topic 8: Issues & Debates Flashcards
define the ‘nature’ view
the view that behaviour is the product of innate biological/genetic factors
define nurture
the view that behaviour is the product of experiences and environmental influences
define the nature vs nurture debate
the relative importance of heredity and environment in determining behaviour and human development
define free will
the idea that we can play an active role in behaviour and have a choice in how we behave
define determinism
the view that free will is an illusion and that our behaviour is governed by internal/external forces which we have no control over
define the free will vs determinism debate
the origins of our decisions, choices and behaviours and the extent to which they are influenced by free will or other identifiable forces
what is hard determinism
the view that forces out of our control (biology/past experience) shape our behaviour
it identifies specific causes of behaviour and is seen as incompatible with free will.
has 3 forms: psychic, environmental, biological
what is soft determinism
all events and human behaviour have causes, but behaviour can also be determined by our conscious choices in the absence of coercion
what is psychic determinism and what evidence supports it
suggests human behaviour is the result of childhood experience and innate drives as a result of unresolved conflicts
psychodynamic approach
Little Hans
what is environmental determinism and what evidence supports it
suggest behaviour is determined by factors outside of the individual, env. determinism assumes our behaviour is caused by previous experience/learning
Learning theories
Bandura Ross+Ross Bobo doll
what is biological determinism and what evidence supports it
suggests that all human behaviour is innate and determined by genes with research identifying factors such as genes/hormones/neurotransmitters
Biological Approach
OCD and the SERT gene
give arguments for the argument of free will vs determinism
determinism
–unfalsifiable even tho it seems scientific
it’s bc it’s based on the idea that causes of human behaviour will exist, which is impossible to disprove and popper said falsifiability is a feature of scienxe
+ it’s in line with the study of science and the goals in studying psychology by saying that behaviours have a measurable cause
using these types of techniques has led to treatments, therapies and beh. treatment that have helped many (eg. Sz)
free will
+ evidence suggests that the perception of free will is better for us
a study found that ppl with internal LoC are more mentally healthy and Roberts et al. found teens with a strong belief of fatalism were at sig. higher risk of dev. depression
– contradictory evidence from Soon et al.
when asked to press a button using L/R hand, brain activity linked to making that choice is detected up to 10s before making that decision
suggests: we believe that we are freely making a decision but our brain is actually determining it before we are consciously aware of them
what is alpha bias
when researchers over-emphasize differences between males and females
what is beta bias
when researchers ignore or downplay differences between males and females
milgram, asch, zimbardo
what is cultural bias
the tendency to ignore cultural differences and interpret all phenomena through the lens of one’s own culture
milgram, Ainsworth, asch
what is ethnocentrism
a form of cultural bias, if left unchecked it can lead to an imposed etic
imposed etic - imposing your cultural views and expectations onto others, intentionally or unintentionally
cultural relativism
idea that cultures can only be understood from within that culture i.e. by taking an emic approach
universality
any underlying characteristic in human beings that can be applied to all despite difference is experience and upbringing, this is threatened by gender and culture bias
define culture
values, beliefs and patterns of behaviour shared by a group of people
how is milgram’s experiment culturally biased and what was found in other cultures
shocks
used an American sample
included all cultures would have similar obedience but American traditions and values are diff. to non-western and he ignored that other factors could influence obedience in other cultures
variation:
the experiment was repeated a south african sample
obedience rate of 87.5%
how is ainsworth’s experiment culturally biased and what were the results of a non-culturally biased version of the study
the strange situation
american, individualist sample
she assumed that the SS could be used to identify the main attachment types in individualist and collectivist cultures, ignoring the varying child rearing practices
variation:
van ijzendoorn + Kroonenberg
looked at SS done in:
Japan - higher insecure-resistant
germany - higher insecure-avoidant
but these may not actually be insecure, but actually a healthy attachment ideal in that culture
how was Yerkes’ study culturally biased
just before WW1, Yerkes developed army intelligence tests to assess recruits. The items were very specific to American culture and the test results showed european immigrants fell slightly below white americans and african-americans were at the bottom of the scale, with the lowest mental age
this had a real impact on african-americans and was linked to segregation
evaluate cultural bias
– Yerkes showed how dangerous culturally biased research can be as his had a real had a real impact on african-americans and was linked to segregation
+ we have evidence of cultural bias
Smith and Bond reviewed european social psychology textbooks and found that 32% of studies were european, most were american and 2% were the rest of the world
this suggests cultural bias is identifiable and therefore addressable via cultural relativism; Berry said we need more emic studies
+ indigenous psychologies; theories that draw explicitly on particular experiences of people in different cultural contexts eg. afrocentrism: suggests that all black ppl have african roots and should consider the african context of behaviour and attitudes
culture bias might not be as relevant now
critics suggest that today, with more global comm. and interconnectedness, we cant simply differentiate into individualist vs collectivist
takano and osaka found 14 of 15 studies on USa vs Japan found no ev of the trad distinction
what is androcentrism
when something is focused on or dominated by, males/the male viewpoint