The Nature and Dynamics of Hannibal's Leadership Flashcards
Hasdrubal’s death
221
Causes unrest across Iberia
What did Hannibal do after Hasdubal died?
Called an assembly of his men
How old was Hannibal when he was chosen to lead Carthage’s Iberian Army?
26
Why did Hannibal attack Saguntum?
To break the Treaty of Ebro
What was Hannibal’s first priority?
Securing control of Iberia
What does Polybius make clear about Hannibal before he marched onto Saguntum?
Hannibal wanted to deal with the threat of Iberia
Tagus battle
Due to unrest after Hasdrubal’s death
Hannibal uses war elephants to cross the Iberian enemies as they crossed the river,
Destroyed the 100,000 strong force with his cavalry (Polybius)
Ambassadors about Saguntum
Polybius
Saguntines sent messengers to Rome
Rome sent ambassadors to Hannibal and told him to stay away from Saguntum
Hannibal accused the Romans of unjustly executing some leading citizens, and said Carthage did not ignore those who were treated unjustly and Saguntum was using its Roman alliance to cause unrest.
Polybius then gives a long opinion about how Hannibal did not give the true opinions and should have just asked for Rome to return Sardinia.
What significance did New Carthage have?
It was the Carthagian capital in Iberia
What did Hannibal reply to the Roman delegation?
- He was looking after the interests of the Saguntines
- Accused the Romansof having unjustly executed some leading citizens
- The Carthagian would not ignore this breaking of the treaty, for it was an ancient custom of Carthage not to ignore anyone who has been treated unjustly
What did the envoys of Rome realise about the meeting with Hannibal?
That there must be war.
What did the envoys of Rome do after their meeting with Hannibal?
They sailed to Carthage to make the same protests to them. The protest being:
* To stay away from Saguntum
* Not to cross the River Ebro
Who was Livy?
A Roman historian writing at the end of the first century
His Histories cove the foundation of Rome through to the Civil War and the creation of the Empire
Aimed to celebrate the glory of Rome
Portrays Hannibal as the villain, but has a gruding respect for him
Flaws:
- His poor geography
- His aristocratic prejudices
- He simplifies and exaggerates the wars
Uses other sources from Polybius, and claims his are more accurate
Used sources that no longer exist
Where were the Romans planning on having their base in the case of war?
Did it ever come to fruition?
- Saguntum, Spain
- It never came to be because Hannibal took the war to Italy
What does Livy have wrong with the geography?
Hannibal travels in the wrong direction after crossing the Rhone
Which Roman leaders does Livy have a prejudice against?
Which does he praise?
- He attacks Flaminius and Varro
- He likes Paullus and Sempronius
What are the benefits of the problems that Livy has when writing?
It improves the story and creates a gripping tale
Livy’s Siege of Saguntum
Fullest account
Authentically questionable as it uses first century siege tactics and lacks potential sources
What is the differance between Livy’s and Polybius’ accounts of the Siege of Saguntum?
Polybius gives a simpler account
How does Polybius say Hannibal defeated Saguntum?
Hannibal starved the people untill they surrendered
Despite their differances, what does both Livy’s and Polybius’ account give an insight to?
How the ancient sources represented Hannibal’s leadership
Describe Hannibal’s leadership in the siege of Saguntum
- Distributes money from selling slaves among men
- Works on the siege works
- Resilient, keeps up the siege despite wounds and failing to destroy the walls
- When Hannibal broke the walls, falarcia flaming javalin, inflict great casualties. Hannibal uses African miners to destroy the walls
- Built a fort inside the city
- Harsh terms: surrender wealth, arms, and settle in a new place, or women and children enslaved and men killed
- Saguntimes refuse, Hannibal sets fire to the city, and sells the valuables and survivors to fund his invasion of Rome
- Livy probably deliberately put Hannibal in a bad light. He takes pleasure in the suffering of others, and his men are mercenaries motivated by gold, not brave legionaries.
What is a falarcia?
What damage could it do?
- A large javelin that had tar at the end which would be set alight
- It could pierce armour and set fire to enemys with it’s tip
Ah, ha!
Why did the war not take place in Spain, but Italy?
Rome was already fighting Illyria
Hannibal’s swift defeat of Saguntum took eight months, and Rome’s preparations for war were not complete
Livy says the siege was shorter or began earlier.
What did the Romans do after hearing the fate of Saguntum?
Immediately chose envoys and sent them to Carthage, telling them to hand Hannibal and his advisors over or war would be declared
The Carthagians declared Rome was the aggressor as it had seized Sicily and the Treaty of Ebro was between Rome and Hasdrubal, not Carthage
Rome’s preparations after the fall of Saguntum and the declaration of war
Created six legions to travel to Iberia, Afria, and Sicily
Publius Cornelius Scipio was sent to attack Iberia.
Tiberius Sempronius LLongus was sent to attack Carthage and Sicily
What reasons does Polybius give Hannibal for attacking Saguntum?
He says that Hannibal attacked Saguntum to seek revenge for the Romans capturing Sicily
What do modern historians say why Polybius gave reasons for Hannibal attacking?
To make the reader accept Hannibal’s guilt in starting the war
What does Polybius say about the Carthaginians before the war started?
- The bitterly resented their defeat in Sicily
- They were further provoked by the affair in Sardinia
- They didn’t like the size of the increased indemnity which they had finally been compelled to agree to pay
- They had subdued the greater part of Spain
- They were ready to sieze any opportunity that presented themselves for revenge againt Rome
How was war decided?
Polybius
The chief Roman envoy pointed to his pocket and told the Carthaginian Council that in it he had both war and peace, and said he would leave them with whichver of the two they ordered him to leave with.
The lead Carthaginian ordered the Roman to decide.
The Roman chose war.
They then parted on the terms.
How did the Carthaginian Council react to the Roman chosing war?
Polybius
They immediately shouted that they accepted it