Unit 2 - Ch. 2 Flashcards
What is ancestral environment?
An evolutionary term that refers to the hunter-and-gatherer era, from which most of our current-day adaptations are hypothesized to have evolved.
Cesare Lombroso
1835-1909 - Commonly known as the father of criminology. Argued that criminals possessed distinctive physical features that were often observed in his “normal” subjects. These features were referred to as “atavisms”. He suggested that criminals were evolutionary throwbacks who had more in common with Neanderthals than modern-day humans.
Charles Darwin
1859 - Natural Selection - Primary mechanism through which evolution created all species. Natural selection works by allowing the “trait” that bestowed a reproductive fitness advantage to be “selected” for in the sense that those with the trait lived long enough to procreate and pass it on to the next generation.
Francis Galton
Darwin’s cousin - misused Darwin’s natural selection theory - he founded Eugenics which is the theory that was responsible for forced sterilization of individuals deemed “unfit” to procreate in the United States during the 20th century and Hitler’s regime (forced abortion, sterilization, concentration camps).
Eugenics
Francis Galton - The belief that the evolution of the human species can be artificially improved by preventing individuals considered genetically “defective” from reproducing by methods such as forced sterilization.
Antisocial Personality Disorder (ASPD)
Official diagnosis defined in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5), referring to a constellation of antisocial behaviours occurring during adulthood that have persisted for at least six months. Sometimes ASPD is used interchangeably with psychopathy, albeit incorrectly.
Conduct Disorder
Official diagnosis defined in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5). It refers to a constellation of antisocial behaviours (e.g., stealing, getting into fights, using a weapon during a fight) occurring during childhood that have persisted for at least six months.
Psychopathy
Typified by a constellation of affective, interpersonal, and behavioural characteristics such as superficial charm, grandiosity, manipulation and lying, absence of remorse, inability to feel empathy, impulsivity, risk-taking, irresponsibility, and living a parasitic lifestyle.
Antisocial Behaviour
Generic term that encompasses a wide range of behaviours (e.g., hitting, slapping, punching, lying, cheating, stealing, running away, breaking and entering, homicide, and so forth).
Define theory (strong theory)
In sum, a theory is simply an explanation of a particular phenomenon, in this case antisocial behaviour. A strong theory:
1) is parsimonious (without excess - simple and straight-forward);
2) clearly identifies the causal mechanisms and corresponding mediators and moderators underlying the phenomenon of interest;
3) is testable and hence falsifiable via hypotheses and predictions;
4) is based on empirical data and is modified in response to new data;
5) possesses interdisciplinary compatibility; and
6) respects gender, ethnicity, and culture. Throughout this chapter, it may be helpful to ask, “Does this perspective provide a good theory of crime?” For example, are certain explanations stronger in the sense that the corresponding evidence is stronger?
Causal Mechanisms
Processes that directly cause a behaviour (i.e., factor X causes factor Y). In order to confirm the existence of a causal mechanism, a research design is needed that allows for the independent variable to be manipulated by the experimenter. Ethically, however, we are unable to do this most of the time. For example, if we wanted to know beyond a doubt whether child abuse causes crime, we would have to randomly assign children to one of two conditions—an abuse and a non-abuse situation, and clearly this is not an option. There are reasonable proxy designs that get us closer to causality, such as treatment studies that use random assignment or comparison groups as well as longitudinal designs that examine whether naturally occurring changes in variable X are related to changes in variable Y.
Moderators
Variables that cause the relationship between variable A and B to vary as a function of a third variable—the moderator.
Mediators
Variables that explain the relationship between variable X and Y. It might be concluded that variable X exerts its influence on variable Y through a third intervening variable—the mediator.
Neurotransmitters
The chemical messengers of the brain. They are stored in synaptic vesicles
Computer Tomography (CT)
Brain-imaging technique - Some researchers may use CT scans to assess whether the functions of the brain are somehow impaired in antisocial individuals.
How would behavioural genetics researchers conduct research?
Behavioural genetics researchers might employ twin methodology to ask whether identical twins are more likely to commit crime than non-identical twins.
How would molecular biologists conduct research?
Molecular biologists might compare the genetic makeup of a group of “criminals” to one of “non-criminals” to look for distinct genetic differences between the two.
How would researchers using neurochemical approaches conduct research?
Neurochemical approaches might examine how genes actually express themselves in terms of the brain’s neurotransmitter systems.
To examine the role that genetics play in criminal conduct, it is necessary to employ methodologies that….
…allow researchers to separate genetic and environmental influences.
Example:
A researcher asks 500 pairs of biologically related fathers and sons to complete a self-report criminal behaviour survey. The researcher then correlates the answers between fathers and sons and finds that the average correlation is .30. The question remains: Is the observed correlation due to fathers passing on “criminal genes,” or is it due to fathers passing on criminal attitudes and criminal life skills through years of living together? Unfortunately, this research design does not permit a clear answer. However, the field of behavioural genetics, which relies heavily on the study of twins and adoptions, can help separate genetic from environmental influences, at least to some degree.
Behavioural genetics
A sub-discipline of biology that studies how genes in humans and animals influence behaviour.
Every human shares about ____percent of his or her DNA sequence with the rest of the human species. The ____percent that we have in common is _____, accounting for our basic similarities. Behavioural genetics focuses on the remaining _____percent of the variance that is free to vary.
Every human being shares about 99 percent of his or her DNA sequence with the rest of the human species. The 99 percent that we have in common is fixed (not free to vary). Behavioural genetics focuses on the remaining 1 percent of the variance that is free to vary.
Monozygotic (MZ) or identical twins
They share 100 percent of their genes. The 1% of DNA that is free to vary from human to human is 100% identical for MZ twins.
Dizygotic Twins (DZ) or fraternal twins
No more alike than non-twin siblings, sharing about 50% of that 1% that is free to vary.
Concordance rate
Formally, the concordance rate is the percent of cases in which both members of a pair have a particular attribute.
Concordance rate is a statistical measure that describes the proportion of pairs of individuals that share an attribute, given that one already possesses this trait. A pair is considered concordant if they both possess an attribute of interest, and discordant if they differ. In psychology and other health-related sciences, the concordance rate is used to estimate the influence of nature (genetics) and nurture (environment) on a particular trait, disorder, or disease.
Concordance rates are typically converted into ______ - a descriptive statistic that represents the proportion of _______ variance in a given behaviour in a sample and/or population that can be attributed to genetic variation among individuals.
Concordance rates are typically converted into a heritability coefficient—a descriptive statistic that represents the proportion of phenotypic variance in a given behaviour (e.g., criminal) in a sample and/or population that can be attributed to genetic variation among individuals
Phenotypic
An individual’s observed properties or how one’s genotype is actually expressed. For example, a genotype may have a recessive gene for blue eyes but a phenotype may be for brown eyes.
Heritability coefficient
A descriptive statistic that represents the proportion of phenotypic variance in a given behaviour (e.g., criminal) in a sample and/or population that can be attributed to genetic variation among individuals
Biometric modelling
A more complex statistical approach to estimate heritability coefficients.
Statistical Modelling methods permit the estimation of two types of environmental factors:
- Shared environmental factors (aspects of the environment shared by all family members, such as living in poverty);
- Non-shared environmental factors (aspects of the environment not shared by all family members, such as exposure to different peer groups or different treatment by parents).
Genetic studies are just as much about _____ as they are about __________
- Genes
- Environment
Common criticisms levied against twin-studies?
It may overestimate (or underestimate) the genetic contribution for several reasons.
First, parents are more likely to provide similar environments for MZ twins than DZ twins.
Second, heritability estimates for MZ twins may be confounded by prenatal factors that by definition aren’t necessarily genetic. Example: MZ twins usually share one placenta and DZ twins usually have two separate placentas, thereby introducing a potential biological difference that is not necessarily genetic.
Also criticized for having small sample sizes and political influences (such as studies conducted in Nazi Germany).
Adoption research has taken one of two forms:
- Parent-Offspring adoption studies: In the parent– offspring paradigm, concordance rates (or correlations) between adoptive parents and adoptees’ antisocial behaviour are compared to concordance rates (or correlations) between biological parents and adoptees. If the concordance rates/correlations are higher for the biological parents and the adopted offspring than the adoptive parents and the adopted offspring, genetic contributions to antisocial behaviour are inferred
- Sibling-Offspring adoption studies: In the sibling–offspring paradigm, concordance rates between adoptive siblings are compared with concordance rates between biological siblings.
Mednick et al. (1984) performed a study on adoptions of 14427 non-familial adoptions between 1924-1947. What were the results?
- If both biological and adoptive parents had no criminal record, only 13.5% of adoptee sons had criminal records
- If the adopted parent had a criminal record and the biological parent did not, only 14.7% adoptee sons had a criminal record
- If biological parent had a criminal record but not the adopted parent, 20% of adoptee sons had a criminal record.
- If both adopted and biological parent had a criminal record, 24.5% of adoptee sons had a criminal record.
Rhee and Waldman (2002) completely a meta-analysis review of twin and adoption studies. What were the findings?
In sum, across all studies (involving a staggering 55 525 pairs of participants!), the variance in antisocial behaviour could be divided as follows:
-heritability (41 percent),
-shared environment (16 percent),
-and non-shared environment (43 percent).
Notably, the removal of potential outliers (e.g., eight studies involving psychopathy) did not alter the findings.
What does research increasingly show about the gene-crime link?
That it is not likely a direct conduit but rather a function of mediational effects of inherited characteristics that predispose an individual to antisocial behaviour (ie lower intelligence, impulsivity, ADHD).
Mediational effect?
In the parlance of researchers working on this problem, an indirect effect, also known as a mediation effect, refers to a situation where two variables of interest are associated via a third variable.
Antisocial behaviour often results from…
…a series of complex interactions between numerous factors that may seem benign on their own but in combination produce devastating consequences.
What is the exciting new avenue in the field of behaviour genetics?
Instead of simply studying the additive effects of “genes” plus “environment,” a new generation of behavioural geneticists are increasingly asking if there are interactive effects between genes and the environment: Is there a “gene” by “environment” effect?I
Interactive Effects
Effects that are known to be multiplicative, exponential, or synergistic rather than merely additive. Thus while psychopathy and sexual deviance may elevate the risk of sexual recidivism by two points, in combination, the risk of sexual recidivism may increase by six points. Or, alternately, the noise level generated by two young toddlers is interactive in that “one boy” plus “one boy” doesn’t equal two boys playing but seems more like six toddlers!
What were the findings in Jaffee et al. research about childhood maltreatment?
The evidence unequivocally demonstrates that childhood maltreatment (e.g., physical abuse, emotional abuse, sexual abuse, neglect) contributes to the development of antisocial and criminal behaviour. What is less clear is why 50 percent of maltreated children do not engage in delinquency, aggressive behaviour, or criminality
In a prospective follow-up study of 1116 five-year-old British twin pairs, children were classified along a genetic risk continuum (e.g., from low to high risk). In sum, the authors reported that the experience of maltreatment increased the probability of receiving a conduct disorder diagnosis by 1.6 percent among children deemed “lowest genetic risk”. However, the probability of receiving a conduct disorder diagnosis increased to 23.5 percent among children deemed “highest genetic risk.”
Twin and adoption studies illustrate that there is a _________ between _________ and ________. However, the actual functional gene(s) involved has __________.
- clear link
- genetics
- antisocial
- not been identified
What is the main function of a gene?
To produce proteins comprised of amino acids - the basic building blocks of life.
Amino acids?
The basic proteins of life that are essentially the precursors to neurotransmitters. Amino acids are converted into neurotransmitters via enzymes.
What are proteins ultimately responsible for?
The phenotypic expression of our genotype.
Genotype
An individual’s complete genetic makeup regardless of whether a particular gene has a visible influence on an individual’s functioning or behaviour; what’s on the “inside” versus the “outside.”
Faulty genes typically do one of two things:
Produce too much or too little of a particular protein.
Human genes are stored in ____ chromosomes (____pairs)
- 46
- 23