposes
Special Rules about Children and Other Descendants
How does a child conceived through assisted conception become the child of the parent for inheritance purposes?
The parent must give consent (1) in writing, (2) before conception, and (3) the child must be born during the consenting person’s lifetime (or within 10 months after the consenting person’s death).
Special Rules about Children and Other Descendants
What are the special rules for children born out of wedlock if the other rules do not apply for the purposes of inheritance?
- the child is always the child of her biological mother
- the child is the child of the biological father if (1) the biological parents participated in a marriage ceremony before or after the birth, or (2) paternity is established by clear and convincing evidence.
Special Rules about Children and Other Descendants
How does a biological father inherit from a child born out of wedlock?
the father must openly treat the child as his child and must not refuse to support the child.
Special Rules about Children and Other Descendants
What are the filing requirements for a child born out of wedlock?
they must file an affidavit in the circuit court and ask for adjudication of parentage witin one year of the parent’s death.
Special Rules about Children and Other Descendants
When does the 1 year filing requirement for children born out of wedlock not apply? (3)
- Parentage has already been established through birth records made out by the deceased parent;
- Admission of parentage under oath; or
- a prior proceeding to determine parentage
Jurisdiction and Venue
Who hears probate and intestacy matters?
Unlike most states, no probate courts. CIrcuit courts hear these matters. Many counties and cities delegate authority over uncontested probate matters to deputy clerks. Contested matters must go before a CC judge
Jurisdiction and Venue
Venue is determined in the following order of priority:
- The circuit court for the city or county where the decedent had a known place of residence
- The circuit court for the city or country where there is real property owned or devised by the decedent
- The circuit court for the city or county where the decedent dies or has an estate
Probating a Will
Methods proponent can use to prove the validity of the will?
- Show that the will has a self proving affidavit (no need for witness);
- The proponent may present testimony from the witnesses to the will about:
- the authenticity of their signatures
- The other requirements for execution were met;
- The testator’s mental capacity and testamentary intent
How does proponent prove the validity of a holographic will?
Must produce 2 disinterested witnesses who testify that the will is completely in the handwriting of the testator.
Executors and Administrators
VA rules for qualifying Executors and Administrators?
- Must be at least 18 years old, legally competent, and must swear an oath before the clerk or judge that:
- She will faithfully perform the duties to the best of her judgment;
- If the will is in probate, that (to the best of her knowledge), the writingis the decedent’s
last true will; and
- If the decedent died intestate, that (to the best of her knowledge), the decedent left no will. - Must post a fiduciary bond equal in value to the decedent’s personal property and to any real property that the will authorizes for sale
- May have to post security (or surety) on the bond (MUST if non-resident)
- A non-resident individual who is appointed to serve as either executor or administrator must consent to service of process in Virginia and must post surity bond — even if security is waived by the will — unless there is a Virginia resident serving as co-executor or coadministrator
bond used to make parties whole if the executor/administrator fails to properly administer the estate.
what must an administrator or executor do when a minor child is a beneficiary of a will?
Petition to have a guardian appointed to manage the property passing to the child while they are still in infancy.
The guardian of the estate must post bond, unless will waives doing so [§ 64.2-504, -505]; provide a list of heirs at the time of qualification [§ 64.2-509]; file an inventory within four months of appointment [§ 64.2-1300]; and file an accounting within 16 months of qualification and annually thereafter [§ 64.2-1304].
Requirements for a contract to make a will?
same to make a regular contract:
1. Certain and definite terms
2. Consideration
3. proof thereof must be clear and convincing
where a contract deals with the transfer of real property, is must satisfy…
the statute of frauds
K must be in writing and signed by the person charged (unless two of three: payment, possession or improvements)
What is a transfer on death deed and what are its statutory requirements?
A deed that transfers property to a designated beneficiary upon the death of the transferor.
The statutory requirements:
1. The deed states that the property will transfer to a designated beneficiary upon death;
2. The deed must be recorded before the transferor’s death in the circuit court where the property is located;
3. The deed is never revoked
When will a statement incorporated by reference be valid?
“If a will refers to a written statement or list to dispose
of items of tangible personal property not otherwise specifically bequeathed, the statement or list shall be given effect to the extent that it describes items of tangible personal property and their intended recipients with reasonable certainty and is signed by the testator although it does not satisfy the requirements for a will.”
If it deals with tangible personality, it need not be executed after the execution of the will.
Who do adopted children inherit from? What if they were adopted as an adult?
- They inherit from the adopting parent(s). Cease to be child of biological parents unless adopting parent is spouse of biological
- Virginia law recognizes adult adoption for inheritance purposes
What do you have if you are the only surviving heir and the decedent is dead?
a vested remainder