Social Stratification Flashcards
what perspective is davis & moore?
functionalist
what do davis & moore think about social stratification?
- systems are a universal necessity
- all roles in society must be filled by people best able to perform them
- roles require training and must be done conscientiously (well)
- unequal power in society is essential for meritocracy and creates social cohesion because the government maintains order
5 criticisms of davis & moore
- lower paying jobs are still functionally important (it is hard to define which are more important- subjective)
- differences in pay may be due to difference in power (structural inequality- capitalism, patriarchy) not talent
- there’s no formal method to measure talent
- some talented people go unrewarded
- TUMIN- education and training don’t justify extreme lifetime inequalities in rewards. education should be the reward. stratification brings conflict (due to unequal rewards)
what does karl marx think about social stratification?
- mechanism that allows privileged few to exploit many which is unequal and oppressive
- proletariat sell valuable labour but bourgeoisie takes value on account of owning the tools- capitalist wants to take value, workers want to maintain value. different CLASS INTERESTS creates CLASS CONFLICT
- POLARISATION- the more workers are exploited, the greater the difference between classes
- ALIENATION- capitalism makes people feel like they can be disposed of whenever so people don’t feel in control of their lives
- life chances differ due to class and proletariat have worse life chances due to inequality
- economic power creates political power because bourgeoisie control the state- propaganda that shapes the ideology of society to justify capitalism
criticisms of marx
- ignores gender
- ignore ethnicity
- capitalist societies more stable then anticipated- marx thought capitalism would collapse
- people have free will to change their destinies
who came up with the idea of the glass ceiling?
beverly skeggs- feminist
who came up with the idea of there being 6 new patriarchal structures in society?
sylvia walby- feminist
what are the six patriarchal structures?
- the household
- paid work
- the state
- male violence
- sexuality
- cultural institutions (media)
how does walby think there is gender inequality in the household?
even though women are now free to dissolve marriage and work, this ‘liberation’ from marriage can lead to poverty
how does walby think there is gender inequality in paid work?
gender pay gap and less access to “top jobs” and therefore segregated into low-paying part-time jobs
how does walby think there is gender inequality in the state?
there is an inadequate welfare system (benefits) for women and even though they may be the head of the family in line parent families, this position remains economically perilous (unable to grow financially)
how does walby think there is gender inequality in male violence?
although violence to women has been officially condemned, female survivors are often humiliated, disbelieved or ignored
how does walby think there is gender inequality in their sexuality?
heterosexual women feel pressure to marry/ cohabit with a man and sexual double standards are still ‘alive and well’
how does walby think there is gender inequality in cultural institutions?
media still shows women as either sexually glamorous OR wives/ mothers whereas men are shown in positions of power
what perspective is max weber? explain this
founding father of interactionism and somewhat critical (conflict theorist) of marx- agrees property ownership= class divisions but class divisions are not just based on economic factors, also skills and qualifications (status and power)
what does weber define market situation as?
what a worker can sell their labour for
what does weber believe about status?
- social classes compete for status
- we show our status through our property
- class, power and status do often overlap but aren’t as closely linked as marx suggests
what does weber believe about marx’s idea that there will be a revolution?
- those with similar market positions may unite to improve their situation through strikes etc
- parties (political, trade unions or pressure groups) compete for power and can have many different classes
what does weber think about social stratification?
- those with similar market situations achieve a similar level or resources and may unite to improve their situations
- social classes compete for status and is shown through their property
- class power and status overlap but aren’t as closely linked as marx suggests
- there are 2 types of power- formal and informal AND authority and coercion
- there are 3 types of authority- rational legal, traditional and charismatic
what are webers two ‘2 types of power’
- authority (legitimate) and coercion (illegitimate)
- formal and informal
what are webers 3 types of authority?
- rational legal
- traditional
- charismatic
what is formal power? give examples
- conforming to the hierarchical, top-down structures within an organisation
- e.g. a managers power over a worker
what is informal power? give examples
- power between people and expressed through everyday interactions which will reflect the dominance or subordination of their status position
- e.g. a wealthy businessman being rude to a waiter
what is authoritative power? give examples
- legitimate power that people are willing to follow as they believe it is the right thing to do
- e.g. police, the law
what is coercive power? give examples
- illegitimate power that uses threat and violence to force people to obey
- e.g. dictators
what is rational legal authority? give examples
- authority based on law that follows clear and established rules based on an understanding that broken rules will be punished
- e.g. police arresting someone for breaking a law
what is traditional authority? give examples
- based on custom and tradition that has often been inherited/ passed down
- e.g. the continuation of the monarchy
what is charismatic authority? give examples
- based on personal qualities, someone being so extraordinary that they inspire people to follow them
- e.g. celebrities having fans
what 4 factors affect the life chances of an individual?
- social class
- gender
- ethnicity
- disability
what is underclass?
a group of people at the very bottom of the social scale who are dependent on welfare benefits
how can social class affect an individual’s life chances?
working classes tend to have poorer life chances since they may lack access to many institutions/ services such as private education that upper classes do have access to
how can gender affect an individual’s life chances?
women tend to earn less and are likely to do low status work due to things such as the gender pay gap and the “glass ceiling”
how can ethnicity affect an individual’s life chances?
certain ethnic groups are more likely to suffer material deprivation a do less well educationally due to things such as labelling + self fulfilling prophecy and discrimination
how can disability affect an individual’s life chances?
individuals with health issues are more likely to suffer from material deprivation and social exclusion since it may be harder for them to find jobs due to prejudices of employers or their inability to do certain tasks because of their disability
what does an ethnography involve?
the observation of a group of people and their way of life involving multiple research methods such as participant observation
advantages of ethnography
authentic experiences - because they have direct access to culture, ethnographic researchers can have more authentic cultural experiences
describe the two types of social status
- ascribed status= inherited and unchanging over time (royal family, aristocracy)
- achieved status= gained as a result of personal talents/ success (olympic athletes, celebrities)