Reproductive and Pediatric Ethics Flashcards
What are the 5 core categories involving reproductive ethics
- contraception
- assisted reproductive technologies
- termination of pregnancy
- genetics/congenital conditions
- maternal-fetal conflict
Discuss contraception: what contraception is, pt’s rights, and duties of providers
- prevention of pregnancy using IUDs, pills, tubal ligation, or injections
- women/adolescents have right to make decision about contraception use/methods
- providers have duty to provide info about contraception options so pt can make informed decision
- when pt “conscientiously objects” and providers do NOT agree w/ contraception do NOT have to provide Rx; best scenario is to be transparent regarding policies
What are some ethical issues that may emerge about contraception
- women forced to use contraception
- women forced to become sterilized against their will
- disagreement b/w partners
- disagreements b/w pt and clinician
What are some ethical issues that may emerge about assisted reproductive technologies
- medical risks to mother
- donor/surrogate rights
- pre-implantation genetic diagnostic screening
- donation/destruction of embryonic tissue
- # of embryos implanted vs selective reduction
- finances/success rates
What are some ethical issues that may emerge about pregnancy termination
- pro-choice vs. pro-life (woman’s autonomy vs. fetus autonomy)
- Roe vs. Wade=right to make own choice regarding pregnancy termination
- Planned Parenthood vs. Casey= upheld initial Roe ruling but stipulated states may ban abortions after point of fetal viability (23-24 weeks)
- Hyde Amendment + barring use of federal funds to pay for abortions expect to save mothers life and in cases of rape/incest
Discuss maternal-fetal conflict: what is maternal-fetal conflict, and duties of providers
- when caring for pregnant pts must consider risks/benefits/outcomes for both mom and baby
- as fetus gets to viability (23-24 weeks) more compelling to consider/advocate for fetus
- concern for fetus should NOT lead to inappropriately withholding effective therapies for mom
What are some ethical issues that may emerge about maternal-fetal conflict
- lifestyle conflicts (smoking, drinking, illicit drug use)
- tx refusal by pregnant pt
- pt declared “brain dead”
- when fetus is considered “a person”
Which organization feels health providers and policy makers need to use advocacy of health behavior rather than punative action to manage maternal-fetal conflict
-ACOG
What are some reasons to have prenatal diagnostic testing done
- possible heritable condition in 1 or both parents
- FMHx of 1 or more heritable conditions
- high risk population group (Ashkenazi Jewish)
- couples are blood relatives
- couple are anxious about reproductive risks
What impact can prenatal diagnostic testing have on potential or having current or future pregnancies
-depending if testing shows non-significant/significant genetic risks parents may/may not decide to have kids
Who can give consent for a child
- parent’s presumed appropriate decision maker
- have ethical/legal obligation to obtain parental permission to perform recommended medical interventions
- parents do NOT have absolute power to refuse care though
- ultimate goal = parental permission + child’s assent
When are parents not considered to have decision making power
- in cases where typical supportive-loving parent-child relationship is not present
- would need to get court appointed guardian
- emergencies
- clinician can act in pts best interest if parent is no available and delay of tx would lead to significant harm
- reach age 18 in majority of states
- minor status (emancipated minors)
When can clinicians break confidentiality of minors
- if danger to self or others
- if in dangerous situation (abuse or neglect)
- for absence notes (need to miss school; no need to disclose dx or reasoning)
- for note to use meds at school
What should be done when provider and parent disagree
- try and persuade parent/guardian to accept effective/appropriate care
- further response depends on specific case (may involve court or ethics committee)
What should be done when child refuses tx
- response depends on:
- seriousness of clinical situation
- effectiveness of tx
- side effects of tx
- side effects of NOT receiving tx
- reasons behind refusal
- parents preferences on tx
- difficult to force long term tx (inhalers, insulin)