Week 6 - Religion and Gender Flashcards
What is the difference between Sex and Gender?
- Sex = biological differences
- Gender = cultural constructions of male and female characteristics on a continuum
Gender
- a key organizing principle in society
- affects our choices, opportunities, world view
Gender in the context of religion
- religion is where we find society’s most “conservative” and “progressive” themes (i.e. gender fluidity)
- gender generates powerful religious symbols organized by sex differences
Gender - Azande
women have no access to divination practices
Gender - Witchcraze
women viewed as evil and sexual
what is the most important aspect in shaping a particular view of gender?
religious belief
Gender in the Religious context
- occupies a large place in all religions
- religious language, rituals, roles, symbols draw on this experience
- use it as a metaphor for division or separation
- focus on difference
8 ways Gender and Religion intersect
1) Control Over Bodies (abortion, contraception, FGM)
2) The Clothes We Wear (ex: hijab)
3) Power (gender relations)
4) Economics - what woek is appropriate depending on gender
5) Marriage - polygamy, same sex
6) Gender Construction (ex: rites of passage)
7) Ascetic Groups (ex: nuns, brotherhoods)
8) Concepts of Normalcy (ex: homosexuality)
Religion, Myth, and Gender
- many texts, myths and rituals articulate what men and women are like
- how men and women supposed to relate
- dictate appropriate conduct for genders
- the value ascribed to each sex is not equal
- preoccupied w/ separating men & women (often western interpretations) -> many creation and divine myths feature androgynous, two-spirit, intersex, sex/gender changer, or binary figures in one body
- can’t understand gender experience, construction, roles without religious context
Hijras
- 3rd gender in India and Pakistan
- undergo voluntary castration
- often identify as transsexual, transgender, transvestite, homosexual, asexual, intersex, or eunuchs
- many perform stereotypical feminine gender roles in how they dress, behave, talk, jewelry, have long hair, wear cosmetics
History of Hijras
- viewed as cultural descendents of the court eunuchs of the Islamic Mughal Empire
- typically live together in commune arrangment of 5 or more “chelas” (disciples) supervised by “guru” (teacher)
- still face discrimination in health, housing, education, employment
Hijras under British Rule
seen as “breach of public decency” and incapable of “moral transformation” -> laws enacted against Hijras to fit British social standards of time
Hijra Lifestyle
- some practice asceticism, others engage in sexual relationships with men or engage in sex work
- by joining hijra community, individuals perceived as failing to fulfil conventional gender norms, such as marriage and bearing children
- seen as deviant and suffer discrimination and marginalization
- also seen as having power to curse, to bless and remove curses
- see themselves as descendants of Bahuchara Mata
Bahuchara Mata
- Hindu goddess of chasity and fertility
- grants favours of male children
- patron goddess of Hijra community
History of Bahuchara Mata
- daughter of known warrior travellinf w/ caravan along w/ her sisters, when notorious bandit hijacked caravan
- in their culture, dying at hands of enemy is absolute no-no and would rather take their own lives
- Bahuchara decided it wasn’t her or her sister’s time to die
- instead she cut off her and her sisters breasts as way to curse bandit with impotence/make him a “eunuch”
- only way for bandidt to remove curse was if he paid homage to Bahuchara Mata by dressing and behaving like a woman
- cutting off breasts secure her deification for her virtue and purity
Different Versions of Bahuchara Mata
- one variation: thieves rape her and she curses them; theieves then realize she has turned them into hijras
- other version: Bahuchara is a powerful man or prince. When threatened by theives, he transforms into a woman through his “spiritual power”. The theives try to rape her and in her defence she cuts off her breast so she no longer appears feminine and curses theives and they become hijras
- one aspect of stories is Bahuchara’s creation of hi-res seen as curse
- some hijra’s believe their identity as a curse as a punishment and explains their low social status and derogatory treatment in society
Hijra Myths
- 2 childless couples wanted a blessing from Bahuchara
- both had babygirls, and when they grew up these girls they loved eachother and got married -> angered local king
- king’s animals’ sex changes by drinking from the lake
- he realized power of water and took one of the girls there to drink: she became a boy
- lake became the well at Becharaji, and it’s said that any who enter well come out as a kinnar (Hijra) their body changes, as does their face, voice, and sex
Worship of Bahuchara Mata
- worshipped by many hi-res, regardless of individual religous identification, particularly due to her association with transgender identity
- worshipped for her ability to give blessings associated with fertility to newlyweds and childless couples
- myths also have theme of celibacy or impotence -> in particular, male celibacy achieved through the removal of genitalia and gender transformation