Unit 2 Assessments and interventions Flashcards
Not common in OBM literature. May be due to :
• interventions are effective without Assessment,
* Rule-governed behavior * OBM is concerned with “increasing”behavior vs. decreasing behavior
Functional Assessment
Records review
Informant assessments—interviews
with staff and managers
Descriptive assessment (e.g., ABC
analysis)
Experimental analysis (structural,
functional analysis
Types of Functional Assessments
Planning documents
Organization chart
Industry productivity standards
Industry conditions
Competitors
Customer list
Product/services
Employee handbook
Job descriptions
Records Review: Historical Data -OBM
An analysis of events that precede
and follow a pinpoint
Conduct for both the undesired and
desired pinpoint
Two basic formats
The data sheet can be open-ended
or contain antecedents and
consequences common to the
performance.
Open ended requires more skilled
data collectors
A-B-C Analysis
Must observe behavior Occurring- problematic if major concern is a behavior that Rarely occurs.
Time consuming
targets Results
What makes A-B-C difficult?
Very Little in the literature.
Therrein,systematically varied five Antecedents in a restaurant to assess for influence on customer greeting;
Two of the five that occasioned high levels of greeting were combined into an intervention that increased customer greeting. Note: To achieve a satisfactory increase a final feedback condition was necessary.
For experimental analysis ) in OBM
Accurate
Advantage Experimental analysis – OBM
- time consuming
- requires Frequently occurring behavior,
- requires expertise.
Some disadvantages of experimental analysis are that:
do not rely on the behavior Occurring to determine the function, but they are likely the Least accurate.
interviewing staff members,
Two types of Interviews
Structured- follows a Script
Unstructured-interviewer develops a list of topics ahead of time, but informant answers determine which direction the interview takes
We will Use a structured interview.
Make sure the staff member is Relaxed. (start with ‘grand tour question’),
Reinforce their responding
Don’t allow for Attacks
Don’t use behavioral Jargon
Give them time to answer, general to specific,
End with: ‘Is there anything else you think is important?’
Some good interviewing techniques to
An interview assessment that covers Four areas that could contribute to performance problems.
One of the most Common assessment tool in the OBM literature.
Performance Diagnostic Checklist (PDC)
- Is there a written job Description
- Have the employees received adequate Instruction about what to do?
• Are the employees aware of the Rational of the behavior as it relates to the organization?
-If yes can they Explain the rationale?
• Are there job aides visible while completing the job?
-If yes, what are they?
Are there frequently updated, challenging, and attainable Goals that employees are comfortable with?
-If yes, do employees feel these goals are Fair? If employees say that the goals are NOT fair, what reasons have they stated?
PDC-Antecedents
If equipment is required, is it reliable?
Is it in good working order?
Is it ergonomically correct?
If no, what is?
Is the equipment and environment optimally arranged in a physical sense
Are larger processes suffering from certain
incomplete tasks along the way (process
disconnects)
Are these processes arranged in a logical
manner, without unnecessary repetition
Are these processes maximally efficient?
Are there any other obstacles that are keeping the employees from completing the task?
PDC Equipment and Processes
Can the employees tell you what they are supposed to be doing and how to do it?
If yes have they mastered the task?
If fluency is necessary, are they fluent?
Can the employees physically/verbally
demonstrate completion of the task?
If yes, have they mastered the task?
If fluency is necessary, are they fluent?
Do the employees have the capacity to learn
how to complete the task
PDC-Knowledge and Skills
Are they delivered contingent on the task?
If so, provide examples of the consequences.
Are they Positive or negative
Are they Immediate , Frequent
Consistency/probability?
Are there Premack Reinforcers?
- If yes, what reinforcers are used?
Do the employees see the effects of their performance?
- if yes, How? Are they natural Arranged?
Supervisors should deliver them. Best if they are available.
- Direct or indirect Feedback
Is there performance monitoring?
- If yes, self-supervisor direct (verbal)
supervisor indirect (written)
Is there a RESPONSE EFFORT associated with the performance?
Are there other behaviors competing with the
desired performance?
PDC-Consequences
Sample uses from the literature
Franchise restaurants
Ski shops
Coffee shops
Implementation generally delivered to managers and
employees
In larger organizations, or in a business with multiple sites it can be delivered to relevant managers and
sample staff
PDC
If the PDC shows Decrements in
Antecedents…
-Keep in mind:
• role of antecedents. They don’t function independently of the consequences.
• Few examples of effective antecedent only interventions
An antecedent intervention consists of manipulations before the behavior occurs.
broadly defined as
antecedents that encourage
engaging in a task
Examples:
Smiley faces
Have you washed your hands?
Remember to clock out for breaks
Job Aides—
“Are there Job Aides Visible While
Completing the Job?”
Highly detailed set
of instructions on what is expected
Can be:
A memo
Checklist
Meeting/workshop
Task Clarification:
PDC Antecedent Interventions
-A list of activities in sequential order that need to be completed
.
-Conduct a task analysis of a task and place the tasks in order of occurrence
Found to be successful with simple and complex tasks. Perhaps especially useful for complex jobs:
Pilots
Physicians
Antecedent Interventions
Checklists
Clearly identify when to use it
Simple wording
Not too lengthy
One page
Test them out first
The Checklist Manifesto
An antecedent that describes an expected level of performance. That is, what is required by the
company
Sometimes include timelines
Employees need to know what is
expected
In a PM-designed business, it signals when reinforcement can be obtained—not that punishment is available for failing to make the goal
Goal
Difficult , yet obtainable
• Stay away from stretch goals
Under the control of the employee
Good goals
Create an ultimate goal and sub goals
Sub-goals allow for the shaping of behavior so that employees can contact reinforcement
Small reinforcers for the sub-goals
Large reinforcer for the ultimate goal
Lots of verbal praise for increasing performance
if the goal is much higher than current baseline levels
Too easy, too hard?
Watch for new problems arising from an increase in behavior (out og paper)?
quality of the performance? Consider adding qualifying statement
Increase requirements when met for several
consecutive sessions
Make sure employees have contacted reinforcement before increasing
Do not reinforce lower ones once a new, higher one has been set
Keeping an eye on your goals
Patterns will likely be different if
introducing new behavior or setting a
goal for a long-standing behavior:
- Slow and steady - Seep increase followed by leveling off - Slow increase followed by steep increase
Patterns of Increasing Behavior
Can the employees tell you what they are supposed to be doing and how to do it?
-If yes have they mastered the task?
If fluency is necessary, are they fluent?
Can the employees physically/verbally
demonstrate completion of the task?
-If yes, have they mastered the task?
If fluency is necessary, are they fluent?
Do the employees have the capacity to learn how to complete the task?
PDC-Knowledge and Skills
Training (and is a common solution to many organizational problems. Many times the problems are due to an environment without properly aligned antecedents and consequences
Training is an antecedent intervention and shouldn’t be expected to solve these types of problems.
Very expensive and time consuming
Classroom-An instructor teaches a
group of individuals typically by lectures, worksheets, tests, and occasionally role-play/rehearsal
Behavioral Skills Training (BST)-An instructor teaches skills using verbal antecedents, modeling, rehearsal, and feedback
Select the training that makes the most sense in terms of:
Number of staff to be trained
Is opportunity to practice in real-life
essential (e.g., CPR)
How often will they use the information
Types of Training
Advantages:
-Many people can be taught at once
Disadvantages
-: Questionable retention/generalization, limited ability to practice skills
Useful for:
-Large number of employees (initial training)
- A lot of information to teach (be careful)
Classroom Training- OBM
Procedures: Set clear learning objectives Deliver a pre-test Provide instruction Evaluate
Typically delivery methods includes: Lecture Watching videos Internet Conferences
Classroom
Avoid passive attendance by audience
members (i.e., pure lecture/video
provided by the instructor)
Generally, provide the rationale, and
specific aspects of the job skill from the
learning objectives
Deliver material in a succinct and
interesting manner
Consider classroom management
strategies for some groups
Consider the use of Active Student
Responding (ASR)
Instruction in Classrooms
Promoting responding in the audience during instruction
-allows the instructor to receive ongoing feedback
Types:
Response cards
Guided notes
Choral responding
ASR In the classroom
A key component appears to classroom instruction
Can be somewhat difficult to achieve in a classroom setting
Role-playing or
Evaluation of video models may allow for this
Performance Feedback-Classroom instruction
Some skills can be acted out
Have employees complete a skill as
taught and provide feedback either during or immediately after the performance
Consider using mastery criteria
Role-play
Evaluating video models performing
behavior (Williams & Gallinat, 2011)
Employees evaluate correct and incorrect elements of a performance
May be especially useful for skills that do not occur often, or skills that are difficult to role-play
While watching, employees evaluate performance with assessments tools
Typical tools include checklists, or other
evaluation tools used on the job
Provide feedback on the accuracy of recording
Vary the scenarios: different employees, situations, tools, etc.
Video Modeling
Advantage
Can be done on the job and perhaps
facilitate generalization
Disadvantage
Time-consuming
Useful for:
Employees can’t demonstrate skills
Increase fluency
BST
- Provide instruction-verbal or written
- Model the performance for employee
- Have employee engage in activity and provide immediate feedback on correct and incorrect
elements of performance - Set mastery criteria—this will depend on the behavior but consider 3 consecutive demonstrations with 100% accuracy
- Repeat modeling and rehearsal until criteria are reached
BST Procedure
A rate of accurate performance
Some jobs require it
Typically helpful with most job duties
Assists with retention (Bucklin)
Methods:
Additional practice with a time component after a skills has been learned
- time drills
-SAFMEDS
Fluency
Experts train supervisors who then
train staff
Page, Iwata, & Reid (1982)
- supervisors were trained on
evaluating teaching behaviors These supervisors trained 45 staff members . Replicated using peers to
train peers
Caregivers were trained to respond to
emergency situations (e.g., fire response)
These caregivers then taught other caregivers to respond to emergency situations
- Benefit: Trainer maintenance
This approach may be very effective, but make sure there is reinforcement programmed in for the staff trainers (i.e., it is not just extra work)
Pyramidal Training
Provide feedback!
If a behavior is not used frequently consider making opportunities available to engage in the behavior:
Ie: video tapes, simulated drills, etc
After Training
New staff members in a residential
setting with a three week pre-service
Skills required by the state were taught in a classroom
Fluency measures incorporated after mastery criteria were met
BST follow-ups were completed on the floor
On-going feedback
Pyramidal training through supervisors when new material was introduced
Created opportunities for low-occurrence behavior
Data collection
A Sample Training Program
for new Staff
They are Set by:
Looking at internal performers
Input from managers and employees
Customer requirements
Baseline levels of performance
External competitors-careful
Industry standards-careful
Goals
Are there reminders to Prompt the task at the correct time/duration?
Is the supervisor present during task completion?
PDC – Antecedents
Can the employee learn to
complete the task in a time that is
feasible in the current setting
If not, consider changing the job (can
anyone learn this) or reassign to
another position
Employee training
PDC-Equipment and Processes
If equipment is required, is it reliable?
Is it in good working order?
Is it ergonomically correct?
If no, what is?
Is the equipment and environment optimally arranged in a physical sense
PDC – equipment and processes
Examining and designing the interaction with equipment and workplaces to fit employees A person sitting at a desk typing on a computer Problems with equipment can cause long-term problems
Ergonomics
Are larger processes suffering from
certain incomplete tasks along the way
(process disconnects)
Are these processes arranged in a logical manner, without unnecessary repetition
Are these processes maximally efficient?
Are there any other obstacles that are keeping the employees from completing the task?
PDC-Equipment and Processes
As defined by Rummler and Brach
1995):
“A series of steps designed to produce a product or service”
Results in products/services for customers, products for the business to operate, or actions that support the other processes.
Many flow through Departments. They are not Departments (Production department).
Should have a goal and formal structure, but is not
always the case, Otherwise problems like repetition and disconnects are possible.
**This is the REALM of behavioral systems analysis
Process