Unit 6.2: Study Design Flashcards
What is Specificity?
- Refers to degree to which test is consistent and stable in measuring what it is intended to measure
- Refers to how close determined value is to actual value (depends on procedures/equipment used)
- Will depend on strictness of test conducted and individual’s motivation
- E.g. Endurance athlete doing Cooper’s 12 minute run to test aerobic power
What is Accuracy?
- Refers to degree to which test actually measures what it claimes to measure and extent to which conclusions/decisions are made on the basis of test scores being appropriate/meaningful
- Precision of data gathered
- Depends on instruments being used (must be accurate)
- E.g. hand timing a race won’t be as accurate as laser-timing
What is Reliability?
- Refers to how close a determined value is to the actual value
- Consistency of test scores over time and across alternative measurements
- Depends on procedures/equipment used
- reliable test -> produces same result if repeated
- E.g. Need to make sure improvement in performance in a fitness test is due to actual fitness improvement and not because there is learning/habituation effect on the test (McMorris -> 160 times repeating test)
What is Validity?
- Refers to ability of test to correctly indentify parameters which are most important in regard to the claims of the study: Does the test measure what it is supposed to measure?
- E.g. making basketball players run 100m will not tell us how quick they are in in a basketball game, where sprints are much shorter and repeated many times
What must be considered when designing an experiment?
- Causalty
- Control Group
- Randomization
- Placebos
- Blinding and Double-Blinding
- Statistical Analysis
What is Causalty?
- Relation between an event (cause) and a second event (effect), where second event is understood as consequence of the first
- Causation must be taken with care because:
1. Other factors could influence results (e.g. habituation, weather…)
2. Relationship between two variables does not necessary mean causation
What is the Control group?
- Group in experiment/study that does not receive treatment by researchers to be used as benchmark to measure how other tested subjects do
Explain control and experimental groups
- Must be identical in all relevant ways except for introduction of suspected causal agent into experimental group
- If suspected causal agent is actually causal factor of event -> event should manifest itself more significantly in experimental group than control group
What is randomization?
- A process used to select experiment participants when performing cause and effect experiment.
- Random allocation of individuals into groups
What is a placebo?
- A participant taking treatment that will not affect performance, used as control in testing new drugs
What is a blind experiment?
When participants do not know which group they belong to so they do not know if they are receiving placebo or substance under study
What is a double-blind experiment?
- When neither participants nor experimenters know who is receiving a particular treatment.
- Utilized to prevent bias in search results
Explain the importance of PAR-Q test
- Screening tool used to determine if participating in physical activity of test will put health/life of participant at risk
- Measures component of fitness required for individual to undertake physical activity
- Anyone looking to partake in exercise program should go through questionnaire
- Helps determine safety of test for participant
- If person answer no to all questions -> can participate
- If person answer yes to one or more -> must see doctor before undertaking physical test
What are advantages of field testing?
- More specific to performance environment
- Greater ecological validity, more motivation to perform at optimal level
- Less specialized technical equipment -> do not have to be an expert to manipulate tools
- Easier to test large sample size
- Cheaper than lab
What are disadvantages of field testing?
- Environment can alter results
- Much planning in testing administration
- Less advanced tools/technology
What are advantages of Laboratory testing?
- Greater accuracy and reliability of measured variable as well as tools used
- Greater control of environmental factors
- Stimulates sports demand
What are disadvantages of Laboratory testing?
- Not always accessible
- Limited value assessing team sports
- Not conducted in sport environment
What is maximal testing?
- When we want to know the maximal amount a person can do (e.g. VO2max ( maximal weight they can lift)
What are advantages of maximal testing?
- Measurements can be more accurate
What are disadvantages of maximal testing?
- Risk of injury/overexertion
- Difficult to ensure athlete is working to max
- Effort depends on athlete’s motivation
What is submaximal testing?
When athlete works below maximum effort and data is extrapolated to estimate maximum capacity
What are advantages of submaximal testing?
- Prevents injury/overexertion
- Safer and less stressful
- Can be completed quickly
- Easier to recruit participants -> more willing to participate
- Quicker recovery -> retesting occurs faster
- Correlation reasonably strong with aligned maximal tests
- Better for those such as children/elderly who find it difficult to reach maxinal levels
What are disadvantages of submaximal testing?
- Depends on extrapolation and then estimate of maximal performance
- Pacing/motivation required
- Correlation for some tests is reasonably poor
- Small measurement inaccuracies -> large discrepancies