Why do we need concepts and theories of IR? Flashcards
What is the field of IR mostly influenced by?
History
- (Britain pre-WW2)
Political Science
- (US post-WW2)
Why are concepts contested?
- definitions are rareley consensual
- meaning isn’t fixed in time
- ethno-centrism
What is the concept of state based on?
European/regional history
Why do we have concepts?
4
To describe complex realities
To make sure we’re talking about the same things
To ensure constructive dialogue
To develop and evaluate theories
How was the concept of State defined?
Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States
1933
Legal criteria of statehood
4
- Defined territory
- Permanent Population
- Capacity to enter into international relations
- Government (governance = functioning bureaucracy)
Constitutive theory statehood
external validation/recognition is necessary to gain statehood
declarative theory on statehood
declaration is enough to achieve statehood
De Facto state / internal sovereignty
state monopolizes some functions within its territory
De Jure State / external sovereignty
State has recognition from other states and actors as well as autonomy over its territory
What is a state?
entity with well-defined population, territory and recognized political authority over a geographical space
What is a nation?
a group of people that are bound by cultural artifacts or history
what is a nation-state
state with a monogamous population
Is India a nation-state?
India is more of a state-nation: it became a state first, then made/bended into a nation
what is sovereignty?
there is no actor above the state that can compel it to act in certain ways
Case study statehood IEA
IEA = Islamic Emirates of Afghanistan
It has:
- de facto state: monopoly force + military and police force
- bureaucracy
- diplomatic outreach
- to be able to provide assistance to Afghans
It hasn’t:
- official recognition from other states
- legitimacy
- governance capabilities
Case study statehood ISIS
It has:
- control and governance of large areas of territory
- tax revenue
- police and military force
- infrastructure
It hasn’t:
- UN membership
- recognition from other states
- legitimacy
- permanent population
- limited state capacities