Wear Flashcards
Define wear?
- IS A PROGRESSIVE LOSS OF BEARING SUBSTANCE from the material as a result of CHEMICAL OR MECHANICAL ACTION
- chemical = CORROSION
Describe the 4 modes of wear?
- mode 1- Generation of wear debris that occurs with MOTION between the 2 primary bearing surfaces
- mode 2- primary bearing surface rubbing against a secondary surface in a manner not intended by designers
- mode 3 - 2 primarily bearing surfaces with interposed 3RD body particles- cement
- mode 4- 2bearing surfaces rubbing together e.g back side wear on a acetabular, fretting of morse taper, stem- cement fretting or femoral component impingement on rim of cup
What is the most common type of wear?
- type 1 - occurs for most wear in a functioning hip
What are the mechanisms of wear?
- ABRASIVE
- ADHESION
- FATIGUE
When does 2 body abrasive wear occur?
- When a SOFT MATERIAL (UHMWPE0 comes into contact with a SIGNIFICANTLY HARDER MATERIAL ( METAL)
- asperities of the harder material surface may plough into the softer surface->GROOVES / LOOSE WEAR DEBRIS
- femoral head aperities 0.1um
When does 3rd body abrasive wear occur?
- When EXTRANEOUS material e.g. METALLIC/ CERAMIC, BONE, DEBRIS enter INTERFACIAL region.
- They may become embedded in the polymer and abrade the femoral head.
- Raised edges abrade polymer at a greater rate. Single transverse stratch may increase wear factor by 10.
When does ADHESIVE wear occur?
- When a junction is formed between the two opposing surfaces as they come into contact.
- If the bond between the 2 materials stronger than the cohesive strength of the individual bearing material surface, fragments may be torn off the surface and adhere to the stronger material- UHWMPE adheres to metal, esp if dry-> shearing of UHMPE
What is FATIGUE WEAR? Can you name an example?
- DELAMINATION, a form of failure that occurs in the structures subjected to dynamic and fluctuating stresses.
- It is possible that failure can occur at a load e.g TKR when the joint is less conforming and the UHMPE is more highly stressed.
- fatigue wear is more a problem in TKR as the joint is less conforming and the UHMWPE is more highly stressed
- Repeated loading causes SUBSURFACE FATIGUE FAILURE at a depth of a few millimetres = as this in an area of MAX PRINCIPLE STRESS
- no wear is not related to surface roughness
- cracks appear when the endurance limit is exceeded
What is FATIGUE life?
- This is the NUMBER OF CYCLES NEEDED TO CAUSE FAILURE AT A SPECIFIC STRESS LEVEL, taken from the S-n curve plot ( log graph)

What is MICRO DELAMINATION?
- When the surface layer of UHMWPE breaks off , it produces large particles.
- UHMPE asperities 1-10um ( 2 0rders higher than metal asperities).
- These are plasticially deformed by loading, producing local stress concentrations above the yield stress of UHMPE -> failure by plastic deformation and rupture.
what factors can excerabate fatigue wear?
- a subsurface layer of oxidation
- subsurface faults
- misaligned or unbalanced implants
- thin UHMWPE
What are the type of wear?
- Volumetric
- Linear
What is VOLUMETRIC WEAR?
- VOLUME OF MATERIAL DETACHED from the softer material as a result of WEAR - mm3/year
- directly related to square of the radius of the head
- creates a cyclinder
- head size is most important factor in predicting particles generated.
- measure by linear wear and square the radius of head
How can you measure volumetric wear in vitro?
- pin on plate, rotating pin on disc or joint simulators
- joint simulators mimic loading conditions in vivo - apply cycle 4Hz but with no rest periods. an vary temperature, and lubricant.
- Problem to underestimate wear cf invivo 60 days to apply 10 million cycles with each million cycles = approx 1 year of clinical use
How can you measure volumetric wear in vivo?
- direct examination of the explanted cup
What is LINEAR WEAR?
- is the LOSS of HEIGHT of bearing surface mm/year
How can you measure liner wear in vivo?
- Cup penetration measured initial and follow up X-ray- medial migration
Can you describe the law of wear?
- Volume of material removed by wear
- V= kLX
- k- wear factor for the given materials incoorporating the hardness of the softer material
- L- load
- X- sliding distance
- NB - a larger femoral head will have greater V as X is greater.
What factors affect wear?
Patient factors
1) WEIGHT- applied load
2) AGE and ACTIVITY - applied rate of load
Implant factors CROUCH LIPSS
a) COEFFICIENT OF FRICTION
b) ROUGHNESS - surface finish
c) TOUGHNESS - abrasive wear
d) HARDNESS- stratch resistance
e) SLIDING DISTANCE OF EACH CYCLE- diameter of femoral head
f) NO OF CYCLES
g) SURFACE DAMAGE
h) PRESENCE OF 3RD BODY WEAR- abrasive wear
Can you describe the wear in THR?
- acetabulum- WEAR and CREEP- - ( CREEP is the viscoelastic property- time dependent irreversible plastic deformation in response to a constant load. the amount of creep depends on the APPLIED LOAD not on SLIDING MOVEMENTS BETWEEN SURFACES.
What is the direction of creep in an THR?
- SUPEROMEDIALLY- as this is the direction of the compressive joint reaction force
- 0.1mm for 1st milion cycles

What is the direction of WEAR in an THR?
- SUPEROLATERAL- as this is PERPENDICULAR TO THE INSTANTEOUS AXIS OF ROTATION

What dominates the initial penetration rate in an THR? What is its rate?
- Creep cf wear.
- 0.1mm for first 1million cycles
What are the consequences of wear particles?
- SYNOVITIS
- ASEPTIC Osteolysis and LOOSENING
- IMMUNE REACTION
- INCREASED FRICTION OF THE JOINT
- MISALIGNMENT OF THE JOINT
- CATASTROPHIC FAILURE
How do wear particles exert their biological activity?
- By Being PHAGOCYTOSED by MACROPHAGES WHICH STIMULATES THE RELEASE OF SOLUBLE PRO INFLAMMATORY CYTOKINES- IL6/IL1, TNF APLHA, AND PROSTAGLANDINS- PG E2
- These mediators released near to bone cause osteolysis, aseptic loosening by stimulating osteoclasts.
- macrophages directly can effect this by stimulating o2 free radicals and hydrogen peroxide
What size of wear particles are the biologically active?
- 0.1-10 µm
- 0.1-0.5 µm most potent!!
What has been quoted as the critical wear rate for osteolysis around the acetabular cup?
- 140mm3/year
What are the criteria that affect osteolysis/ macrophage activation ?
- Size of particles
- Morphology of particles - irregular shaped are more active than spheres
- Total no of wear particles
- Volume of wear debris
- Imune response to particles
With a 28mm head what are the wear rates; linear, volumetric, particle no and size for UHMPE vs metal Ceramic vs UHMPE Metal vs metal ceramic vs ceramic
- UHMPE vs metal LW 150-200 um/pa,Vol 40-80mm3/pa, no 7x10 power 11 size 0.5-100 µm
- ceramic vs UHMPE LW 75-100 um/pa. Vol 15-20mm3/pa, size 0.5-100 µm
- METAL vs Metal LW 5-10 um/pa, vol 0.1-10 mm3/pa, no 4x10(12)- 2.5x10(14) size 0.05-0.5 µm
- ceramic vs ceramic lw- negligible, VW 0.004mm3/pa, size 0.025 µm
What are the advantages of ceramic on ceramic bearing surfaces?
- Low wear
- Biocompatibility
What are the disadvantages of ceramic on ceramic bearing surfaces?
- Risk head fracture
- Abrasive wear
- Edge loading
What are the advantages of metal on metal bearing surfaces?
- Good long term clinical results
- Ability to self polish
What are the disadvantages of metal on metal bearing surfaces?
- Undetermined effects of elevated ions
- Undetermined cancer risk potential
- metal hypersensitivity
What are the advantages of cross linked UHMPE bearing surfaces?
- Reduced wear
- accomplished by perioxide chemisty, variable-dose ionzing radiation and electron-beam, irradiation
What are the disadvantages of bearing surfaces?
- Particles biologically more active xs cross linked poly can lead to reduced mechanical properties short term clinical results
Where are UHMPE/metallic wear particles transported to ?
The liver, spleen and abdominal lymph nodes
What are the limitations of UHMPE as a bearing surface? Why?
- Wear RESISTANCE UHMPE sterilised by gamma irradiation- 2-4mRads -> significant degradation oxidation during post irradiation ageing -> higher wear rates/delamination/ gross failure
- By formation of free radicals BY GAMMA RADIATION. these free radicals react with O2 molecules->additional chain scissoring-> increasing CRYSTALLINITY, DECREASE FATIGUE STRENGTH, FRACTURE TOUGHNESS AND WEAR RESISTANCE
Where does the max oxidation occur in UHMPE?
- 1-2mm below the surface at the SUBSURFACE WHITE BAND
Why is UHMWPE cross linked? How is this achieved?
- To improve the oxidation and wear resistance
- by Peroxide chemistry variable dose ionizing radiation electron beam irradation sterilisation with gamma radiation in O2 free environment including a vacuum/ inert gas ( argon/nitrogen) or use ethylene oxide or gas plasma
Does cross linked UHMPE produce particles
- Yes, submicrometre and nanometre size large amount of these which have more functional biological activity - may lead to more osteolysis
How does surface roughness affect THR wear?
- Damaged heads->higher Volumetric wear
- higher total penetration rates
- higher no of particles over prothesis lifetime
- Damaged head generate->increased no small, biologically active particles <10 µm
How does thickness of UHMPE affect THR wear?
- Thickness at least 8MM - as creep, stress and wear increase dramatically when thickness below this.
- adequate uhmpe thickness obtained by a 40mm cup only by downsizing the femoral head to 22mm
How does type of metal affect THR wear?
- cobalt chrome excellent if cold worked as HARD, CORROSIVE RESISTANT AND RESISTANT TO FATIGUE
- Stainless steel- cheap but EASILY SCRATCHED
- Ti- POOR WEAR and HIGH COEFFICIENT OF FRICTION, sensitive to SURFACE FLAWS AND SCRATCHES- used for femoral components - uncemented/ tibial trays in tar
How does Head size affect THR wear?
- the LARGER HEAD SIZE > SLIDING DISTANCE AND VOLUMETRIC WEAR
- vol wear debris = πr2P where P is the penetration , r radius and . p proportional to 1/r2 so larger femoral head less Penetration
How does modularity affect THR wear?
- increased wear in both uncemented and cemented metal back cups due to reduced UHMWPE THICKNESS and INCREASED PEAK STRESSES especially in incongruent and GAPS between liner and metal back
How does back side occur?
- Wear between from relative movement linear and shell.
- worse if poor locking mechanism or screw holes with sharp unpolished margins.
- UHMWPE may creep through holes - conduit for wear particles
How does offset affect THR wear?
- Decreased offset increases joint reaction forces and increase wear
How does UHMWPE production affect THR wear?
- Ram extrusion produces linear wear of 0.11mm/pa cf compression moulding 0.05mm/pa
How does gamma sterilsation affect THR wear?
- oxidation of the UHMWPE leads to crystallisation and reduction in fatigue strength
What is tribiology?
- as the science that deals with the interaction between surfaces in motion and consequences of the at interaction ie friction, lubrication and wear
What is friciton?
- As the resistance to sliding motion between 2 bodies in contact
For dry friction three laws of friction apply?
- Fricitonal force F= coefficient of friction (µf) x applied load ( w)
- F is independent of the apparant area of contact or sliding speed (v)
- The knetic F is independent of V
In the hip it is important to discuss frictional torque. What is frictional torque?
- FT = frictional force ( F) x radius r= µf x W x r
What are the projections on the surface of materials called?
- Asperities
- the taller and more numerous= the rougher the surface and greater the friction
What is roughness?
- Expressed as mean surface roughness or Ra
- = the average height of the asperities
- Ra for polishes exerter stem is 0.01-0.03 cf articular cartilage is 1-6ra
What is the coefficient of friction for a normal knee/hip?
- knee 0.005-0.02 µf
- hip 0.01-0.04 µf
What is the coefficient of friction for a metal on PE, metal on metal?
- metal on PE = 0.02
- metal on metal 0.8
What is syovial fluid?
- A dialysate of blood plasma
- without clotting factors, erythtocytes or haemoglobin
- clear, sometime yellow, viscous
- contains Hyaluronate and plasma proteins
- Behaviour is non newtonian- shear stress is not proportional to shear rate
- Pseudo-plastic - undergoes shear thining ( viscosity decreases as shear rate increases)
- Thixotrophic- undergoes shear thining with time when sheared at constant rate
What is Rheology?
- Science of deformation and flow of matter
what is shear?
- Rate of deformation of a fluid when subjected to a mechanical shearing stress
What is shear stress?
- Applied force per unit area needed to produce deformation in a fluid
what is viscosity?
- the measure of internal friction of fluid
- this friciton becomes apparant when a layer of fluid is made to move in relation to another layer
- the greater the friction the greater the amount of force required for this movement = shear
- viscosity= shear stress/ shear rate
- shear stress = force per unit area to produce a shear action dynes/cm2
- shear rate is a measure of the change in speed at which the intermediate layers of fluid move with respect to each other measures in seconds-1, s-1
What is newtonian fluid?
- Fluid or dispersion whose rheoloigcal behaviour is decribed by newton’s law of viscosity
- here the shear stress is poroportional to shear rate with the proportionality constant being viscosity
- e.g. water, thin motor oils, synovial fluid in Ra ( enzymic degradation makes it a less effective lubricant
What is non newtonian fluid?
- When the shear rate is varied, shear stress doesn’t vary in the same proportion ( or even necessarily in the same direction)
- the viscosity of such fluids therfore changes as the shear rate is varied
What is shear thining/ pseudo-plastic?
- describes a non -newtonian fluid whose viscosity of decreases as the applied shear rate increases
- it is dervived from the alignment of the hyaluronic acid molecules as shear rate increasesa
When happens in RA pt knees in regard to synovial fluid?
- enzyme degradation of syonival fluid -> loss of non newtonian properties making the fluid a less effective lubricant
What is Dilatant?
- Non newtonian fluid whose viscosity increases as shear rate increases
- = shear thickening
- rarer than shear thining but is found in fluids containing high levels of deflocculated solids e.g. sand/water, clay surries
What is plastic
- Descibes a fluid that behaves as a solid under static conditions but once flow is induced with a force known as yield value the fluid may behave non- newtonian or Newtonian e.g tomato ketchup
What is thixotropic?
- Undergoes shear thining with time when sheared at a constant rate
- ie viscosity decreases
What is Rheopexy?
- essentially opposite of thixotropic beahviour in that fluid’s viscosity increases with time as it is sheared at a constant rate
What are the 2 main types of lubrication?
- Fluid- filmed
- boundary
What is fluid filled lubircation?
- Surfaces are separated by a fluid film, the minimum thickness of which must exceed the surface roughness of the bearing surface in order to prevent asperity contact
What is boundary lubrication?
- Contact bearing surfaces are separated by only a boundary lubricant of moelcular thickness which prevents excessive bearing friction / wear
What does the biotribological preformance of a joint depends on the
- Lamdba ratio
- this is the ratio of fluid-film thickness to surface roughness
- a ratio of 3 = fluid film lubricaton whilst 1 = boundary lubrication
Name the different types of fluid film lubrication seen in synovial joints?
- Hydrodynamic
- Elastohydrodynamic
- Micro elastohydrodynamic
- Squeeze film
- Weeping
- Boosted
Describe hydrodynamic lubrication?
- Wedge of fluid becomes entrapped and pressurised
- one suface rotates whilst the other slides
- rapid speed but low loads
- High viscosity
- no contact between surfaces and so no wear
- occurs during the high speed non -accelerating rotatory motion of the femur during swing phase of gait

Describe elastohydrodynamic lubrication?
- IN EHD deformation of the bearing surface serves to trap presssurised fluid and increase the surface area
- increased SA-> increased shear rate => increased viscosity
- increase capacity of fluid-film to carry load and decrease stress within the cartilage

Describe micro-elastohydrodynamic lubrication?
- assumes the asperities of articular cartilage are deformed under high loads
- this smoothes out the bearing surface creates a film thickness of 0.5-1µm which is sufficient for fluid-film lubrication

Describe squeeze film lubrication?
- This occurs when bearing surfaces approach each other without relative sliding motion
- because a viscous lubricant cannot instantaneously be squeezed out from the gap between 2 surfaces that are approaching each other, pressure is built up as a result of the visious resistance offered by the lubricant as it is being squeezed from the gap
- the pressure is temporarily capable of supporting large loads before the fluid is squeezed out and surface contact occurs
- squeeze film may occur during Heel strike

Describe weeping lubrication?
- Tears of lubricant fluid are generated from the cartilage by the compression of bearing surfaces

Describe boosted lubrication?
- assumes that under squeeze film conditions, water of synovial fluid is pressurized into the cartilage, leaving behind a more concentrated pool of hyaluronic acid-protein complex to lubricate the surfaces

What lubrication occurs in prolonged standing?
- Boosed ( FF)
- Boundary lubrication
What is present on the surface of articular cartilage to protect against abrasion/ reduce?
- Monolayer of
- glycoprotein - lubricin
- Dipalmitoyl-phosphatidyl-choline ( phospholipid)
what lubrication is present in heel strike?
- Squeeze film
what lubrication is present in stance?
- Elastohydrodynamic lubrication and micro elastohydrodynamic lubrication
what lubrication is present in toe off?
- Weeping
- Micro EHD + Elastohydrodynamic lubrication
- Boundary
what lubrication is present in swing phase?
- Hydrodynamic lubrication
What lubrication occurs in PE on Metal?
- Boundary as fluid film is too thin
- only large metal on metal articulation show FF lubrication
- the effective radius determines the FF thickness
- a large effective radius increases contact surface area and decreases interface stress
- radial mismatch/clearance between femoral head and acetabular cup allow a large effective radius and so FF thickness
What is wettability?
- The relative affinity of a lubricant for another material
- measured by angle of contact at the edge of a drop of lubricant applied to the surface of the material
- ceramics have greater wettability cf metals due to hydrophilic
What factors determine lubrication?
- magnitude and direction of loading
- geometry of bearing surfaces/ surface roughness
- material properties of surfaces- wettability
- velocity at which bearing operates
- visocity of lubricant
What is corrosion?
- As unwanted dissolution of metal in solution resulted in its continued degradation
- electrochemical deterioration f metal happens when positive metal ions are rejected from a reaction site ( anode) and electrons are allowed to flow to a protected site ( cathode)
Why is insitu degradation of metal alloy implants is undesirable because?
- the degradation process may decrease the structural integrity of the implant
- the release of degradation products may elicit an adverse biological reaction in the host
Name the electochemical processes of degradation?
- Galvanic corrosion
- Crevice Corrosion
- Fretting corrosion
- Pitting corrosion
What is galvanic corrosion?
- 2 dissmiliar metals are electrically coupled together
- the difference in surface potential causes electron to flow between the 2 metals
- the greater the diff in potential the more the driving force exists for this to occur
- the more active allow becomes the anode and more noble metal the cathode
What is crevice corrosion?
- is the formation of a cavity or crevice where exchange in material from bulk solution is limited
- this results in change in the local environment
- the solution within the crevice will change leading to a decrease in the species required for oxygen reduction and a build up of aggresive species with a decrease in pH
- tighter crevices reduce the amount of electrolyte that must be deoxygenated and acidified and wil thus cause a more rapid attack
- after oxygen becomes depleted within the crevice the metal is oxidised and electrons migrate to areas outside the crevice where they are consumed in the reduction reaction
- particularly damaging to passive films on metal implants
What is fretting corrosion?
- Synergistic combination of wear and crevice corrosion of 2 materials in contact
- it results from micromotion between the 2, which disrupts the protective film of a metal
- movement can be as little as 3-4mm and is dependent on the contact load and frequency of movement
What is pitting corrosion?
- Localised corrosion attack in which small pits or hles from
- the pits ordinarily penetrate from the top of a horizontal surface downwards in a near-vertical direction
- insidous form of corrosion often going undetected and with very little material loss until failure occurs
- -> damage implant with substaintial release of metal ions
- can occur especially if solution has a low pH and contains chloride ions
- dissolution occurs within the pits, and oxygen reduction takes place on the adjacent surfaces
- electrons flow between the 2 sites- anode = small area of active metal and cathode = large passive surface of the remaining metal
What is stress ( fatigue) corrosion?
- Metals that are repeatedly deformed and stressed in a corrosive environment show accelerated corrosion and fatigue damage
What is intergranular corrosion?
- Metals have granular structure with grains being the term for areas of continuous structure
- grain boundary being the disordered areas between the grains
- the grain is anodic and susceptible, wheras the grain boundary is cathodic and immune
- alloys are more susceptible to intergranular corrosion than pure metals
What is intragranular ( leaching) corrosion?
- This occurs due to electrochemcial differences between the grains
What is inclusion corossion?
- This occurs due to inclusion of impurities, cold welding or metal transfer
- e.g metal fragments in screwdriver
What combination of metals is stable?
- Colbalt- chromium and ti alloy if absence of movement
What combination of metals is unstable?
- stainless steel with either CoCr or Ti
- with the steel being susceptible to attack