Research methods Flashcards
Strengths of an independent measures design
- No order effects because different participants are used in each level of the IV
- Reduces demand characteristics because participants only see the task once
- The effects of individual differences can be reduced by random allocation to levels of the IV
Weaknesses of an independent measures design
- Individual differences could effect the results if participants in one level of the IV differ from those in another
- More participants are needed so may be harder to find
Strengths of a repeated measures design
- Individual differences are unlikely to effect the results because participants do both levels
- Counterbalancing reduces order effects
- Uses fewer participants so quicker than independent measures
- Blind procedures can reduce demand characteristics
Weaknesses of a repeated measures design
- Order effects and extraneous variable could effect the results
- Increases risk of demand characteristics because participants see the task more than one
Strengths of a matched pairs design
- Participants only see the task once so reduces demand characteristics
- Controls individual differences
- No order effects
Weaknesses of a matched pairs design
- The similarity between pairs is limited by the matching process
- Time consuming and difficult to find
How to address demand characteristics?
By not sharing the aim of the study till the end
What is reliability?
Something has high reliability if it produces similar results under consistent or same conditions
Why do lab experiments have high reliability?
Because the researcher can have a lot of control which ensures all participants are treated in the same way
Why is it useful for an experiment to be controlled?
Because it makes the experiment easier to replicate as they are following the exact same procedure
What is external reliability?
When a study’s results are consistent in the same situation with the same people
How would you test reliability?
Split half method
What is validity?
When a test measures what it claims to measure eg. an intelligence test measures not something else like memory
What is internal validity?
Whether the effects observed in a study are due to the manipulation of the IV and not something else
How to improve internal validity?
Standardised instructions, counterbalancing and eliminating demand characteristics
What is external validity?
Relates to issues beyond the investigation and whether the findings will generalise to other settings (ecological validity) and other people (population validity)
How to improve external validity?
Natural settings and random sampling
Why do lab experiments have high internal validity?
Because in lab experiments you can control extraneous variables so the researcher can be sure that changes to the DV have been caused by the IV
Strengths of a laboratory experiment
- Control of extraneous variables
- Can be replicated therefore researchers can be more confident in their findings
- Casual relationships can be determined
Weaknesses of a laboratory experiment
- The artificial situation could make participants behaviour unrepresentative
- Participants could respond to demand characteristics and alter their behaviour
Strengths of a field experiment
- All participants are in their normal situation so their behaviour is more representative
- Participants could be unaware they are in a study so less demand characteristics
Weaknesses of a field experiment
- Less control over extraneous variables so findings are less reliable and replication is more difficult
- The researcher cannot be sure of cause and effect
- Participants could be unaware they in a study which raises ethical issues
Strengths of a quasi experiment
- They can be used to study real world issues
- If participants are in their normal situation, behaviour is more representative
- If participants are unaware they are in a study, it reduces demand characteristics
- They enable researchers to investigate variables that could not practically or ethically be manipulated
Weaknesses of a quasi experiment
- They are only possible when naturally occurring differences arise
- Control over extraneous variables is difficult
- The researcher cannot be sure of cause and effect
- Hard to replicate