The Liberal State, c1911–18 Flashcards
What does liberalism mean? (in the 20th century)
A viewpoint or ideology associated with free political institutions and religious toleration, as well as support for a strong role of government in regulating capitalism and constructing the welfare state.
Examples of unsuccessful events/policies from 1896 that shows Italy as divided
𝟭𝟴𝟵𝟲 - Italy defeated by Abyssinian forces at the Battle of Adwa.
𝟭𝟴𝟵𝟲 - Around 2% of the Italian population spoke Italian.
𝗠𝗮𝘆 𝟭𝟴𝟵𝟴 - Protests against Italy’s undemocratic and corrupt political system and economic turmoil leads to 100 killed in Milan.
𝗝𝘂𝗹𝘆 𝟭𝟵𝟬𝟬 - King Umburto I assassinated.
𝟭𝟵𝟬𝟬 - The government ended internal tariffs to support free trade (but this actually damaged southern Italy).
𝟭𝟵𝟬𝟬-𝟭𝟵𝟭𝟭 - There were 9 governments.
𝟭𝟵𝟬𝟭-𝟭𝟵𝟭𝟭 - There were over 1,500 strikes in Italy.
𝟭𝟵𝟬𝟭-𝟭𝟵𝟭𝟯 - 200,000 Italians left southern Italy each year, in part because of the extreme poverty
𝟭𝟵𝟬𝟯-𝟭𝟵𝟭𝟭 - Giolitti became Prime Minister on 3 separate occasions.
𝟭𝟵𝟭𝟬 - Italian Nationalist Party formed, supporting Imperialism as a way to achieve Italian glory through violence and war.
𝟭𝟵𝟭𝟬 - eruption of Mount Vesuvius had a damaging effect on the southern economy.
𝟭𝟵𝟭𝟬/𝟭𝟭 - 25,000 people died in Naples (southern Italy) of cholera, and half the population were illiterate in that area.
When was Italy defeated by Abyssinian forces at the Battle of Adwa?
1896
When did only 2% of the Italian population speak Italian?
1896
When were there protests against Italy’s undemocratic and corrupt political system and economic turmoil, leading to 100 killed in Milan?
May 1898
When was King Umburto I assassinated?
July 1900
When did the government end internal tariffs to support free trade? (actually damaging southern Italy)
1900
In what period were there 9 governments?
1900-1911
In what period were there 1,500 strikes in Italy?
1901-1911
In what period did 200,000 Italians leave Southern Italy each year? (in part because of the extreme poverty)
1901-1913
In what time period did Giolitti become PM on 3 different occasions?
1903-1911
When was the Italian Nationalist Party formed?
1910
When was the eruption of Mount Vesuvius that damaged the southern economy?
1910
When did 25,000 people die in Naples due to cholera?
1910/11
In 1896, how much of the Italian population spoke Italian?
Only 2%
What happened in May 1898?
Protests against Italy’s undemocratic and corrupt political system and economic turmoil led to 100 killed in Milan.
In 1900, what did the government do?
Ended internal tariffs to support free trade (but this actually damaged southern Italy).
How many governments were there between 1900-11?
9 governments
How many strikes were there in Italy from 1901-1911?
Over 1,500
From 1901-1913, how many Italians left southern Italy each year, in part because of the extreme poverty?
200,000 Italians
How many separate occasions did Giolitti become Prime Minister on between 1903-1911?
3 separate occasions
What did the Italian Nationalist party support?
Imperialism as a way to achieve Italian glory through violence and war.
In 1910/11, how many people died in Naples (southern Italy) of cholera?
25,000
Describe Italy from 1896-1911
Politically unstable and divided, but modernising
Examples of successes from 1896 for the Liberal government and the Italian people
𝟭𝟴𝟵𝟵-𝟭𝟵𝟭𝟬 - Industrial production doubled
𝟭𝟵𝟬𝟬 - radicals and republicans won only 34 and 28 seats respectively (good for Liberal govt) although they were still considered a threat because of their base in the north of Italy.
𝟭𝟵𝟬𝟬-𝟭𝟵𝟬𝟳 - government expenditure doubled on public works.
𝟭𝟵𝟬𝟰 - Giolitti refused to crush general strike in northern Italy which actually fell apart after a few days because of a lack of organisation (good for Liberal govt)
𝟭𝟵𝟬𝟰 - Nitti introduced a law to stimulate industrial growth in Naples.
𝟭𝟵𝟭𝟭 - Literacy rates had improved (37.6% illiteracy as opposed to 69% in 1870)
𝟭𝟵𝟭𝟮 - Universal manhood suffrage was introduced.
In what time period did industrial production double?
1899-1910
When did radicals and republicans won only 34 and 28 seats respectively? (good for Liberal govt)
1900
When did a general strike in northern Italy fall apart after a lack of organisation?
1904
When did a general strike in northern Italy fall apart after a lack of organisation?
1904
When did Nitti introduce a law to stimulate industrial growth in Naples?
1904
By what time had literacy rates improved, from 69% illiteracy in 1870 to only 37.6% illiteracy?
1911
When was universal manhood suffrage introduced?
1912
From 1899-1910, what happened to industrial production?
It doubled
What happened in 1900 with radicals and republicans and why were they still a threat?
Radicals and republicans won only 34 and 28 seats respectively (good for Liberal govt) although they were still considered a threat because of their base in the north of Italy.
What happened to government expenditure from 1900-1907?
Government expenditure doubled on public works.
In 1904, what happened to a general strike in northern Italy?
It fell apart, due to a lack of organisation.
What did Nitti introduce in 1904?
A law to stimulate industrial growth in Naples.
What happened in 1905?
Tommaso Tittoni became PM for one month
In 1911, how had literacy rates improved?
37.6% illiteracy as opposed to 69% in 1870
What happened in 1912 regarding suffrage?
Universal manhood suffrage was introduced
How many of Italy’s 2.2 million industrial workers were employed in the northern provinces of Lombardy, Liguria, Piedmont/Milan Genoa and Turin?
Half of Italy’s 2.2 million industrial workers. They accounted for 55% of industrial income.
Overall, what was Italy like by 1911?
In the early 20th century, Italy was a slowly modernising country, but one that had deep, geographical and economic divisions. The economy was not as industrialised as other European powers and southern Italy remained largely agricultural and poor.
Any reforms that were implemented by the Liberal government were unable to effectively heal division within Italian society. As a result, many people migrated to countries such as America, looking for a better way of life.
The Italian political system was weak as well, particularly the system of Trasformismo, which newer political parties were able to exploit at the expense of the Liberals.
Despite all its weaknesses and division, Italy still appeared to be a great colonial power, however by 1911 this looked increasingly unlikely.
What was Trasformismo?
The method of making a flexible, centrist coalition government which isolated the extremes of the left/right-wing in Italian politics. Political dealings.
Describe the Liberal Party 1896-1914
Not a structured party. They were, instead, a series of informal, personal groupings with no formal links to political constituencies.
What was the Roman question?
Used to describe the split between the Italian state and the Catholic Church, which refused to recognise Italy as a state.
“A dispute regarding the temporal power of the popes as rulers of a civil territory in the context of the Italian Risorgimento”.
Risorgimento
Unification of Italy as a new nation in 1870
Irredentism
Movement that sought to bring under Italian rule various lands that were considered to be culturally, linguistically or historically Italian, but were not included in the unified Italian Kingdom of 1870.
Italy’s unification would only be complete if ALL Italian speaking lands were incorporated (e.g Trieste and Fiume)
Redemption of Italian territory.
When was the Associazione Nazionalista Italiana (ANI) formed? - nationalists
1910
What were the four different groups Giolitti had to deal with 1911-1914?
- Socialists (PSI)
- Nationalists (ANI)
- Catholics
- Radicals and republicans
What happened when the ANI was formed in 1910?
Brought the Nationalists together under the leadership of Corradini. By 1914, it had huge support.
Who was the leader of the ANI when it formed in 1910?
Corradini
In the 1913 election, who won a quarter of all votes? How many deputies did they have in parliament?
The PSI and had 79 deputies in Parliament
(this was a lot of votes and was going to be a problem for the Liberal government)
What did Socialism’s growth in popularity mirror?
Mirrored Italy’s industrialisation as the population of Italy’s northern cities expanded due to internal migration.
How was cooperation between the Catholics and the Liberals most evident in 1911?
At a local level - Catholics were part of governing coalitions in Turin, Bologna, Florence and Venice. The Church also had considerable influence in the north of Italy.
By 1911, how many of Italy’s 2.2 million industrial workers were employed in the northern provinces of Lombardy, Liguria and Piedmont?
HALF of Italy’s 2.2 million industrial workers - shows divisions between North and South.
The South was far less modern. How much wealth did it account for?
The South accounted for only 27% of the wealth in Italy.
Were the ANI willing to work with the Liberals?
NO.
The ANI were not willing to work with the Liberals, making them incredibly difficult to deal with. They were the party MOST opposed to Giolitti’s policies, favouring steady colonial expansion, a stronger army, a ban on public sector strikes and stronger police powers.
What were the ANI’s beliefs?
- Favoured steady colonial expansion
- Favoured a strong army
- Wanted a ban on public sector strikes
- Wanted stronger police powers
- Wanted an AGGRESSIVE foreign policy to claim lands in Africa and claim irredente lands.
Was Giolitti’s programme of placating the PSI (by offering moderate social reform) successful?
It was partly successful, particularly with moderates like Filippo Turati. But Giolitti found it increasingly hard to win over the entire PSI because the maximalists in the socialist party (one of whom was Mussolini) wanted to overthrow the state.
Why did Giolitti find it difficult to win over the entire PSI party?
The maximalists in the socialist party (one of whom was Mussolini) wanted to overthrow the state.
Giolitti’s invasion of Libya in 1911 was done primarily to…
neutralise the threat of the Nationalists.
Why did the Nationalists become an increasingly influential political movement 1911-1914?
Because of the humiliating defeat for the Italians at Adwa and the shame of poverty of Italy meaning many Italians were emigrating for a better life.
When was the PSI formed?
1892 - it was one of the few formal political parties
What does PSI (Socialists) stand for?
The Partito Socialista Italiano
What did Giolitti announce in 1904 about the Church?
Giolitti announced the Church and state were “two parallel lines, which should never meet”.
Giolitti’s attempt to boost Italian support for his leadership through modernisation and economic reform failed to…
halt the rise of nationalism.
What did the nationalists see Giolitti as?
Corrupt and weak
1911-1914: Who was the leader of the PSI?
Filippo Turati
From 1911-1914, what did exports increase by?
4.5%
Intellectuals and politicians tried to understand the Questione Meridionale…
Why was the south so backward and poor?
In the 1913 election, what did the Pope do?
Swung his support in favour of Giolitti
What did Giolitti do with reforms?
Giolitti enacted a series of reforms to allow workers to strike and hold peaceful protests.
By 1910, how many Catholic worker’s unions were there?
374
By 1910, how many peasants did the Federation of Agricultural Workers represent?
240,000 peasants
This is good from Giolitti
How did Giolitti try to deal with the Socialists?
Via trasformismo by offering a variety of social reforms like state-subsidised sickness and an old age fund for the merchant navy. Leading socialist Leonida Bissolati was even offered a place in Giolitti’s cabinet (but he declined).
Who did the Nationalists have support from?
A number of educated middle class supporters who viewed it as a force for national renewal, which would undermine the increasing support for the socialists, destroy the corruption of the current system, and bring in new dynamic Italy.
Although Giolitti wanted the support of the Church to help with his parliamentary majority, who was he more concerned with gaining the support of?
The Socialists
How was Giolitti unable to reduce tension between the Church and state?
He was not willing to give the Pope any concessions on Roman territory and so was unable to solve the “Roman question” which still festered at the heart of tension between Church and state.
What did many believe about Risorgimento?
That it had failed, and only Socialism could solve Italy’s problems of political corruption, persistent rural poverty and the widening gap between the ruling elite and working class.
Between 1901 and 1911, how many strikes had there been?
1,500 strikes
Between 1910 and 1911, how many people died from Cholera in Naples? (south)
25,000
What did Giolitti do in order to improve literacy rates?
Placed responsibility for primary schooling on central government.
What did many Italian Socialists believe?
That Giolitti’s reforms were aimed at avoiding instability rather than actually helping the poor.
What did Giolitti implement to help improve the situation for Italy’s poor?
Policies, such as raising the minimum working age to 12 years and reducing food taxes to make food more affordable.
What did Giolitti reduce to make food more affordable?
Food taxes
1911-1914: What was Italy often seen as?
“the least of the Great Powers”
What were the maximalists of the PSI?
A left-wing offshoot of the PSI that were more extreme. They despised the Liberal state and believed in violent revolution.
What did Giolitti’s compromises with the PSI do?
Brought him into considerable conflict with the Catholic Church and the Nationalists as they opposed socialism.
But by 1914, what was life expectancy and illiteracy like?
Italians had the same life expectancy as other Europeans and the national average for illiteracy was 37.6%.
In 1912-13, how many Italians emigrated?(mostly from the south)
Around 1.5 million
What was Giolitti’s most important concession to the socialists and when was this?
1906
When he brought in a new policy of non-intervention in labour disputes and courts to settle pay disputes.
How was Giolitti, in a sense, the first PM to win the organised Catholic vote?
Giolitti did offer concessions to the Church in return for support e.g he promoted Catholic interests in education.
L’ASINO: What did the magazine cover suggest about Giolitti as a politician and people’s attitudes towards him?
- Translates to the donkey - suggests he’s stupid
- He appeals to different people
- He’s not relatable
- He appeals more to the rich
- Changes to adapt - not genuine and two-faced
- He’s not trustworthy
- Tried to appeal to Catholics, socialists and nationalists. Might be clever, manipulating, expedient and corrupt.
- He was certainly a significant political force in 20th century Italy.
Who was Italy allied with in the Triple Alliance? Why was this a problem?
Germany and Austria Hungary.
Created a difficult situation as Italy and Austria’s interests overlapped in the Balkans.
Why did Italy invade Libya September 1911?
- In an attempt to create a more aggressive foreign policy and wanted to assert its dominance in North Africa to compete with France (imperialism).
- Pressure from the Nationalists.
- France was consolidating her control over Morocco and Giolitti was worried that France would invade Libya next which would be of considerable embarrassment to Italy, as Italians saw Libya as a country that should be part of their empire and under no circumstances should it be French.
- The Catholic Church also had considerable financial interests in Libya, causing them to encourage the government to invade.
For Giolitti therefore, invasion of Libya would be a way of uniting the Italian people behind his government by gaining support of both the Catholics and Nationalists.
When Italy invaded Libya in 1911, who was Libya under control of at the time?
The Ottoman Empire
When did Italy invade Libya?
29th September 1911
How did people react to the invasion of Libya in September 1911?
It was greeted with an outpouring of national enthusiasm.
Describe the initial successes of the Libyan campaign
- Met with an outpouring of national enthusiasm.
- Italy’s navy had seized all ports and coastal towns within three weeks.
- 70,000 troops were committed to the invasion.
- On the 8th October, Libya was formally handed over to the Italians by the Ottomans.
It appeared that Italy and Giolitti had won a great victory, especially as this was Italy’s first colony overseas. By 1912, it appeared that Giolitti’s programme of creating a unified Italy had been successful.
Libya 1911: Within three weeks, what had Italy’s navy done?
Seized all ports and coastal towns
Libya 1911: How many Italian troops were committed to the invasion?
70,000
When did the Ottomans formally hand over Libya to Italy?
8th October (1911
Libya 1911: Describe what was appearing by 1912
It appeared that Giolitt’s programme of created a unified Italy had been successful. His social reforms had pacified the PSI who were now prepared to support his government, and the Catholic Church was co-operating with the Liberals in several key areas .
What did the victory in Libya initially seem to do for the government?
Seems to galvanise nationalistic support for the government.
Overall, initially, what did the Libyan War do to relations between Catholics, PSI and ANI?
Pleases the Nationalists and Catholic Church. Not so much the PSI, he pacifies them instead.
Libya 1911: However, how did relations with the Nationalists actually turn out?
The war did not actually help Giolitti absorb the Nationalists. Rather, it increased support for the ANI, who claimed credit for the policy and led to them demanding more from the Liberal government.
Libya 1911: However, how did relations with the Nationalists actually turn out?
The war did not actually help Giolitti absorb the Nationalists.
How were the ANI able to capitalise on dislike of Giolitti?
They claimed that his handling of the war was mismanaged and had led to a huge loss of life (3,500 Italians died)
How many Italians died in the fighting of the Libyan War 1911?
3,500
How much did the Libyan War cost Italy?
1,300 million lire
How did the war destroy Giolitti’s cooperation with the PSI? (which had been key to his programme of Trasformismo)
The PSI argued that Italy’s wealth was being wasted on foreign campaigns.
Libya 1911: Who ended up forming an alliance and why was this bad for the socialists and Liberal government?
The Catholics and the nationalists formed a temporary alliance which weakened the moderate socialists to the extent that the revolutionary wing of the party seized control, ruling out further cooperation with the Liberal government. Any moderate socialists were expelled from the party. Giolitti’s attempts to absorb the socialists into the liberal state had ended in failure.
After the invasion of Libya, what did Giolitti realise he had to do?
Realises he needs to extend the franchise as support was high, people fought for your country etc. Thought by giving more people the vote, they would vote for him.
Giolitti’s problems after the Libyan war were exacerbated by…
the extension of the franchise.
Extension of the franchise: Who did Giolitti have to give the vote to?
- Men who had fought in the war, so all men who had completed military service
- All men over 30 could vote by 1912
Extension of the franchise: After Giolitti had extended the franchise, what did it mean for Italy’s electorate?
Meant 70% of Italy’s electorate were now illiterate
By extending the franchise, what did Giolitti hope would happen?
He hoped that extending the franchise would increase the popularity of the Liberals as men in more rural areas (more conservative) could now vote.
Extension of the franchise: What showed the failure of Giolitti’s strategy?
The 1913 election
How did the 1913 elections show the failure of Giolitti’s choice to extend the franchise?
- Liberal deputies won 318 seats, a loss of 71 from the 1909 elections.
- The PSI now had 20% of the vote
- The conservative peasants were voting for the Catholic Party rather than the Liberals. This meant Giolitti was now RELIANT on CATHOLIC SUPPORT, especially as he had promised to make concessions to the Church in return for their support.
In the 1913 elections (after extension of the franchise), how many seats did the Liberals win?
318 seats, a load of 71 from the 1909 elections
Shows failure of the franchise extension
In the 1913 elections (after extension of the franchise), how many seats did the Liberals win? (showing failure of franchise extension)
318 seats, a loss of 71 from the 1909 elections.
In the 1913 elections (after extension of the franchise), how much of the vote did the Socialists now have?
PSI now had 20% of the vote (huge number)
In the 1913 elections (after extension of the franchise), who were the conservative peasants actually voting for?
The Catholic Party rather than the Liberals. This meant Giolitti was now RELIANT on CATHOLIC SUPPORT, especially as he had promised to make concessions to the Church in return for their support.
After the extension of the franchise and 1913 election, what was now impossible and why?
Trasformismo was now impossible as the Socialists and the Nationalists would not work with a Liberal government that was making concessions to the Catholics. They don’t like his concessions.
This saw Giolitti stand down in the spring of 1914. He was seen as the leader of a weak liberal government that alienated everyone but the Catholics.
When did Giolitti resign as Prime Minister after the failures of Libya and franchise extension?
21st March 1914
Why did Giolitti resign in March 1914?
- Socialists and radicals withdrew their support for his coalition government
- Extending the franchise had led to a situation where mass suffrage meant that actually nationalists and Catholics got the most support
- Trasformismo was not working
- Libya ended up as a failure
By 1914, a wall of opposition had built up against Giolitti and his political methods. His alliances had fallen apart and he was losing support from many parties.
Negative consequences of the Libyan war:
- Increased support for the Nationalists as the ANI claimed credit for the policy and led to them demanding more from the Liberal government. ANI also capitalised on dislike of Giolitti by claiming he mismanaged the war. Lost total support of ANI over Libya.
- Loss of life - 3,500 Italians died fighting.
- Cost 1,300 million lire.
- Destroyed Giolitti’s cooperation with the PSI which had been key to programme of Trasformismo.
- The Catholics and Nationalists formed a temporary alliance which weakened moderate socialists and increased the influence of maximalists in the party. Maximalists took control of PSI.
- Franchise extension meant Liberals lost seats and socialists won 20% of the vote.
- Socialists and nationalists unwilling to work with Giolitti as he was making concessions to Catholics.
Giolitti resigns as PM in March 1914.
Libya produced the same crops as Italy therefore…
fall in crop prices.
Libyan war: What did emigrants refuse to do?
Emigrants refused to move to Libya to start an Italian colony.
Who was Giolitti replaced with after he resigned in March 1914?
Antonio Salandra
What was Antonio Salandra like as a PM after replacing Giolitti?
His support floundered, and by June 1914 Italy seemed to be on the verge of anarchy. The outbreak of World War One would be yet another challenge for Salandra in the years to come.
Summarise the successes of Libyan invasion in 1911
Looked like the invasion had been a success. Both the PSI and Catholics were co-operated with the Liberals, Italy seemed unified.
What were the problems facing Italy from by 1911 categorised into?
- Political problems e.g limited franchise
- Economic problems e.g northern and southern Italy having different wealth
- Social problems e.g illiteracy
Political problems facing Italy by 1911: Why was limited franchise a problem?
Not until 1912 that the vote was extended to most adult men. Many Italians felt alienated from the political system.
Political problems facing Italy by 1911: What began to grow as a response to the growth of socialism and disillusionment with the Liberal government?
Nationalism
Political problems facing Italy by 1911: Who was seen as a threat by the Liberals? Why?
Radicals and Republicans - because their base in the north of Italy and their desire to overhaul the political system was threatening.
Political problems facing Italy by 1911: Why did the Liberals face growing competition after 1912?
They only represented the professional classes, not the bulk of the population
Political problems facing Italy by 1911: What were the liberal politicians afraid of?
The weakness of the ruling class in the south and peasant discontent as a result of this.
Political problems facing Italy by 1911:Why was Trasformismo such a problem?
Political parties were so weak that factions were formed to make coalitions known as Trasformismo. This led to instability as they easily fell apart.
Political problems facing Italy by 1911: How many governments were there between 1870 and 1915?
20 different governments
Political problems facing Italy by 1911: What did the socialists do against Liberals governments?
Often formed coalitions of opposition against Liberals governments whom the viewed as the party of the elite.
Political problems facing Italy by 1911: Why was the Catholic Church hostile to the new unified Italy?
A significant amount of land was taken from the Church (the Papal States) and so most Catholic politicians withdrew from political life, paving the way for Liberal Italy to dominate. Only in 1913 was an alliance formed between Catholics and Liberals.
When was an alliance formed between Catholics and Liberals?
1913
Political problems facing Italy by 1911: What was a problem with MPs?
Known as Deputies, they often served local interests rather than national ones. This meant they often switched political allegiance and were open to bribes.
Social problems facing Italy by 1911: What percentage of Italians were illiterate in 1870? Where were rates higher?
More than 69% of Italians were illiterate in 1870. Rates were higher in the south.
Social problems facing Italy by 1911: What was limited and localised?
Industry was limited and localised due to lack of resources and poor transport and communications.
Social problems facing Italy by 1911: What damaged the economy in southern Italy and what angered people further?
A series of natural disasters in southern Italy damaged the economy and led to anger amongst the people at the lack of aid provided by the government.
Social problems facing Italy by 1911: What was increasing in the south that led to disease?
Poverty was increasing in the south, leading to diseases like cholera and typhus. The main killers here were TB (tuberculosis) and malaria.