Strategic Theory Flashcards
Clausewitz quote
“War is the continuation of politics by other means”
Define armed conflict
The use of armed force between two parties, concerning government and/or territory, which results in at least 25 battle-related deaths in one calendar year
What are the FIVE main types of armed conflict?
Interstate, intrastate, internationalised intrastate (external force supports non-state actor), non-state, one-sided violence
Why has conflict declined according to Steven Pinker?
Humans have simply become better people
Reporting bias
State where violence took place responsible for counting casualties, so can give inaccurate or misleading figures
Define motivation
Desire to act in a certain way e.g. attack another nation for territorial gain
Define opportunity
Logistical tools that allow one to pursue their motivation e.g. new weapon technology or fast transport links
Example of increased opportunities
Industrial revolution railway expansion
Britain 1830: 125 miles of railway track
Britain 1871: Over 13,000 miles
Define bargaining theory
Just because states have different ideas or different interests, this does not mean that they will go to war
Bargaining model shows how states can avoid conflict through negotiations
What are the FIVE assumptions of bargaining theory
Actors prefer better over worse outcomes
Actors consider each other’s preferences
Compromise can be found
Both sides need to perceive conflict as costly
All costs are known to both parties
The bargaining range
Any deal where the territory gained is greater than the territory it would’ve gained through war, once the costs of war are subtracted
What is gained by proving resolve?
Acts that are a show of great strength e.g. building large new navy
Intended to get better offer in bargaining by suggesting their costs will be lower or their opponents will be higher
HOWEVER, can be misinterpreted as an act of war
Define commitment problem
One state cannot commit to upholding their side of any negotiated deal indefinitely due to the fact they are strengthening at a far greater rate than their opponent
What is preemptive conflict (commitment problem)?
A state attacks another one due to fear that the state is imminently going to attack them
What is preventive conflict (commitment problem)?
A state attacks another state that is strengthening, due to fears that the strengthening state will gain superiority over them
Example of preemptive conflict
Six Day War 1967
Israel attacked Egypt, claiming Egypt were about to launch a military strike against them
Example of preventive conflict
2003 US invasion of Iraq
Intended to prevent Saddam Hussein’s regime acquiring nuclear weapons
Define information asymmetries
Parties in conflict have an inadequate or inaccurate information regarding the strength of their opposition
This can lead them to suffer from overconfidence
Example of information asymmetry leading to overconfidence
World War 1
France believed their fortresses on the German border to be impregnable to German weaponry
Germany underestimated effectiveness of trench warfare
Led to high costs for both sides
Define classical deterrence theory
Credible and capable threats can prevent the initiation (and escalation) of conflict
Define spiral theory
Conflicts spiral out of control when states inadvertently threaten each other’s security while communicating deterrent threats
Define democratic peace theory
Idea that democracies settle disputes through peaceful means and do NOT go to war with one another
Michael W Doyle
Three levels of analysis when explaining war
Human nature, form of government and system characteristics
Thinkers who believed a Republic or democratic system prevented conflict
Joseph Schumpeter (liberal pacifism) Niccolo Machiavelli (inclusion of all classes) Immanuel Kant Citizens in a republic act in their OWN interest. War is not in their interest
What undercuts democratic peace theory?
They fight wars of aggression and overthrow regimes with different ideologies
Democracies do not hold their leaders accountable to a greater degree than autocracies
The costs of war are not imposed upon all individuals
What is nuclear deterrence theory?
Idea that nuclear weapons prevent wars because the costs are far too high and there are no opportunities
Critiques of nuclear deterrence theory
Nuclear weapons have existed less than 80 years, not long enough to say it is a rule
China didn’t get WMD until 1964, yet no conflict with West since CCP took power in 1949
Define alliance
A method of managing and preventing conflict, whereby groups with shared interests protect each other against potential threats
Features of alliances
Balance power by accumulation
Small states bandwagon for “free” protection
e.g. Luxembourg 580,000 pop and 0.42% Defence spend
Effect of alliances on war onset
Increases likelihood due to commitment problem
Harder to assess costs so information asymmetries too
HOWEVER, decreases likelihood as signalling that costs are high is easier with more participants
Parties can discourage aggression in their allies