Theorists - Class and Educational Achievement Flashcards
Key Theorist - Adonis and Pollard (1998): Class and Educational Achievement
WHAT DOES THEIR THEORY DO?
- Explain the differences in educational outcome due to the middle being able to afford private education.
Key Theorists - Adonis and Pollard (1998): Class and Educational Achievement
WHAT IS ONE OF THE POTENTIAL ISSUES WITH THIS THEORY?
- This doesn’t account for the class differences within state education.
Key Theorist - Douglas (1964): Class and Educational Achievement
WHAT DID THIS THEORY FIND?
- Working class children had a lower result on the IQ test.
- Working class parents spent less time with their children doing educational activities.
- If parents cannot afford to send their child on education trips, then the child’s motivation will decrease.
Key Theorists - Bereiter and Engleman (1966): Class and Educational Achievement
WHAT DOES THIS THEORY ARGUE?
- Language in a working class home is poor.
- Families communicate by gestures, single words or ungrammatical sentences.
Key Theorist - Bernstein (1975): Class and Educational Achievement
WHAT DOES THIS THEORY IDENTIFY?
- Differences between the language that working class and middle class students use.
Key Theorist - Bernstein (1975): Class and Educational Achievement
WHAT DOES THIS THEORY ARGUE?
There are the following two speech codes:
- The restricted code – typically used by the working class. It has limited vocabulary and is based on the use of short, often unfinished, grammatically simple sentences.
- The elaborate code – typically used by the middle class. It has a wider vocabulary and is based on longer, more grammatically correct sentences.
Key Theorist - Bernstein (1975): Class and Educational Achievement
WHICH CLASS DOES THIS THEORY ARGUE ARE BENEFITTED, AND WHY?
- The middle class because classroom dialogue, exams and textbooks and written in an elaborate code.
Key Theorist – Feinstein (1998): Class and Educational Achievement
WHAT DOES THIS THEORY ARGUE?
- Working class parents have a lack of interest in education was the main reason for their child’s education underachievement more than the material deprivation.
- Middle class are more successful because parents provide them with the necessary motivation, discipline and support.
Key Theorists – Sugarman (1970) and Hyman (1967): Class and Educational Achievement
WHAT DO THEY BOTH BELIEVE?
- A pupil’s culture is a ‘self-imposed barrier’ to educational and career success.
Key Theorists – Sugarman (1970) and Hyman (1967): Class and Educational Achievement
WHAT DOES SUGARMAN BELIEVE?
The working class has the following four features that act as a barrier to educational underachievement:
- Fatalism – a belief in fate and the attitude that ‘whatever will be will be’ and there is nothing a person can do to change their status.
- Collectivism – valuing being part of a group more than succeeding as an individual.
- Immediate gratification – seeking pleasure now rather than making sacrifices if it gives you rewards in the future.
- Present-time orientation – seeing the present as more important than the future and therefore not having long term goals.
Key Theorist - Howard (2001): Class and Educational Achievement
WHAT DID THIS THEORY FIND?
- Among the working class, students had a lower intake of energy, minerals and vitamins and a weak immune system.
Key Theorists - Tanner et al (2003): Class and Educational Achievement
WHAT DID THIS THEORY FIND?
- That there was a heavy burden on working class families, such as transport, uniform and books.
Key Theorist - Flaherty: Class and Educational Achievement
WHAT DID THIS THEORY FIND?
- There is a stigma around free school meals – only 20% of those who can access it do access it.
Key Theorist - Ridge: Class and Educational Achievement
WHAT DID THIS THEORY FIND?
Many parents of working class families only have part time employment.
Key Theorist - Bourdieu (1984): Cultural Capital
WHAT DOES THIS THEORY BELIEVE?
- Both cultural and material factors affect educational attainment.
- The middle class possess both cultural and economic capital.
- Cultural capital supports the knowledge, attitudes, values, language and tastes of the middle class.
- The education system is ethnocentric.