Sexual Ethics Flashcards
Premarital sex
Sex before marriage
Extramarital sex
Sex outside of marriage, where at least one party is married to someone else
Contractarian
The idea that moral rules or norms are based on an implicit mutual agreement
Histroicals attitudes to sex and sexuality
- premarital sex, extramarital sex and homosexuality are a falling short of God’s ideal
- UK has a Judeo-Christian ethical view
Why have attitudes to sex and sexuality changed
- effective use of contraception has made premarital sex less risky
- 75% see no moral issue with premarital sex
- 68% do not consider homosexual relationships to be wrong
- 85% find extramarital sex always wrong
- increase in cohabitation (more likely to divorce if you cohabit)
The non-harm principle
MILL
- rules are needed only in order to prevent people being harmed and to take action if harm takes place
- provided the people involved have given consent and no one is harmed then no further rules are needed
Support of the non-harm principle
JOHN HARRIS
- sexual ethics as such is not needed, since issues as violence, abuse or paedophilia would be dealt with under other ethical debates
Michel Foucault
Challenges religious thinking on sexual ethics
- categorises sexual behaviour in terms of normal and abnormal
- unhelpful way of seeing the world = should be rejected
Feminist view on sexual ethics
- gender inequality disproportionately affects women by sexual discrimination
- MeToo movement highlighted this issue - sexual abuse, assault at work, revenge porn
- women are more judged if they have had several partners
Applying natural law - Aquinas
- each person and each activity has a telos
- the primary precept of human beings is reproduction
- sexual acts without reproduction does not reach your telos - no masturbation, contraception, homosexual acts
- marriage is fundamentally important - premarital and extramarital rejected
John finnis
Based on natural law theories
- certain things in life are basic goods of human flourishing eg reproduction, knowledge, work
- only in marriage that both friendship and reproduction can be combined
- homosexual sex is instrumental and harmful
Fletcher’s view
- key to christian ethics is agape
- it applied to individual situations
- agape is the middle ground between legalism ad antinomianism
- premarital sex and homosexuality is not morally wrong as long as they are based on love
- extramarital sex can sometimes be supported depending on the circumstances
Fletchers view on dangers of his view
- there is a danger of promiscuity
- people are ignoring the value of dignity of persons and are treating them as ‘love objects’
Fletchers difficult cases surrounding extramarital sex
- Mrs Bergmeier
- patriotic prostitution
Christianity and sexual ethics
- biblical material, Jesus says very little about sexuality
- Paul said that christians should remain celibate
- RC, equal weight to church teaching, natural law and biblical material
- liberal, value the bible but feel that there is a need to interpret and apply Paul’s teaching literally
- evangelical, may take the biblical teaching in a moral literal sense
Kant - persons and marriage
- persons have desires but also rationality to make decisions regarding our desires
- main concern is that sexuality can reduce us purely to acting on desires
- marriage helps us to avoid degrading us as a person because the couple has freely and rationally chosen to enter into this contract
- sexual relationships are based on will and desire