Real Property Flashcards
what does “for the purpose of” do for estates?
Nothing
Fee Simple Absolute
Present Estate, Runs Forever
What estate is created unless language shows clear intent to create another estate?
Fee Simple Absolute is the presumed estate
Alienation (right to transfer) and Fee Simple Absolute
Cannot restrict alienation, if restricted condition is ignored
Conditions on Fee Simple Absolute
Are permitted
RIght of First Refusal on Fee Simple Absolute
Are Permitted
Life Estate
Present estate, Measured by life, not time
Life Estate and Alienation
Permitted to restrict right to transfer
How are life estates implied?
To A after Death of B, B has implied life estate
Life Estaet Pur Autre Vie
Measuring life is in someone else
Life Tenant’s main duty
Maintain the Estate, Normal use of land in present condition
How is a life tenant guilty of waste?
If he uses the land in a way thats less or more then the normal use of the land
Voluntary Waste
affirmative use beyond the right of maintenance causing harm to premises/ held liable to holder of future interest
Open Mines Doctrine
can deplete natural resources if they were being depleted before
Ameliorative Waste
Altering property but increasing value of it
Changed Conditions on Life Tenant Property
If changed conditions have made the property relatively worthless in it’s current use, the life tenant can tear it down without liability to the holder of the future interest
Permissive Waste
Failing to Maintain
To avoid Permissive Waste Life Tenant must
Repair, but not replace/ Pay taxes on property/ Pay interest on mortgage (duture interest holder pays principle)
Life Tenant Limitations on Liability
Limited to amount of income received from land or if personally using property, reasonable rental value of the land
Class Gifts
Not identifiable group of people
Once established class stays open for:
People who later meet definition
If members of class predecease testator
their gift lapses
Rule Of Convenience for Class Gifts
Class closes when anyone in the class is entitled to distribution, rule of construction not law, only if grantor did not state otherwise
When does a future interest exist?
It exist now but possession will not come until later, if ever
Future Interest Retained by Grantor
Reversion, Possibility of Reverter, RIght of Reentry
Future Interest given to Grantee
Remainder, Executory iInterest
Reversion
Interest kept by Grantor when Grantor gives less then duration estate grantor had/ NO RAP
Possibility of Reverter
Grantor gives fee simple determinable
Fee Simple Determinable
Key Words: So long as, until, while, during/ Ends automatically when condition happens
Right of Reentry (power of termination)
When grantor gives fee simple on a condition subsequent/ must have express language reserving right of reentry, ambiguous language will be read in a way that there is no forfeiture
Fee Simple Condition Subsequent
Title does not automatically go back to Grantor unless Grantor exercises right
Key Words: Provided However
Remiander
Possessory if at all upon natural expiration of estates before them/ Grantee interest
Vested Remainder
Nothing stands in the way of person becoming possessory on the expiration of estate before them, no condition needs to happen
Vested Remainder Subject to Open (Subject to Partial Divestment)
Class where members are not yet known and class remains open to all of future people who qualify as members of the class/ Subject to RAP
Contingent Remainder
Something has to happen or be known before remainder can become possessory/ Subject to RAP
- Condition must be satisfied before grantee can be certain (ex: age)
- Contingent one grantee being born (ex: To A’s children, A has no children at time_
- If can’t identify person by name, contingent on identifying person (ex: widow)
Executory Interest (Subject to total divestment, subject to executory limitation, subject to executory interest )
Cuts short estate before it (not on natural expiration)/ RAP
Shifting Executory Interest
Taking title from one grantee to another grantee
Springing Executory Interest
Taking title from grantor and giving it to grantee
Rule Against Perpetutities
No interest unless it must vest, if at all, not later than 21 years after some life in being at the creation of the interest
What is subject to Rule Against Perpetutities?
Contingent Remainders, Executory Interest, Vested Remainders subject to open, Options and Rights of First Refusals
Exception to Rule Against Perpetuties
Charity to Charity
Look Out for RAP Hypos
- Gift over to class following open class: Watch for facts where class is open and gift contingent on class member reaching a certain age, anyone is capable of having kids
- Unborn Spouse: where gift does not vest until widow/widower dies
Joint Tenancies
Right of Survivovrship, Right to Partition
Joint Tenancies and Texas
NONE right of survivorship doen by contract
Creation of Joint Tenancies
Time, Title, Interest, Possession
Joint Tenant/ Title
Joint Tenants must take by the same instrument
Joint Tenant/ Interest
All joint tenants must take the same kind and same amount of interest
Joint Tenant/ Time
All interest must have vested on same day
Joint Tenant/ Possession
All must have identical rights of possession
Joint Tenant Language
Must have clear language to created, failure results in Tenants in Common
“Joint Tenants”, “as joint tenants with right of survivorship” “in joint tenancy with right of survivorship”
Destruction of Joint Tenancy
- Conveyance by one of Joint Tenants
- Mortgage in Title Theory
- Contract of sale
- Creditors Sale
Conveyance by one of Joint Tenants
Destroys Joint Tenancy of sellers interest, buyer takes as tenant in common
- Lease is ok
Title Theory
Minority/ Title passes from mortgagor to mortgagee
- Mortgagee entitled to possession upon demand at any time, can take possession so long as mortgagor defaults
Lien Theory
Majority/ Lien attaches to title, title does not transfer
- Mortgage cannot take possession of the land before foreclosure unless mortgagee consents or abandons land
Joint Tenant and Contract of Sale
Severs when you contract to sell the land, not upon actual sale
Creditors Sale and Joint Tenancy
Judgement lien not enough, has to be actual judicial sale
Tenancies in Common
Default Tenancy (if Joint tenancy not properly created)
- Right to partition, No right to survivorship
- All tenants must have equal rights of possession
Tenancy by The Entirety
Created by Husband and Wife
Rights and Duties among co-tenants
Possession, Accountability, Contribution
Co-tenants and Possession
No Exclusive right of possession, right to possess all the property Consistent with other co-tenants right to possess
Co-tenants and Accountability
- Do not have to account for share of profits
- Will have to account if there is an agreement to share, lease of property to a third party, depletion of natural resources
Co-tenants and Ouster
Will have to account to co-tenant if keeping co-tenant off the property or claiming right of exclusive possession
Co-tenants and Contribution
Right of co-tenant to force others to pay for expenditure
- Available for mortgage (if everyone has signed), governmentally imposes obligations
- None for improvements or nonnessary repairs (can recoup in sale or partition)
Tenancy for Years
Any estate for a fixed period of time, no matter how short
- SOF: Any lease for over 1 year has to be in writing (1 year exact ok)
Periodic Tenancy
Ongoing, continuing, repetitive until one party gives valid notice
Ways to Create Periodic Tenancy
- Express agreement
- Implication (lease silent on duration)
- Operation of Law:
- Oral Lease violating statute of frauds, determined by period covered in rent check
- Holdover Tenant: Tenant gives rent after expiration of lease and landlord accepts it
Terminating a Periodic Tenancy
2 Requirements
- Proper Notice: week-week, month-month, year-6 months
- Effective day of termination: Last day of period only
Tenancy at Will
No period of duration, either party terminates at any time without notice
Terminating a Tenancy at Will
Death of either party, waste by tenant of any kind, assignment by tenant, transfer of title by landlord, lease by landlord to someone else
Tenancy at Sufferance
Holdover Tenant/ Landlords sole option (not T)
- Hold tenant as wrongdoing trespasser and sue to throw him off and recover damages for holdover
- Impose a new periodic tenancy
- Residential: always month to month, prior lease doesn’t matter
- Commercial: if old lease for year or more new lease is year to year
If less then year measured by rent period of old tenancy
- Can only imposes if reasonable holdover (1 hour probably not)
Raised Rent: only if landlord tells tenant of higher rent before expiration of lease
Tenant Duties
If Lease is silent: pay rent and no waste
If Lease says tenant must repair and maintain: Tenant must repair wear and tear unless wear and tear is specifically excluded
- Tenant can terminate the lease if premises are destroyed and tenant not at fault
Landlord Remedies if Tenant doesn’t pay rent
Landlord can sure for damages and sue to throw tenant out
Landlord Remedies if Tenant unjustifiably abandons leasehold
2 choices:
- Treat abandonment as offer to surrender, accept offer by retaking premises, ending tenants liability as of that date
- Rent premises and hold tenant liable for deficiency
Landlord Duties- When lease begins
- Given tenant actual possession when lease begins
- If can’t give actual possession landlord has breached
Landlord Duties- Implied Covenant of Habitability MBE
Must provide property that is reasonably suited for residential use
- If landlord breaches tenant can either move out and end lease or stay and sue for damages
Implied Covenant of Habitability in TEXAS
NO Implied Habitability
- Statutorily obligated that landlord repairs conditions that materially affect physical health or safety
Implied Warranty of Suitability in TEXAS
Commercial only, covers latent defects
Implied Covenant of Quite Enjoyment: In every lease, 3 ways to breach
- Total Eviction: terminated lease, ending tenants obligation to pay rent
- Partial Eviction:
- Landlord- Stay and pay no rent, doesn’t terminate lease
- Person other then landlord: Tenants rent is apportioned to reflect amount taken away
- Constructive Eviction: Where landlord fails to provide service landlord obligated to provide, premise uninhabitable
To not pay rent 3 requirements: Landlord has to do it, must be substantial interference with covenant of quite enjoyment, must be abandonment of premises within a reasonable time after breach
Assignment
Tenant transfers everything
- Doesn’t matter if its called something else if this is what its doing
Sublease
Tenant transfers, holding a portion back
- Doesn’t matter if its called something else if this is what its doing
TEXAS: Sublease and Assign
No right to assign or sublet unless landlord gives permission
MBE: Sublease and Assign
Tenants can assign or sublet unless lease says otherwise
Touch and concern the Land
If performance of covenant makes land more valuable or useful
Assignments/ Privity of Estate
between landlord and present tenant or tenant and assigned landlord
Assignments/ Privity of Contract
where there is agreement between parties or where assignee expressly assumes obligations under lease
Assigned Tenant
Will be liable for rent and covenants that touch and concern the land
Subleassor and Sublessee
Subleassor is deemed to have kept the estate
Sublessee is not liable to landlord (no privity of contract or privity of estate)
Non-assingment or nonsublease Clause
- Enforceable, Narrowly construed stating one does not prohibit against the other
If landlord gives permission, clause is waived for all time unless landlord states otherwise at time of giving permission
Landlord Tort Liability Generally
No duty to tenant or tenants inviteess
Exceptions to landlords no duty rule
latent defects, short tem lease of furnished dwelling, common areas under landlord control, negligent repair, public use exception
Landlord Liability with Latent Defects
duty to disclose (not repair) which landlord knows of or has reason to know of
Landlord Liability with Short Term Lease of Furnished Dwelling
Short term: 3 months or less
liable for defects even if landlord doesn’t know of has no reason to know of them
Landlord liability and Negligent Repair
Liable even if all due care was used
Landlord liability and Public Use
Landlord must know or should know of major defects, landlord must know or should know tenant will not fix defect, landlord must know or should know public will be using premises