Real Property (MBE/MEE) Flashcards
i
Fee Simple Absolute
- Absolute ownership of potentially infinite duration
- No accompanying future interest
- Freely alienable, devisable, and descendible
Defeasible Fee
- Potentially infinite duration, subject to termination by occurrence of event
- Alienable, devisable, and descendible
- Types: Fee simple determinable; fee simple subject to a condition subsequent; fee simple subject to an executory interest
Fee Simple Determinable
- Ownership automatically terminates upon a specific condition and passes to grantor.
- Look for durational words: “as long as,” “until,” “while”
- Future interest: Grantor (or successor) retains possibility of reverter; if future interest is in third party, it is an executory interest
Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent
- When a specific condition occurs, grantor can exercise a right of reentry.
- Look for specific conditional language: “upon condition that,” “provided that,” “but if”
- Will terminate only if grantor affirmatively demonstrates intent to terminate
- Future interest: Grantor reserves right of re-entry/right of termination
Fee Simple Subject to Executory Interest/Limitation
- Ownership automatically terminates upon happening of a specific condition and passes to a third party.
- Future interest: Executory interest held by the third party
Life Estate
- Present possessory estate limited by in duration by life
- Look for durational language: “to A for life;” “to B after life of A,” “to B for life of C”
- Ownership terminates upon end of measuring life
- Future interest: Remainder or executory interest
Life Tenant Rights and Duties
LT’s rights:
* Right to possess, collect rents, lease/sell mortgage
LT’s burdens:
* Must pay property taxes to extent LT receives financial benefit from land; pre-existing mortgage obligations and assessments for improvements allocated between LT and FI holder
* LT must make reasonable repairs (up to amount of income produced by property or, if LT is in actual possession, FMV), however this does not apply if damage is caused by third party tortfeasor
Life Tenant: Mortgage Obligations Incurred Before Life Estate
- A mortage obligation incurred before creation of life estate in mortgaged property is subject to allocation between life tenant and future-interest holder
- Parties not personally liable for mortgage obligation unless they assumed the mortgage, but failure to pay may result in loss of property interest
Waste Doctrine
- LT must deliver property to FI holder in substantially same condition as when LT took possession
- Permissive Waste: LT permits premises to deteriorate through neglect, failure to preserve, failure to reasonably protect property
- Voluntary Waste: Condition of property is substantially changed due to LT’s affirmative action. Affirmative action that results in diminution in property value prohibited.
- Ameliorative Waste: Voluntary action that does not diminish the property value. Permitted when change results in reasonable use of the property. LT has duty not to change premises if FI holders have reasonable ground for objection.
Reversion
- Held by a grantor who transfers a life estate or estate for years without conveying remaining FI to a 3P
- Not subject to RAP
-Remainder
-Contingent Remainder
Remainder:
* FI that becomes possessory upon natural expiration of a prior estate created in same conveyance in which remainder is created
Contingent Remainder:
* Created (i) in an unascertainable grantee, or (ii) subject to an express condition precedent to grantee’s taking
Survivorship Contingency
If a survivorship contingency is stated in a conveyance, then the majority view is that the contingency applies at the termination of the interest that precedes distribution of the remainder
-Rule in Shelley’s Case
-Doctrine of Worthier Title
Rule in Shelley’s Case:
* Prevented contingent remainder in grantee’s heirs and instead granted a vested remainder in the grantee.
* Abolished in most jurisdictions.
Doctrine of Worthier Title:
* Prevents grantor from creating a remainder in grantor’s heirs
* Creates rebuttable presumption of reversion to grantor
-Vested Remainder
-Vested Remainder Subject to Open
-Vested Remainder Subject to Complete Divestment
Vested Remainder:
* Not subject to any conditions precedent
* Ascertainable grantee
Vested Remainder Subject to Open:
* When 1+ class member is qualified to take possession at time of conveyance (but less than all of them)
* Each class members’ share is subject to potential partial diminution
Vested Remainder Subject to Complete Divestment:
* Occurrence of a condition subsequent will completely divest remainder
-Executory Interests
-Shifting Executory Interest
-Springing Executory Interest
Executory Interests:
* FI in 3P (not a remainder) that cuts prior estate short upon occurrence of specified condition
* Subject to RAP
Shifting Executory Interest:
* Cuts short prior estate created in same conveyance, so estate shifts from one grantee to another grantee upon happening of condition
Springing Executory Interest:
* Divests grantor’s interest or fills a gap in possession in which estate reverts to grantor
Rule Against Perpetuities
- Specific FIs are valid only if they must vest or fail by end of a life in being plus 21 years
- Affected FIs: Contingent remainders, vested remainders subject to open, executory interests, powers of appointment, ROFR and options may be unless commercial
- Unaffected FIs: Does not apply to FIs that revert to grantor (reversion, possibility of reverter, right of reentry)
- “Vest or fail” requirement: If any possibility it will not be known whether interest will vest or fail within applicable period, RAP not satisfied. Tests FI as of time it is created
- Effect of violation: Only offending interests fails unless undermines grantor’s intent
- Exception: Charity-to-charity
Special RAP Rule for Class Gifts
“Bad as to one, bad as to all”), unless:
* (i) Rule of convenience applies: Membership in class closes whenever any member of class is entitled to immediate possession of a share of the class gift
* (ii) Transfers of a specific dollar amount to each class member
* (iii) Transfers to a subclass that vests at a specific time
Tenancy in Common
- Two or more grantees with unity of possession
- No right of survivorship
- Each cotenant holds undivided interest with unrestricted rights to possess whole
- Interest freely devisable/transferable
- Default co-tenancy: In most states there is a presumption that a conveyance to 2+ people is a TIC
Joint Tenancy
- Two or more persons own the property with right of survivorship (when one JT dies, interest goes to other JTs)
- Requirements: Express language and four unities of Time (created at same time), Title (by same title), Interest (with identical equal interests), Possession (equal rights to possess the whole) (TTIP)
- Severence: Converts JT into a TC (only w/r/t severed share)
Tenancy by Entirety
- Same unities as JT, plus unity of person (i.e. marriage)
- Parties must be married when deed is executed or conveyance occurs
- Neither party can alienate or encumber property without consent of the other
Co-Tenant Rights and Obligations
- Right to natural resources: Limited to size of contenant’s interest in land
- Possession: Each cotenant has right to possess entire property
- Ouster: Cotenant who is being denied access can bring a court action to regain access to property
- Adverse Possession: If one cotenant ousted other, he can make a claim for adverse possession. Ouster requires physical removal, changing locks, constructing fence to prevent other cotenant from coming, not just exclusively using property.
Partition: TC or JT (not TBE) generally has right to unilaterally partition property (preferably a partition in-kind i.e. a physical division)
Easements: Co-Ts may agree to create an easement; unilaterally-created easement only enforceable against co-T who created it
Third Party Rents: Must share rents recieved from 3P but can deduct operating expenses
Contribution: Right to contribution for operating expenses (e.g., property taxes, mortgage payments) (if sole possession, only if they exceed rental value of property) but no right to contribution for (i) expenses for repairs (unless co-tenant gave notice) or (ii) improvements, but in either case may be entitled to additional value in a partition action
Federal Fair Housing Act
- Prohibits discrimination in sale, rental, and financing of homes and housing-related transactions (advertising, homeowner’s insurance, zoning)
- Exemptions: Owner-occupied buildings with no more than 4 units and SFH sold/rented without a broker (still subject to advertising rules)
- Protected Classes: Race, color, religion, national origin, sex, disability, familial status
- Racial discrimination: Plaintiff need only show a disparate racial impact, not racial intent or purpose
Conflict of Laws
Generally apply law of the situs (i.e. state where real property is located) unless:
* (i) document specifies applicable law,
* (ii) dealing with property acquired during marriage (law of spouses’ domicile when property was acquired),
* (iii) collateral issue (state with most significant interest) (ex. issues that relate to a foreclosure but do not affect an interest in land)
Tenancy for Years
- Created by express agreement for fixed period of time
- Automatically terminates at end of term (no notice needed)
- May be terminated before end of term (e.g., breach)
- SoF applies if term longer than 1 year
Periodic Tenancy
- Repetitive, ongoing estate measured by set periods that automatically renew (e.g., month-to-month) unless valid termination notice
- Term may be fixed by parties or by their actions
- Created by express agreement, implication (no mention of duration), or operation of law (holdover tenant)
- Termination Notice: Give notice before last period ends; late notice is effective for next period. Notice effective as of last day of period, but in YTY only six months needed.
- SoF: Does not apply unless initial term exceeds 1 year
Tenancy at Will
- Estate with no fixed period of time and may be terminated by either party at any time
- Created by express agreement or by implication
- Notice is required
Tenancy at Sufferance
- T wrongfully holds over past expiration of lease
- T bound by terms of lease existing before expiration, including rent
- Lasts until T leaves, L evicts T, or L elects to hold T to periodic tenancy
Tenant’s Duties
- Pay rent, unless premises destroyed or material breach by L (i.e. breach of covenant of quiet enjoyment or implied warranty of habitability)
- Avoid waste (see waste doctrine)
- Make reasonable repairs: In non-residential leases, T may be contractually liable for all damage to property
Landlord’s Remedies for Tenant’s Breach
Failure to pay rent: L can sue for damages and evict and terminate lease
* Future Rent: No anticipatory repudiation in most states
* Late rent: L entitled to damages; removal depends on if breach is material or L waived right to evict by accepting payment
Abandonment: Treated as offer to surrender rights under lease
* L accepts surrender: Lease terminates and T liability for future rent ends
* L rejects surrender: T remains liable for rent but L must mitigate damages
Landlord’s Duties
- Possession: Deliver actual physical possession
- Repair: Except for T damages, L must repair for residential but not for commercial leases
- Implied Warranty of Habitability
- Covenant of Quiet Enjoyment
- Security Deposit
Implied Warranty of Habitability
- Premises must be fit for basic human habitation (health/safety)
- Applies only in residential leases
If breached:
* (i) T must notify L of defect and give reasonable time to repair,
* (ii) T can (a) refuse to pay rent, (b) make reasonable repairs and deduct cost from future rent, or (c) remain in possession, pay rent, and seek damages
Covenant of Quiet Enjoyment
- T has a right to quiet use and enjoyment of the premises without interference from L
- L has duty to control other tenants’ nuisance in common areas
- Applies in both commercial and residential leases
- Breach may amount to eviction
Eviction
- Three types: Actual, partial, constructive
- Actual: Lease terminated and T’s obligation to pay rent ends
- Partial: T excused from paying rent for L’s partial eviction, exception for 3P with superior claim or adverse possessor/trespasser
- Constructive: Substantial interference caused by L’s actions/failure to act. T must give notice of problem, L fails to respond, and T must vacate premises within reasonable time after L fails to fix problem.
- No retaliatory evictions
Tenant’s Tort Liabilities
- Duty of care to invitees/licensees/foreseeable trespassers
- May be liable for dangerous conditions/activities
Landlord’s Tort Liabilities
Modern trend: General duty of reasonable care; liability for defects existing prior to T’s occupancy, failure to make required repairs, criminal activities of 3Ps who injure Ts
Note: A landlord can technically be liable for trespass against a tenant because tenant is in legal possession of the property.
Assignment vs. Sub-Lease
- Assignment: Complete transfer of T’s remaining lease term
- Sublease: Any transfer for less than entire duration of lease
Assignment and Sub-Lease Liability
- Original T: Liable for lease covenants unless novation by L because still in privity of contract with L
- Assignee-T: Liable to L for rents/covenants running with lease because assignee-T is in privity of estate with L
- Sublease T: Not liable for rents/covenants in lease to L because not in privity with L, unless sub-T expressly assumes covenants
- L’s Assignments: L may assign lease rights/obligations to 3P but remains liable to T for all covenants in lease unless T attorns (i.e. acknowledges new L)
Note: L can still remove sublessee from premises if rental payments are not being made to owner by either sublessor or sublessee T
Limitations on Assignments
- T can still assign/sublet if lease prohibits, but L can terminate for breach and recover damages
- Modern Rule: L can only withhold permission on reasonable grounds, regardless of if commercial/residential. Traditional rule made distinctions and said residential could withhold permission on absolute discretion.
Land Sale Contracts: Statute of Frauds
- Land sales K must be in writing, signed by party to be charged, and contain all of the essential terms (parties, property description, terms of price/payment)
- Options and ROFR must satisfy SoF
- Deed need not satisfy SoF
- Mortgage agreement must satisfy SoF
Exceptions to SoF:
* Part performance: Possession, payment, or substantial improvements (2/3 required)
* Detrimental Reliance: Specific performance permitted when party seeking enforcement reasonably relied on K and would suffer hardship
Marketable Title
- Title free from defects or unreasonable risk of litigation
- Seller generally not required to deliver marketable title until closing
- Buyer can rescind/recover if breached
- Buyer can waive right to marketable title before closing
Note: Red flags for marketable title include covenants, easements, leases, liens, boundary disputes, zoning violations, adverse possession
Implied Warranty of Fitness
- Warrants use of adequate materials and workmanship for new homes
- Includes latent construction defects
- Suits must be brought within a reasonable period of time (e.g., several years may be unreasonable)
- May be breached by seller’s negligent OR intentional conduct
- Disclaimer: Cannot be disclaimed by general “as is” disclaimer
Merger
Land sales K obligations merge into deed upon delivery unless parties intend otherwise or obligations are collateral to/independent of conveyance