Slides Week 5 Flashcards
Bonding
- The early relationship formed between mother and infant
- Early belief that post birth bonding was critical for later social development.
- It is now thought that attachments are formed with infants through daily interaction.
- Infants are predisposed to respond to human interaction:
- A few days after birth Infants show clear preference for their mother’s face.
- At One year children use their mother’s emotional expressions to guide their own behaviour in ambiguous situations
Social Referencing
- Relying on another person’s emotional reaction to appraise an uncertain situation
- Starts at 8–10 months
- Caregiver’s role very important
- Helps evaluate safety and security
- Guides actions
- Aids in gathering information about others
Bonding and Temperament
The infant’s temperament is determines:
- The type and amount of social interaction in which they engage with others.
- The quality of the bonds established with their primary caregivers
Temperament Chart
Elements of Personality
- Melancholic
- Choleric
- Phlegmatic
- Sanguine
Measure and Observe Temperament
- Difficult to define and measure and observe
- No clear-cut distinction between temperament and personality
- Key dimension of personality
- Evident from birth.
- Shapes Attachment and subsequent intimate relationships.
Three General Temperament Patterns
- Easy (Flexible)
- Slow to warm up (Fearful)
- Difficult (Feisty)
Each individual’s temperament shows their style of expressing needs and emotions
Temperament Type - Basic Clusters
- Chess & Thomas Basic Clusters
Temperament - Australian Study
- Sanson, Prior, Oberklaid 1985
- 2,443 representative Melbourne families
- Infants aged 4 months - 8 months
- Four temperaments identified
- Babies rated middle of most of the dimensions that showed difference between easy and difficult
- Easy 39%
- Average 40%
- Slow to warm up 8%
- Difficult 12%
Temperamental Differance
- Cause of temperamental difference unclear
- Possible psychological basis suggests association between colic, sleep disturbance and temperament classification
- Not related to:
- Birth order effects
- Birth in Rural v Urban environment
- Individual Gender
- Evidence for Cohort difference indicating environmental factors shape temperament
Temperamental Difference - Smart & Sanso 2005
- Smart & Sanson (2005):
- Compared infant temperament patterns in two cohorts of infants.
- Australian Temperament Project (ATP): commenced in 1983
- Longitudinal Study of Australian Children (LSAC): commenced in 2004
- THREE facets of temperament style assessed:
- Approach-Sociability, Cooperation-adaptability, Irritability-soothability
- Findings were that ATP infants scored higher in irritability than LSAC infants.
- Reason:
- Parents of LSAC infants older and better educated.
- Improved personal and social resources (e.g., maturity, income, parent education) for parenting role.
Tempermental Stability
- Persistences of infant temperament over time is likley but not inevitable
- Mood tone is most likely to be stable over time
Mood Tone
refers to the overall tone of a person’s feelings
Temperamental Stability - Young, Fox & Zahn-Waxler (1999):
- High activity + negative mood at four months (i.e., difficult) à less altruism & empathy at 2 years (i.e., less responsive to mother’s distress).
Temperamental Stability - Lewis (1993)
- Negative mood tone (frequent expression of intense negative emotions – anger, distress) at 3 months
- Poor cognitive performance at 4 years (even after other variables controlled for).
Temperamental Stability - Caspi & Silva (1995)
- 800 NZ boys and girls from birth -18 years
- “Lack of control” at 3 years [rough in play (Activity), distractible, hard staying still (Distractibility), dramatic mood swings (Responsiveness)]
- Risk taking, sensation seeking, low regard for authority, negative emotional response to everyday events, enmeshment in adversarial relationships at 18 years.
- Explanation: environmental engineering
- Shy child growing up in extroverted environment = more likely to be rejected
Temperamental Stability - Continuity & Change
- There are both continuities and change in temperament over time:
- Studies have shown clear longitudinal continuity of temperament
- Explanation: Children as niche pickers – select environments that match their genetic predispositions
- Patterns of interactions lead to same conditions being recreated
- Goodness of fit With child temperament + parenting styles
Goodness of Fit
- Thomas & Chess 1977
- Degree of overlap between infant’s temperament and parents image of ideal child
- If good fit then continuity of temperament is observed
- If poor fit then Parental effort to change infant can modify initial temperament tendancies
- If modification is successful the discontinuity in temperament is observed
Conclusions about Temperament
- Biological basis to temperament
- A number of facets/dimensions to temperament
- Children’s temperament matters for their development and well being
- Reactivity/Irritability/cooperation in infancy can put a child at risk for development of behaviour problems (e.g., aggression, hyperactivity)
- Temperament influences development directly and indirectly through in the type of interactions it elicits from others around the child.
Attachment Defined
- Deep, affectionate, enduring relationship to another individual.
- Bowlby (1969):
- Studies of infants and children orphaned in WWII.
- Infants biologically motivated to form attachments because they ensure survival.
Role of the Mother - Bowlby
- Studies of institutionalised children in the 1940s and 1950s
- Influenced development of contemporary attachment theories.
- Bowlby: subsequent problems of these children resulted from being deprived of the experience of bonding to a mother.
- Children deprived of consistent care by a mother were:
- Developmentally delayed.
- Showed later forms of psychopathology, e.g., delinquent personalities.
- This hypothesis = Maternal Deprivation Hypothesis.
Maternal Deprivation Hypothesis
- Bowlby
- Suggests that continual disruption of the attachment between infant and primary caregiver (i.e. mother) could result in long term cognitive, social, and emotional difficulties for that infant.
- Originally believed the effects to be permanent and irreversible.
Role of the Father
- Bowlby:
- Institutionalised infants who were also deprived of fathers
- Their later psychopathology was not attributed to paternal absence.
- Initially suggested that fathers are as crucial to their child’s development as mothers.
- However, it also shows that fathers have a unique role in the child’s development.
Role of the Father - Peterson
- Father’s role been so downplayed that paternal deprivation is considered “normal”, even for a child in an intact family environment (Peterson, 2010, p. 151).
- Research shows fathers may be first object of attachment for some infants (see Peterson, 2013, p. 158-162).
Role of the Father - Schaffer & Emerson 1964
- 60 Scottish infants.
- Even in homes where the mother was the primary caregiver, some infants formed their first emotional bonds with:
- Fathers.
- Grandparents.
Role of the Father - Ainsworth
- Study of Ugandan infants
- Fathers were primary attachment figus in 5-20% of cases
- Subsequent researchers interested in examining how fathers might contribute to infant and child attachment behaviours.
Historical Research Fathers - Lamb 1977
- Qualitative difference between type of care provided by each parent for infants.
- Mothers → Nurturant acts of parenting, e.g., feeding, changing, dressing, and comforting the child.
- Fathers → Engage in play activities with the child.
Historical Research Fathers - Russell 1978
- Russell (1978):
- Fathers devote approximately 13 hours per week to parenting.
- Much of this time is involved in play activities with children.
- This research is 40 Years old!!
Contemporary Fathering
- Rochlen, McKelly & Whittacker (2010):
- Increase in the numbers of fathers who choose to stay at home and care for their children, with 65% increase in numbers from 2004-2007.
- However, 50% of fathers reported a stigmatising incident, with 67% of incidents perpetrated by stay at home mothers.
- Australian statistics: 4-5% of two-parent families have stay-at-home fathers (80,000 in 2016, AIFS).
- Come to this role for various reasons, however still face stigmatisation
- Gender role expectations have not changed significantly
Attachment Aspects
Bowlby: Attachment behaviour has Four Aspects:
- Proximity Maintenance
- Safe Haven
- Secure Base
- Separation Distress
Proximity Maintenance
Child maintains close proximity to caregiver
Safe Haven
Child turns to caregiver for comfort when frightened or threatened
Secure Base
Child considers caregiver as providing reliable base to come back to.
Separation Distress
Child is distressed when separated from caregiver
Separation
- When infants are separated from caregivers, anxiety occurs
- Three stages of the separation process
- Protest
- Despair
- Detachment
Working Model
- Repeated experiences with caregiver establish a Working Model.
- Children Internalise experiences with caregivers and the way they are treated/valued
- Important to overcoming separation anxiety and judging situations
- Based on likely response of caregiver if they were present at the time
- If something goes wrong, knowing they will be protected
- This working model provides a prototype for all subsequent relationships (friendships, love relationships, faith experiences).
Comfort or Food?
- Early research on attachment was also interested in the question of what led to an infant developing an attachment to a caregiver.
- Is comfort or food more important?
- This question was addressed in research by Harry Harlow in 1959.