Wills Flashcards
Why do we require strict compliance with wills formalities?
Because there is no constitutional right to exercise dead hand control - it is a privilege.
What are some common will substitutes, and why would you use them?
They avoid the costs and inconvenience of probate. Examples include:
-inter vivos outright gifts
-inter vivos living trusts
-future interests
-co-ownership of property (joint tenancy has right of survivorship)
-life insurance
-bank arrangements (Totten trusts, joint or survivor accounts, POD designations)
-Deeds
What are the two forms of intestacy?
- Total intestacy - decedent dies without a will or their will is denied probate
- Partial intestacy - will does not dispose of all property (gift failed, no residuary clause)
What is intestate succession?
Distributes property to people who society views as “proper” after the intestate’s debts and taxes are paid. Distribution scheme cannot be altered to fit decedent’s intent.
What law applies for intestate succession?
If decedent was married, use the law of the domicile at the time the property was acquired.
Otherwise, use law decedent’s domicile at death for personal property and law of the situs of the property for real property.
What is the intestate share of the surviving spouse?
Common law: widow gets dower (life estate in 1/3 of real property husband owned during marriage), widower gets curtesy (life estate in all wife’s real property if child was born to marriage).
Modern law: spouse is heir (amount they take varies by state, but they will often take entire estate if there are no descendants or if the only descendants are also descendants of the surviving spouse).
What is the intestate share if all children survive?
Equal shares of the portion of the estate that does not pass to the surviving spouse.
What are the methods of computing shares if at least one descendant predeceased the decedent?
- Classic Per Stirpes: one share created for each child and one share for each deceased child who has at least one surviving descendant.
- Per capita with representation (majority rule): property divided into equal shares at first generation where there are living takers. Each living person at that level takes a share, and the share of a deceased person at that level passes to their issue.
- Per capita at each generation (modern trend): make initial division of shares at first generation where there are living takers. Pool shares of lower generations so each person receives an equal share.
What is the intestate succession order under a typical statute?
Proceed down list until takers are found:
-Spouse and/or descendants
-Parents
-Descendants of parents (siblings and descendants)
-Maternal and/or paternal grandparents & descendants (aunts, uncles, cousins, etc.)
-Nearest maternal and/or paternal kin
-the state
How are adopted children treated for purposes of intestate succession?
Same as biological children of adopting parents. Generally no inheritance in either direction between adopted children and biological parents, unless a biological parent marries an adopting parent.
How are stepchildren and foster children typically treated for purposes of intestate succession?
No inheritance rights unless adopted.
Exception: adoption by estoppel permits a children to inherit from or through stepparent or foster parent when legal custody is gained under an unfulfilled agreement to adopt.
How are nonmarital children treated for purposes of intestate succession?
Mother: child always inherits
Father: child will inherit if father married mother after child’s birth, man was determined to be father in paternity suit, or man is proved by clear and convincing evidence to be father during probate
How are half vs. whole blood siblings treated?
UPC/majority rule: no distinction, they inherit equally
Minority: half bloods have half shares or are cut out entirely if whole blood siblings exist
How are posthumous children treated for purposes of intestate succession?
Most states: if person is in gestation at the time of the intestate’s death, they can be an heir
Some states: child who is born within statutory period can inherit under specified circumstances.
How are disinheritance clauses treated for intestate succession?
Common law/majority rule: will provision expressly disinheriting is ineffective as to property passing by intestacy
UPC/minority rule: testator may exclude right of individual to succeed to property passing by intestate succession.
What is an advancement?
A lifetime gift to an heir with the intent that the gift be applied against any share the heir inherits from the donor’s estate. If an advancement is found, the gift’s value is added back into the estate to calculate shares, then subtracted from the recipient’s share (hotchpot)
Common law: a substantial lifetime gift to a child was presumed an advancement
Modern: lifetime gift presumptively not an advancement unless shown to be intended as such (UPC requires a writing)
What happens in the case of simultaneous deaths?
USDA: disposition depends on order if death; if order cannot be established, property of each decedent is disposed of as if they had survived the other.
UPC (120 hour rule): A person must survive decedent by 120 hours to take any distribution of the decedent’s property.
How does disclaiming work?
An heir or beneficiary may disclaim their interest (can’t be forced to accept an inheritance). Most states require disclaimer to be written, signed by disclaimant, acknowledged before notary, and filed within 9 months of death.
Effect: property passes as if the disclaimant had predeceased the decedent.
What happens if the decedent’s death is caused by heir or beneficiary?
Majority rule: a person who feloniously and intentionally brings about the death of a decedent forfeits any interest in the decedent’s estate.
Occurs through a slayer statute or the imposition of a constructive trust.
What is the difference between a will and a codicil?
A will is an instrument executed with formalities, revocable during lifetime and operative at death. A codicil is a supplement to a will that modifies it.
What is the applicable law to determine the validity and effect of a will?
Real property: state where property is located
Personal property: state where testator is domiciled at time of death
Savings statute (majority rule/UPC): will is admissible to probate if executed in accordance with law of that jurisdiction, state where will was executed, testator’s domicile when will was executed, or testator’s domicile at death.
What is the required legal capacity to make a will?
Must be 18 and of sound mind
What are the requirements of testamentary capacity?
Testator must understand at the time the will was executed:
1. Nature of act
2. Nature and extent of their property
3. Persons who are natural objects of their bounty
4. All of the above in order to formulate an orderly scheme of disposition
What is the requirement of testamentary intent?
Testator must have present intent that the instrument operate as their will. Promises and ineffective deeds are not given effect.
What are some of the common formalities for wills?
-in writing
-signed by testator (or by someone else at the testator’s direction and in their presence)
-2 attesting witnesses
-testator signs will in the presence of witnesses
-witnesses sign in testator’s presence
Other requirements may include: signing at the end of the will, publishing the will, witnesses signing in the presence of each other
UPC requires two competent witnesses OR signature by notary
Can a witness to a will be interested?
Common law: witness who was beneficiary was not competent
Modern: will is valid, but bequest to interest witness may be void under purging statute unless the witness was supernumerary
What is a self-proving affidavit?
Recites that all elements of will execution were performed and is sworn to by testator and witnesses before a notary. Functions like a depo so witnesses don’t have to show up in court later.
What is a holographic will?
One that is entirely in the testator’s handwriting with no attesting witnesses.
UPC and majority of states require that at least the material portions be in the testator’s handwriting.
Do most states and the UPC recognize oral (noncupative) wills?
NO
What is the difference between a devise, a bequest, and a legacy?
Devise: gift of real property
Bequest: gift of personal property
Legacy: gift of personal property in a will