Task 5 Flashcards
Positron emission tomography (PET
Measured variations in cerebral blood flow (glucose, …)
Radioactive substance is injected (tracer, usually radioactive oxygen H215O or the recently found PiB to diagnose Alzheimer’s), which emits radiation that is monitored. The greater the blood flow in a region, the greater the signal emitted by the tracer in that region.
The gamma rays that are produced when the a positron and an electron collide (substance decays and emits a positron from the atomic nuclei). The PET scanner is therefore rather a gamma ray detector.
Results are reported as a change in regional cerebral blood flow (rCBF) between a control and an experimental condition
Where there is more blood flow, there will be more radiation
PET measures relative activity, not absolute metabolic activity
Metabolic activity is resolved in regions / voxels (5-10mm
PET imaging requires sufficient time to detect enough radiation to create images of adequate quality . The participant must be engaged continually in a single given experimental task for at least 40 s, and metabolic activity is averaged over this interval.
Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI)
Imaging focuses on the properties of deoxygenated hemoglobin (deoxyhemoglobin), which is paramagnetic compared to oxygenated hemoglobin.
fMRI measured the ratio of oxy- to deoxygenated hemoglobin (blood oxygen level-dependent = BOLD)
Active areas show an increase in oxygenated hemoglobin (opposite as expected) because the amount of blood directed to that area increases, causing an over-availability and excess of oxygen.
Indirect measure of activity via BOLD
why the BOLD response increase only multiple seconds after stimulus onset.
While neuronal processes occur within milliseconds, changes in blood flow occur much slower
block design
the recorded neural activity is integrated over a “block” of time during which the participant either is presented a stimulus or performs a task. The recorded activity pattern is then compared to other blocks that have been recorded while doing the same task or stimulus, a different task or stimulus, or nothing at all.
Event-related design
across experimental trials, the BOLD response will be linked to specific events such as the presentation of a stimulus or the onset of a movement. That way, a clear signal can be obtained by averaging over repetitions of these events.
Limitations of PET and fMRI
Poor temporal resolution
(PET= decay rate of tracer, FMRI= dependant on hemodynamic changes that underly bold signal)
Difficulty interpreting data
(Data sets are massive and many differences arise in comparisons between experimental and control conditions)
Correlation ≠ Causation
PET= signal is vague and active areas are not necessarily critical
FMRI=Bold signal is rather drive by inpur then output
causation can not directly be implied , but fmri is helpful in establishing functional connectivity
(f)MRI vs. PET
+Scanners are less expensive & easier to maintain
+ No radioactive tracers are needed and the same individual can be tested repeatedly
+ Higher spatial resolution (high resolution anatomical images)
+ Testing can be completed fast (under 1h)
+ Better discrimination between grey and white matter
- PET is less susceptible to signal distortion
While PET measures the blood flow, fMRI measured the concentration of oxygen in the blood. => both Hemodynamic measures
Structural imaging
Measures of the spatial configuration of different types of tissue in the brain (principally CT and MRI)
Based on the fact that different types of tissue have different physical properties that can be used to construct a static map of the physical structure of the brain
Most common methods are CT and MRI
Functional imaging
Measures temporary changes in brain physiology associated with cognitive processing; the most common method is fMRI and is based on a hemodynamic measure
Based on the assumption that neural activity produces local physiological changes in that region of the brain which are used to create a dynamic map of neural activity
PET
Based on blood volume Involves radioactivity Participant is scanned only once Temporal resolution = 30s Spatial resolution = 10mm Must use a blocked design Sensitive to the whole brain
MRI
Based on blood oxygen concentration
Involves magneticity
Participant is scanned multiple times
Temporal resolution = 1-4s
Spatial resolution = 1mm (depends on size of voxel)
Can use a blocked and an event-related design
Some brain regions are hard to image
CT
- Constructed with X-ray absorption of different tissue types (amount of absorption is related to tissue density)
- Used in clinical settings to identify tumours, …
- Cannot distinguish between white and grey matter as good as MRI can and cannot provide any functional images
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)
To obtain MRI scans, the following sequence is applied:
- Strong magnetic field is applied across the brain (strength is measured in Tesla – the more Tesla (T) the stronger the magnetic field)
- Single protons (found in water molecules) have their own (weak) magnetic fields and will align with the magnetic field that is produced by the scanner
- The aligned protons are hit with a radio frequency pulse that knocks their original orientation by 90 degrees and makes them spin / precess. Before you apply this pulse, the protons are in the same direction but do not spin in the same precessing phase. By applying the pulse, we set all the protons in the
- The spinning protons produce a detectable change in the magnetic field and this is what forms the basis of the MR signal
- The scanner will pull the protons bac into their original position and let them relax and then repeats the whole process
Different types of images can be obtained with this method: (MRI)
- Images that distinguish tissues / structural images: variations of the rate at which the protons return to the aligned state (T1 relaxation time: measures how quickly the protons give back the energy to the tissue. This happens faster in fatty tissues which causes them to appear whiter in the scan then water tissues)
- Functional images (fMRI): in the misaligned (90°) state, the MR signal decays because of local interactions with nearby molecules (T2 component: measures how quickly the spins diphase again, T2* is sensitive to the oxygenation in the blood). Because the deoxyhaemoglobin produces more distortions because it is paramagnetic and is attracted to the magnetic field. The oxygenized haemoglobin is diamagnetic.
- Voxel-based morphometry (VBM
= A technique for segregating and measuring differences in white matter and gray matter concentration
Divides the brain into many regions (=voxels) and estimates the concentration of white/gray matter in each voxel
Here we can see the structure if the brain
- Diffusion tensor imaging (DTI)
Uses MRI to measure white matter connectivity between brain regions
We use diffusion weighted imaging and can see the connectivity of the brain
water molecules trapped in axons tend to diffuse in some directions but not others. With functional anisotropy, we can find out to which extend diffusion takes place in some directions more than others.
Hemodynamic response function (HRF)
Hemodynamic response function (HRF) = how the BOLD signal evolves / changes over time in response to an increase in neural activity. It has 3 phases:
1) initial dip: because of consumption, when neurons eat oxygen deoxyhaemoglobin increases at first and therewith reduces the BOLD signal (0-2s)
2) overcompensation: In response to the increased consumption of oxygen, the blood flow to the region increases. This increase is greater than the consumption, leading to an excess of oxygen at that region. This is the component of interest in fMRI (6-10s)
3) Undershoot: blood and oxygen dip before returning to their original levels (relaxation), causing a temporary increase in deoxyhaemoglobin. We do not have to wait for the BOLD response to return to baseline in order to present another trial, because different HRFs can be superimposed. Many experiments do wait until it returns to baseline (16-20s)
Safety and ethical issues in functional imaging research
risks
Risks are small but a bit higher in PET (due to the radioactivity used).
In fMRI, large magnets (>3T) can cause dizziness and nausea (enter the field gradually to avoid this). Also, fMRI is very loud (120dB), so all participants must wear earplugs
exclusion criteria
PET: pregnant women and children
fMRI: people with metal body parts, implants, pacemakers, women wearing contraceptive coils, people suffering from claustrophobia, etc. cannot participate, no eye make-up, no metal spectacles or metal objects in general
To minimize individual differences, the date of many participants is averaged in the following way:
- Stereotactic normalization = mapping of individual differences in brain anatomy onto a standard template
- Smoothing = Redistributing brain activity from neighbouring voxels to enhance the signal-to-noise ratio
- Flow diagram: summarizes the sequence from initial hypothesis to data interpretation
furthermore participants are instructed to keep still as possible , they’re heads are restrained -becasue moving the head could lead to regions being harder to detect or false-positve results
voxel
a volume-based unit (cf. pixels, which are 2D); in imaging research the brain is divided into many thousands of these
The BOLD signal is more sensitive to
neuronal input than to output (sensitive to post-synaptic potential vs. action potential – similar to EEG). It could therefore be that areas that simply receive input (“listen”) appear to be active.