reduction vs emergence Flashcards
What is reduction?
Higher-level properties are reduced (i.e.
traced back) to basic laws and properties.
difference between reduction and reductive explanation?
Reductive Explanation
Explanation of higher-level properties on the
basis of lower level laws and properties
• Higher level properties of water (freezing)
can be explained on the basis of
microphysical laws concerning H2O
Intelligibility is required unlike in reduction also necessity (revise the DNE).
Emergence is?
and is it a non-physical property?
Emergence is when Reductive explanation fails
A property F of a system S, made up of the
constituents C1, …, Cn standing in a certain relation R
to each other, is emergent if and only if
(a) there is a law to the effect that all systems with the
same make-up have F, and if
(b) F nonetheless cannot, even in theory, be deduced
from the most complete knowledge of the
properties of the components C1, …, Cn in isolation
or in systems with a different make-up. (A.
Beckermann/C.D. Broad)
No.