Week 3 - Clinical Reasoning & Judgment in Nursing Flashcards
What is the processes by which nurses make judgments, including generating alternatives, weighing them against evidence, choosing the most appropriate?
Clinical reasoning
- The process by which nurses make judgement about patient’s care
What are the 3 main types of knowledge in clinical reasoning?
Recognizing patterns
- You’ve seen this before
- Theoretical knowledge
- Learned in school
Intuition
- Gut instinct
Tacit knowledge
- Hidden knowledge
What is an interpretation or conclusion about a patient’s needs, concerns or health problems, and/or the decision to take action (or not), use or modify standard approaches, or develop new ones as deemed appropriate by the patient’s response?
Clinical judgement
- The outcome & the course of action
What are the 4 stages in the Tanner’s model of clinical judgement?
Noticing
Interpreting
Responding
Reflecting
Whats the process using Tanner’s Model?
- Context background relationship
- if this happened before
- do you know how to fix it
- Need to gather more info - Noticing
a). Expectations
- how many times this has happened
- do you have background knowledge in this field
b). Initial grasp
- Interpreting (trying to figure out the problem using the info g
- reasoning patterns
- analytic
- intuitive
- narrative
Examples of clinical judgment in nursing
Deciding which assessments to perform for a patient after surgery
How to teach a patient newly diagnosed with a condition about their illness and how best to manage it
Deciding which type of pain medication to give a patient and when
Selecting appropriate communication techniques when someone is upset or angry
Deciding which patient needs care first, when you are responsible for multiple patients at once
Tanner’s model of clinical judgement
What is the data and info gathering phase?
Noticing
Tanner’s model of clinical judgement
What does effective noticing involves in nursing?
Focused observation
Recognizing deviations from expected patterns
Information seeking
- Noticing things when communication
- Noticing is also based on the context
Tanner’s model of clinical judgement
What does the phase, noticing involve?
A perceptual grasp of the situation at hand
Involves the nurse having an expectation of the situation from the specific patient’s pattern of responses, textbook knowledge (comparing the patient’s condition to what’s learned in school), and clinical knowledge from similar patients
Tanner’s model of clinical judgement
What is the setting priorities and making a plan phase?
Interpreting
Tanner’s model of clinical judgement
What does the interpreting phase include?
Developing a sufficient understanding of the situation
Involves using one or more reasoning patterns to interpret the meaning of the data and determine an appropriate course of action
Tanner’s model of clinical judgement
What does effective interpreting involve?
Making sense of and prioritizing data
- Prioritizing first
- What’s the most important? Which patient is the most important? Who to attend to first?
- Then develop a plan
Tanner’s model of clinical judgement
What are the types of reasoning patterns used in interpreting?
Analytic patterns: hypothetico-deductive reasoning, weighing alternatives.
- Often used by beginning nurses
- Hypothetico-deductive: if you do this then this is likely to happen
- Learned in school, textbooks etc
Intuition: depends on experience with similar situations, often involves pattern recognition
- Rely more on experience
Narrative thinking: by understanding the illness experience and the meaning attached to it can care be provided.
- Rely more on experience
- Patient’s story
- Adds context which help you to notice when something’s off, help you pick the right intervention, etc)
- Knowing the meaning help you to make priorities and how to communication with that patient
Tanner’s model of clinical judgement
What is the doing (putting plan to action) phase?
Responding
Tanner’s model of clinical judgement
What does the responding phase do?
Deciding on a course of appropriate action for the situation
- sometimes it might be doing nothing
- not b/c you dk how to or that you’re too lazy but b/c what you’re already doing is working so you don’t need more
Tanner’s model of clinical judgement
What does effective responding involves?
Clear communication
Having a calm, confident manner
Having well planned interventions, while also maintaining flexibility
Being skillful
Tanner’s model of clinical judgement
What is the thinking of your action phase?
Reflecting
- thinking about what you’re doing and if it has achieved the intended outcome
Tanner’s model of clinical judgement
What does the reflecting phase include?
Attending to the patients’ responses to the nursing action while in the process of acting.
Involves both reflection-on-action and reflection–in-action.
- Assessing a patient’s responses while providing care
- After completing care to evaluate your work and its effectiveness
Tanner’s model of clinical judgement
What does effective reflecting involve?
Evaluation and self-analysis
Commitment to improvement
Tanner’s model of clinical judgement
What are the types of knowledge?
Abstract, generalizable, applicable in many situations and derived from science and theory
- Textbook knowledge
Knowledge from experience that is often tacit, and aids in instant recognition of clinical states
- Tacit - unseen
- Gut feeling
Highly localized and individualized, and comes from knowing the patient
- Narrative of the patient