w2: Research in Clinical Psych Flashcards
why research?
- to build theories on development of disorders
- to design interventions based on those theories
-to evaluate the efficacy of these interventions
-to promote evidence-based practice
Clinical psychologist = scientist-practitioner
What is research?
Research is a systematic investigation to discover facts or deepen understanding of a topic.
—> rooted in the scientific method to study human behaviour- biological and social science focus.
= enhance human understanding
The scientific method:
purpose: pursue knowledge through systematic observation ensuring findings are replicable and testable.
- reproducible under controlled conditions by other researchers.
- precise measurements, detailed descriptions of methods
- objectivity, precise measurements, and replicability
- standardised data collection
Theory
a structured framework that explains phenomena, relationships, or processes based on empirical evidence and logical reasoning. It is a testable concert or set of ideas that helps describe, predict and understand aspects of behaviour, cognition, or mental health.
theory characteristics
-
Framework for understanding: provides way to organise observations and findings.
Ie. CBT theory explains the link between thoughts, emotions and behaviours. - Based on data and hypotheses: grounded in empirical research.
- Testability: theory generates testable hypotheses, can be confirmed or refuted.
- Predictive power: can predict future behaviours or outcomes based on known behaviours.
- Dynamic nature: are refined or rejected based on evidence. ie. Freud psychoanalytic theory being modified and replaced by newer, evidence-based approaches.
Role of theory in clinical psychology:
- Research guidance - guide development of research questions and hypotheses
-> Beck’s cognitive theory of depression led to studies testing effectiveness of cognitive restructuring. - Treatment development- help design interventions targeting specific mechanisms- behavioural theories and exposure therapy.
- Understanding psychopathology - can explain causes (aetiology) and maintenance of mental disorders. - biological theories- genetic predisposition ie schizophrenia.
- Practical Application: translate research findings into real-world clinical applications. ie. using reinforcement from behavioural theory to encourage positive behaviours.
Goal in Clinical Psychology Research:
Focuses on identifying, defining and categorising events and relationships related to psychopathology
goal
1.Description
2.Prediction- predict outcomes or identify risk factors that increase likelihood.
3.Control - understanding causal relationships to influence and alter behaviour to cognition for therapeutic purposes.
4.Understanding
—> how is this done:
Experimental psychopathology
utilises controlled experiments to explore mechanics underlying mental disorders and to test hypotheses systematically.
Features high internal validity, as it often isolates variables to establish causation, it may lack external validity due to laboratory settings.
- how various factors contribute to mental health conditions - deepen knowledge.
Experimental methods used in experimental psychopathology
1.Case Study (single-case experiment),
2.correlational design/ studies
3.prospective / longitudinal design
4.case-control study
5.treatment outcome study- randomised controlled trials, non random allocations/ quasi-experiment design.
Case Study:
an in depth investigation of a single individual, group, or event to explore specific aspects of psychopathology.
Key characteristics:
- focus on individual case- unique presentation of psychopathological symptoms.
- rich qualitative data- about patients mental state, life history, environment.
- often used to generate new hypotheses.
- lack of generalisability
- Applications:
◦ Useful for rare conditions (e.g., dissociative identity disorder).
advantages:
- hypothesis generation
- exploration of rare disorders
- challenge existing theories
limitations:
- Low internal validity
- low external validity
- observer bias
Single-Case Experiment
observers and measures behaviour before and after an experimental manipulation in one participant.
Design: ABA Designs:
A: Baseline (no treatment)
- behaviour is observed and mesured before any intervention is applied.
B: Intervention/ experimental manipulation.
- treatment is introduced and effects on behaviour are monitored.
A: Return to Baseline.
- intervention is withdrawn to see if behaviour returns to baseline.
- confirm if intervention was responsible for changes
Correlational Design/ Studies:
Research design aimed at identifying relationships or associations between two ore more variables.
- does not establish causation just correlation
Application: to explore relationships - ie. between anxiety, body dissatisfaction and eating disorders.
How correlational analysis works:
- data collection through measures
- analysis took - statistical software to calculate correlation coefficient r, and the statistical significance p.
advantages:
- solves problem of low external validity - can be used in both clinical and non-clinical populations
- high replicability
- mapping relationships
- exploring associations
limitations:
- no causation - correlation does not imply causation
- does not solve internal validity problem
- lack of mechanistic insight - don’t’ know why variables are correlated.
Internal Validity
refers to the extent to which a study can establish a causal relationship between the IV and the DV.
External validity
refers to the extent to which the findings of a study can be generalised to other settings, populations.
Prospective/ Longitudinal Design:
Longitudinal studies: measures the same participants at multiple time points, often over years or entire lifetime- track changes and relationships over time.
Prospective designs: similar to longitudinal studies but focus on collecting data at two or more specific points in time- ie. time 1, time 2. To predict future changes in variables
Key features in longitudinal and prospective design:
+ advantage and limitations
- Time-order relationships: allow researchers to observe whether one variable at time 1 predicts changes in another variable between time 1 and time 2.
- ie. Negative attribution style in time 1 predicts more depressive symptoms in time 2 - Identifying risk factors: helps determine which variables are predictors or risk factors for future outcomes.
- Advantage over cross-sectional designs (which don’t provide insight into causation or temporal relations but rather a snapshot). -> longitudinal and prospective track changes over time
Advantages:
- temporal clarity - determine whether one variable precedes another in time - strong evidence causal relationship
- risk factor identification - pinpoints early indicators of disorders.
- dynamic insight- tracks how variables change over time.
Limitations:
- causation still uncertain- causation requires experimental confirmation
- confounding variables - other unmeasured factors may contribute to results
- resource intensive- requires long term participants retention and significant time and funding.
Case-Control Study:
A case-control study is a type of observational research design. Involves comparing individuals with a specific condition or outcome to individuals without the condition to identity factors that may contribute to the condition.
Key features:
1. Group comparison- condition vs healthy control
2. Retrospective design- look back in time to examine exposure to risk factors or predictors.
3. Data collection - interviews, medical records, self-reports.
4. Outcome focus- assess associations b/w risk factors and development of the condition - not establish causation
advantages:
- clinically very feasible - study rare conditions or outcomes.
- efficiency- requires less resources and time
limitations:
- recall bias, selection bias
- no causal interference
- confounding variables
type of case-control studies.
Memory Specificity Training (MeST)
Psychological intervention designed to improve the ability to recall specific detailed autobiographical memories. - specifically for ppl with a overgeneralisation memory style - linked to many psychiatric conditions
features:
- focuses on retrieving specific events tied to specific place and time.
- overgeneral memory = I always feel sad, instead of being able to give specific memory
- participants presented with cue works -happy, sad-need to provide specific memories associated with them.
Application:
- address over general memory in depression, PTDS, anxiety
- improving emotional processing- enhances ability to access positive, specific memories.
Relevance to case-controls study:
- research: see if over general memory is more prevalent in the case group than control
- evidence base for MeST- individuals with overgeneralisation memory might be suggested to undertake MeST
- evaluating its function- see if the use of MeST improved depression at time 2
Treatment Outcome Study:
Designed to evaluate the effectiveness of an intervention or therapy for specific condition.
Key features:
1. Evaluation of interventions
2. Comparison groups: treatment group and control group.
3. Outcome measure - specific metrics for symptom
4. Study design:
- randomised control trials (RTC)
- non random allocation/ quasi-experiment design
-randomised multiple base line
treatment outcome study
Radomised control trials (RCT)- gold standard
randomly assigned to treatments to control group to minimise bias
- randomisation, balances groups- helps distribute confounding variables
- minimises bias, causal interference, internal validity.
- limitations- cost and resource intensive, ethical concerts of withholding medication, limited external validity.
treatment outcome study
non random allocation/ quasi-experiment design
non random assignment is used when randomisation is not feasible.
- groups made based on pre-existing characteristics or other non-random criteria.
- confounding variables, selection bias, no causal interference.
treatment outcome study
Randomised multiple baseline design
Single-case experimental design where treatment is applied to different behaviours, participants or settings at stagnated time points.
—> allows to observe changes specific to intervention while controlling for time-related factors
Key features:
1. Staggered introduction of interventions - treatment begins at different times for each participant
2. Baseline phase- multiple baseline measurements are collected before intervention - stable pattern of behaviour established.
3. Within participant comparison.
4. Randomisation to redice bias.
Analogue Studies
used to study processes and phenomena that closely resemble those found in clinical populations.
Used in experimental psychopathology to model clinical processes in controlled, simplified settings.
Aim to model aspects of mental disorders or treatment in a simplified way.
Studying stress-induction in healthy participants to understand anxiety mechanisms.
Clinical Trials
experiments that test the effectiveness of treatment such as comparing psychotherapy and medication.
Directly related to treatment outcome
studies.
Purpose: Tests the effectiveness of interventions (e.g., psychotherapy vs. medication) in real-world or controlled clinical settings.
Example: A randomised controlled trial (RCT) comparing CBT to antidepressant medication for depression.
Natural Experiments
observe effect of naturally occurring events in behaviour and psychopathology. - study populations exposed to uncontrollable events.
They focus on naturally occurring events (e.g., trauma, disasters) and their impact, often to explore the psychological effects rather than evaluate specific treatments.
Example: Observing the mental health outcomes of populations exposed to a natural disaster.
Systematic Review
structured process of gathering, evaluating and synthesising research to answer a specific question using explicit and standardised methods.
Example: Reviewing RCTs on PTSD therapies to identify best practices.
meta-analysis
statistical technique that aggregates data from multiple studies to assess the strength and consistency of findings.
Example: A meta-analysis examining the effectiveness of mindfulness-based therapy across dozens of clinical trials.
mediators and moderators
- mediators: variable that explains the mechanics linking the IV and the DV. If moving the mediators eliminates the IV-DV relationship, mediator account effect
ie. coping strategies - moderators: a variable that influences the strength of the IV-DV relationship
ie. client-therapist relationship
Qualitative/Quantitative
- qualitative= reply on verbal data instead of statistical analysis.
+ve: - rich data- deep insight into subjective experience
- flexibility, may guide future research
-ve - subjectivity
-limited generalisability - quantitative, precise measurement and statistical analysis.
Factors influencing choice of research
Nature of research question:
Causal relationship —> experimental design
Correlations or description —> qualitative or observational design
Population characteristics
- large, generalisable samples —>quantitative methods
- advanced stages —> quantitative methods
ethical concerns
Informed consent
Causing distress or withholding benefits
Privacy and confidentiality
Social constructionism !! Alternative framework in clinical psychology
- proposes that reality is socially constructed with no universal truths.
- individual constructs unique realities
- emphasises analysis language and social interaction and history of the patient as a key to understanding their experience.
- case-to-case approach
While the scientific method still remains dominant, to effectively treat patients, clinical psychology must account for individual differences and subjective realities.
Key responsibilities of a Clinical Psychologist:
- diagnosis and treatment
- therapeutic interventions
- monitoring and evaluation
- research contributions
- consultation and collaboration
Key responsibilities of a Clinical Psychologist:
Diagnosis and assessment:
Conduct comprehensive psychological assessments to diagnose mental health condition using:
- clinical interviews
- standardised psychological tests
- behavioural observations
ie. assessing client for depression using diagnostic tools like the Beck Depression Inventory.