Sandel

Question 1

general thesis/argument

Answer 1

1. Enhancement undermines a sense of our qualities as gifted
2. Our sense of our qualities as gifted underpins our commitment to humility and solidarity, and reduces our tendency to over-attribute responsibility
3. Humility and solidarity play a vital role in making a good society, and the tendency to over-attribute responsibility is harmful
   So enhancement undermines the underpinnings of a good society

Question 2

relevant examples

Answer 2

Hyper Parenting - Why seeking perfection is a fault

Question 3

major objections

Answer 3

We already enhance through medicine :: there is a difference between enhancement and therapy

Question 4

Humility:

Answer 4

lack of control over our children

Question 5

Responsibility:

Answer 5

tendency to over-attribute responibility gets worse

Question 6

Solidarity:

Answer 6

explosion of over attribution of responsibility undermines solidarity