Test #1: 3-5 Flashcards
Define social actions
-actions that have meaning attached and are oriented towards the past, present or future behaviour of others
Who came up with the idea of social action?
Weber
What does Week 3 focus on?
What determines our actions:
-structure vs. agency
-different paradigms for social action
(all paradigms are under the umbrella of social action)
What is structure and what is agency?
- structure is the idea that our actions are the products of external forces that exist beyond our comprehension
- agency is the idea that we act based on our free will
Who made the unit act?
Parsons
What was the first way Weber saw social action being studied?
-positivist, closer to science, explains action through external causal forces, like Durkheim (macro)
Was Weber against macro extremism?
-No, but he did believe they were incomplete
What paradigm did Weber create in response to macro extremism?
- Verstehendesoziologie
- social actions can be explained by identifying the subjective meanings that motivate them
- meanings can be attached to ends/goals and means/methods
What did Weber create in addition to verstehen?
-ideal types of actions based on different meanings associated with ends and means
What are the four ideal types?
- instrumental-rational
- value-rational
- traditional
- affectual
Did Weber believe all actions were rational?
-No, he believed they were on a spectrum
Rate the ideal types from most rational to least?
-Instrumental, Value, Traditional, Affectual
What was instrumental rationality?
- means and ends are both rational
- getting a job to make money
What is a core part of all forms of action theory?
-rationality and the inherent assumption that peoples actions are rational
What was value-rationality?
- one of either means/ends are rationally calculated
- then the other means or ends is not rational but instead based on values
- helping the poor because its our value to help the community
What was the ideal-type, traditional?
-both means and end are irrational
-just doing what we have always done
-
What was the ideal type, affectual?
- both means and end are irrational
- we’re driven by emotion
Where does rational choice theory sit?
-it is a whole strain of theory underneath action theory with the primary focus on rationality
Define rational choice theory
-actors enter situations with pre-existing goals and access to resources and make choices aimed at maximizing utility
Define utility
-acquiring more resources or accomplishing more goals
What two assumptions is rational choice theory made on?
- choices are made independently using rational calculation
- actions are caused by their anticipated consequences
What is the basis for modern economic and legal theory?
-rational choice theory
What are criticisms of rational choice theory?
- not everyone has rationality and what may be rational to one person may not be to another
- if people are making choices independently, why do societies look so rule bound?
- where do actors get their ultimate ends?
What does the criticism, where do actors get their ultimate ends, mean?
- I want money because I want a house because I want a family etc. etc.
- what is the end goal?
How does utility answer the criticism of ultimate ends?
-says that utility is the attainment of pleasure and avoidance of pain
What was Parson’s attempting to do when looking at the three approaches (positivism, utilitarianism, idealism)?
-trying to make a general theory of action
What did Parson’s notice about RTC and utilitarianism?
It’s weakness:
-rational choices may look different for one person than it does for another
What typology did Parson’s come up when trying to understand the differences between different types of actions?
Pattern variables/axes:
-all actions can be plotted along five different axes
What were the five different axes?
- affectivity-affectivity neutral
- self-orientation-collectivity oriented
- universalism-particularism
- ascription-achievement
- specificity-diffuseness
What was the axes affectivity-neutral?
-how emotional is the action?
What was the axes self-orientation-collective orientation?
-Are we acting for or the greater good?
What was the axes universalism to particularism?
-Is it unique to one individual or universal across a society?
What was the axes ascription to achievement?
-Is the action based on who we are or what we have achieved?
What was the axes specificity to diffuseness?
-Is it narrowly defined or multifaceted?
How actions fall on the 5 axes depends on what?
-social, cultural and personality systems
What was the ultimate ends for Parsons?
-cultural values or norms
What criticism does Parson’s ultimate ends raise?
- that people aren’t in control of their actions
- ultimately, the way they act is the way society tells them to act
What does the utilitarian perspective see for ultimate ends?
-all action is intended to maximize pleasure and minimize pain
What does the normative/culture perspective see for ultimate ends?
-action is guided by cultural norms or values