Protection (Wills + Intestacy) Flashcards

1
Q

purpose

RESTRICTIONS ON POWER OF TESTATION

A

protection of the family

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

3 considerations

RESTRICTIONS ON POWER OF TESTATION

A
  1. Spousal protection
  2. Property rights
  3. Support rights
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

early 1900s

EVOLUTION OF PROPERTY RIGHTS

A

= the decedent spouse was allowed to disinherit the surviving spouse

EXCEPTIONS

  1. Dower
  2. Curtesy
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

mid-1900s

EVOLUTION OF PROPERTY RIGHTS

A

= disinherited spouse could renounce the will and elect to take ⅓ (or ½) of the probate estate

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

upc and modern statutes

EVOLUTION OF PROPERTY RIGHTS

A

= a disinherited spouse is entitled to a share of the total marital assets

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

2 systems

PROPERTY RIGHTS SYSTEMS

A
  1. Community property

2. Separate property

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

community property

PROPERTY RIGHTS SYSTEMS

A

= each spouse own an undivided interest in all earning of the spouses and property acquired from such earnings during marriage

@ death, a spouse has testamentary power over only his or her one-half community share

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

community property states

PROPERTY RIGHTS SYSTEMS

A
  • 9 states = community property states

- 3 states INCLUDING TN = optional community property states

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

separate property

PROPERTY RIGHTS SYSTEMS

A

= each spouse owns all of his or her earnings during the marriage

@ the death of one spouse, the surviving spouse has two options:

  1. Take under the decedent’s spouse’s will (or intestate laws if no will)
  2. Take an elective share
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

4 statutory tests

PROPERTY RIGHTS SYSTEMS

A
  1. intent to defraud test
  2. illusory transfer test
  3. general power of appointment test
  4. first-generation statute
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

intent to defraud test

PROPERTY RIGHTS SYSTEMS

A

= was the transfer made for the purpose of defrauding the surviving spouse out of his or her elective share?

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

2 factors

INTENT TO DEFRAUD TEST

A
  1. Subjective evidence

2. Objective evidence

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

objective evidence

INTENT TO DEFRAUD TEST

A
  1. Control retained by the transferor
  2. Amount of time between transfer and death
  3. Amount of property left to the surviving spouse
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

illusory transfer test

PROPERTY RIGHTS SYSTEMS

A

= did the transferor in good faith divest him or herself of ownership of the property or was the transfer illusory

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

rule

UPC GPOA TEST

A
  1. a marriage ends with death of spouse AND
  2. the deceased spouse had created an inter vivos trust during the marriage for which only that spouse had the general power of appointment
    = the assets of that trust shall be included in the probate estate for the purpose of determining the omitted spouse’s share
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

rationale

UPC GPOA TEST

A
  • public policy changes resulted in increased share of the estate for spouses upon divorce
  • an omitted spouse’s access to marital assets should not be more restricted than that of a divorced spouse
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

inquiry required

UPC GPOA TEST

A

imposes an objective test that does not require an inquiry into whether the trust was created for the purpose of disinheriting the spouse and avoiding the spousal share under the statute

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

tn modern approach

PROPERTY RIGHTS

A
  • Dower and curtesy are abolished

- Doesn’t affect rights that have vested before April 1, 1977

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

elective share

RESTRICTIONS ON POWER OF TESTATION

A
  • designed to protect a surviving spouse from disinheritance
  • give spouse an election to take a statutory share of decedent’s estate IN LIEU OF taking under the will
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

modern approach to protection of the surviving spouse

ELECTIVE SHARE

A

elective share statutes

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

tn omitted spouse protection

ELECTIVE SHARE

A

Will or any part revoked by both

  1. subsequent marriage AND
  2. birth of a child

(otherwise = spouse may opt for elective share)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

tn elective share formula

AMOUNT OF ELECTIVE SHARE

A

surviving spouse’s elective share %
MULTIPLIED BY decedent spouse’s net estate
MINUS property passing to surviving spouse
= elective share

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

step one

TN ELECTIVE SHARE FORMULA

A

surviving S of intestate D who elects AGAINST taking an intestate share
OR surviving S who elects against D’s will
- has a right of election
- to take an elective-share amount
- equal to the value of the D’s net estate
- determined by the length of marriage
— Less than 3 yrs = 10%
— 3 yrs but less than 6 yrs = 20%
— 5 yrs but less than 9 yrs = 30%
— 9 yrs or more = 40%

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

number of years (step one)

TN ELECTIVE SHARE FORMULA

A
  • years do not have to be consecutive, may be separated by divorce
  • number of years persons are married to the same person shall be combined
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
percentage of decedent's net estate for less than 3 yrs (step one) TN ELECTIVE SHARE FORMULA
= 10%
26
percentage of decedent's net estate for 3 yrs but less than 6 yrs (step one) TN ELECTIVE SHARE FORMULA
= 20%
27
percentage of decedent's net estate for 5 yrs but less than 9 yrs (step one) TN ELECTIVE SHARE FORMULA
= 30%
28
percentage of decedent's net estate for 9 yrs or more (step one) TN ELECTIVE SHARE FORMULA
= 40%
29
value of the net estate (step two) | TN ELECTIVE SHARE FORMULA
includes all of the decedent's real property and personal property subject to disposition under will/intestacy laws MINUS 1. secured debts to the extent that secured creditors are entitled to realize on the applicable collateral AND 2. funeral and administration expenses AND 3. award of exempt property, homestead allowance and year's support allowance
30
net does not include (step two) | TN ELECTIVE SHARE FORMULA
any assets over which the decedent held a power of appointment - whether exercised or not - UNLESS D exercises the power of appointment to direct the assets to be paid to the decedent's personal representative for administration as part of probate estate
31
step three | TN ELECTIVE SHARE FORMULA
amount payable to S by the estate shall be reduced by the value of all assets includable in the decedent's gross estate that were a. transferred or deemed transferred to S OR b. for the benefit of S EXCEPT 1. homestead allowance AND 2. exempt property AND 3. year's support allowance
32
fraud | NET ESTATE
any conveyance 1. made fraudulently 2. to children or others 3. with an intent to defeat S of distributive/elective share = at the election of S, can be a. includable in the decedent’s net estate b. voidable to the extent the other assets in the decedent’s net estate are insufficient to fund and pay the elective share amount
33
finley factors application | NET ESTATE
- used to determination whether conveyance should be voided - factors should not be applied mechanically - weight and significance of factors = depend on the facts of each particular case
34
7 finley factors | NET ESTATE
1. whether transaction was made with/without consideration 2. size of the transfer in relation to D's total estate, 3. time between the transfer and D's death, 4. relations which existed between D and S at the time of the transfer 5. source from which the property came 6. whether transfer was illusory 7. whether S was adequately provided for in the will
35
required procedure | WAIVER OF ELECTIVE SHARE
Notice must be filed, right to elective share is not automatic
36
notice of election | WAIVER OF ELECTIVE SHARE
= surviving spouse must file a notice of election within specific period
37
upc waiver of right to elect | WAIVER OF ELECTIVE SHARE
``` right of election of a surviving spouse AND rights of surviving spouse to a. homestead allowance b. exempt property c. and family allowance d. or any of them MAY BE WAIVED - wholly or partially - before or after marriage - by a written a. contract b. agreement c. waiver - signed by S ```
38
upc unenforceable waiver | WAIVER OF ELECTIVE SHARE
S’s waiver is not enforceable if the surviving spouse proves that - S did not execute the waiver voluntarily OR - that 4 elements are present 1. waiver was unconscionable when it was executed AND 2. before execution of the waiver S was not provided a fair and reasonable disclosure of the property or financial obligations of the decedent 3. did not voluntarily and expressly waive, in writing, any right to disclosure of the property or financial obligations of the decedent beyond disclosure provided AND 4. did not have, or reasonably could not have had, an adequate knowledge of the property or financial obligations of the decedent
39
upc extent of waiver | WAIVER OF ELECTIVE SHARE
a. waiver of "all rights” (or equivalent) in present/prospective spouse’s property/estate OR b. complete property settlement entered into after/in anticipation of separation/divorce = waiver of 1. all rights of elective share 2. homestead allowance 3. exempt property 4. AND family allowance = renunciation by each of all benefits that would otherwise pass by a. intestate succession OR b. will executed BEFORE the waiver OR c. property settlement UNLESS waiver provides to the contrary
40
upc unconscionability | WAIVER OF ELECTIVE SHARE
= for decision of court as a matter of law
41
tn waiver by antenuptial/prenuptial agreements | WAIVER OF ELECTIVE SHARE
Any antenuptial/prenuptial agreements re: property owned by either spouse before marriage = BINDING IF entered into 1. freely, knowledgeably, and in good faith 2. without exertion of duress or undue influence
42
independent counsel for antenuptial/prenuptial agreements | WAIVER OF ELECTIVE SHARE
- participation of independent counsel is not ESSENTIAL - BUT provides best assurance that the legal prerequisites will be met and that the antenuptial agreement will be found enforceable in the future
43
tn enforceability of antenuptial/prenuptial agreements | WAIVER OF ELECTIVE SHARE
Terms are enforceable by all remedies available for contract terms
44
general rule | SPOUSE'S PERSONAL RIGHT TO ELECTION
right to election is personal to spouse = only the surviving spouse may make the election to take against the will
45
exception | SPOUSE'S PERSONAL RIGHT TO ELECTION
= election can be made on behalf of legally incapacitated 1. With court approval 2. Upon a showing that an election is necessary to provide adequate support for the spouse during his or her life expectancy
46
spouse dies before election is made | SPOUSE'S PERSONAL RIGHT TO ELECTION
= election cannot be made by the spouse’s personal rep rationale = statute is intended to protect the surviving spouse against disinheritance, not to provide benefits to the spouse’s heirs
47
effect of election on testamentary plan | ELECTIVE SHARE
elective share is paid in the manner causing the least disruption to the T’s testamentary plan = 1. first paid in cash or kind from the assets passing under the will that, but for the election, would have passed to the spouse outright 2. to the extent that these assets are insufficient, excess is paid pursuant to the abatement rules that apply to creditors’ claims
48
lifetime transfer to defeat elective share | ELECTIVE SHARE
lifetime transfers by the decedent = subject to the elective share IF the grantor-spouse retained the power a. to revoke OR b. to invade, consume, or dispose of the principal = revocable trusts may not be used to defeat a spouse’s right of election (majority rule where addressed)
49
parent's disinheritance of kids | PROTECTION OF CHILDREN
1. A testator may disinherit her children | 2. = a parent need not bequeath anything to her children
50
pretermitted child statutes | PROTECTION OF CHILDREN
1. designed to protect children from being accidentally omitted from the will
51
2 situations | UPC PRETERMITTED CHILD STATUTE
1. T had no children living when executed will | 2. T had 1+ kids when will executed and gave stuff to 1+ of kids
52
testator had no children living when executed will | UPC PRETERMITTED CHILD STATUTE
= omitted kid gets share equal in value to that which the child would have received had the testator died intestate UNLESS 1. will devised all or substantially all of the estate 2. to the other parent of the omitted child and 3. that parent survives T and is entitled to take under the will
53
testator had one or more kids when will executed and gave stuff to one or more of the kids UPC PRETERMITTED CHILD STATUTE
= an omitted kid is entitled to 1. Share that’s limited to devises made to T’s then-living kids AND 2. Share that omitted kid would have received had T given equal shares to all omitted and non-omitted kids AND 3. Interest that is same character of that devised to then-living kids TO THE EXTENT FEASIBLE - Whether equitable or legal - Whether present or future
54
effect | UPC PRETERMITTED CHILD STATUTE
- To satisfy a share when T has 1+ kids and gave them stuff = devises to T’s then-living kids abate ratably - In abating, court shall preserve character of T’s testamentary plan TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT POSSIBLE
55
application | UPC PRETERMITTED CHILD STATUTE
ONLY APPLIES TO 1. Any child born or adopted after execution of will 2. Any child T fails to provide for in will SOLELY because he believes child to be dead
56
doesn't apply | UPC PRETERMITTED CHILD STATUTE
DOESN’T APPLY 1. If appear from the will that the omission was intentional OR 2. T provided for the omitted after-born or after-adopted child by transfer outside the will AND intent that the transfer be in lieu of a testamentary provision is a. shown by the testator's statements OR b. is reasonably inferred from the amount of the transfer or other evidence
57
rule | TN PRETERMITTED CHILD STATUTE
Child born or adopted after making of a will who is - Not provided for - Nor disinherited - Nor provided for by settlement made by T in T’s lifetime - BUT PRETERMITTED = gets the same portion of T’s estate as if T died intestate
58
application | TN PRETERMITTED CHILD STATUTE
to raise this portion = devisees/legatees/other heirs shall CONTRIBUTE PROPORTIONALLY out of their shares
59
rule | OMITTED CHILD
a child born or adopted after the will was executed takes an intestate share of the decedent’s estate
60
application of abatement | OMITTED CHILD
normal abatement rules apply
61
exceptions | PROTECTION OF PRETERMITTED CHILDREN
pretermitted child will not take a share IF a. It appears from the will that the omission was intentional OR b. At the time the will was executed, the testator had other children and devised substantially all of his estate to the other parent of the omitted child OR c. The testator provided for the omitted child by a transfer outside of the will with the intent that it was in lieu of a testamentary gift
62
limited to bequests to other children | PROTECTION OF PRETERMITTED CHILDREN
1. T had other children at the time the will was executed AND 2. the will makes a provision for one or more of the children = pretermitted kid’s portion of the estate is limited to the provisions made to the other children
63
reduction of bequests | PROTECTION OF PRETERMITTED CHILDREN
the bequests to the other children are reduced by pretermitted kid BUT no other beneficiary’s bequest is reduced (UPC/some state)
64
failure to provide for child believed to be dead | PROTECTION OF PRETERMITTED CHILDREN
UPC/majority exception to general rule application only afterborn and after-adopted children existing children are protected IF T fails to provide in her will for a living child solely because she mistakenly believed the child to be dead = the child shares in the estate as though he were an omitted afterborn or after-adopted child
65
pretermitted grandchildren | PROTECTION OF PRETERMITTED CHILDREN
pretermitted child statute operates only in favor of the testator’s children = the testator’s grandchildren are not covered
66
3 upc support rights | PROTECTION OF FAMILY
S and/or minor children are entitled to 1. Homestead exemption 2. Personal property exemption 3. Family allowance
67
upc homestead exemption | PROTECTION OF FAMILY
= homestead is exempt from all creditors up to the value of $15K
68
upc personal property exemption | PROTECTION OF FAMILY
= tangible personal property is exempt from unsecured creditors up to the value of 10K
69
upc application | PROTECTION OF FAMILY
Support rights are NOT CHARGEABLE against any benefit for share passing to S or children by 1. D’s will 2. Intestate succession 3. Elective share
70
upc family allowance | PROTECTION OF FAMILY
- financial support for the period of administration of the decedent's estate - the surviving spouse and decedent children are entitled to a reasonable allowance
71
4 tn support rights | PROTECTION OF FAMILY
1. Homestead 2. Family allowance 3. Exempt personal property 4. Life insurance proceeds
72
tn homestead | PROTECTION OF FAMILY
= TN statute protects family residence/farm - Up to an aggregate value of 5K for property in individual’s name - Up to an aggregate value of 7.5K for property held jointly = EXEMPT from creditor’s claims
73
property in individual’s name | TN HOMESTEAD
Up to an aggregate value of 7.5K for property held jointly | = EXEMPT from creditor’s claims
74
property held jointly | TN HOMESTEAD
Up to an aggregate value of 7.5K for property held jointly | = EXEMPT from creditor’s claims
75
death of household head | TN HOMESTEAD
REGARDLESS OF PROVISIONS MADE IN WILL head of the household dies = homestead property passes 1. to the surviving spouse for life and 2. then to the decedent’s minor kids free from debts of mother/father/children and 3. once minor kids come of age/die = land can be sold and proceed distributed to head of household’s intestate heirs
76
individuals 62 yrs and older | TN HOMESTEAD
TN statute provides for larger homestead amount for individuals 62 yrs and older
77
amount of land exempted | TN HOMESTEAD
depends on whether the residence is urban or rural
78
tn family allowance | PROTECTION OF FAMILY
= 1 year’s support - authorizes payment out of an estate of amount needed to maintain S (and kids) for a year - in addition to homestead, exempt personal property, share of estate
79
purpose | TN FAMILY ALLOWANCE
= to provide funds for support of the spouse and children during the period the decedent’s assets are tied up in probate administration
80
tn personal property exemption | PROTECTION OF FAMILY
a. the surviving spouse of an intestate decedent OR b. a spouse who elects against a decedent's will = entitled to receive from the estate of the decedent certain exempt personal property having a fair market value not exceeding 50K (in excess of any indebtedness or security interests in the property) (in addition to benefits passing by 1. intestate succession 2. elective share 3. homestead 4. a year’s support allowance)
81
exempt personal property | TN PERSONAL PROPERTY EXEMPTION
this exemption applies to 1. Tangible personal property - normally located in or about the principal residence AND - not used primarily in a trade or business, or for investment purposes 2. Motor vehicles - not used primarily in a trade or business
82
no surviving spouse | TN PERSONAL PROPERTY EXEMPTION
D’s unmarried minor children are entitled, as tenants in common, to the exempt property
83
tn life insurance proceeds | PROTECTION OF FAMILY
life insurance on a decedent’s life is generally exempt from creditors’ claims
84
applicable law | EXAM INSTRUCTIONS
1. wills = tn (compare to UTC) intestacy = tn (compare to UTC) 2. trusts = UTC (or majority if UTC silent) 3. non-probate transfers = majority 4. powers of appointment = majority 5. uniform prudent investment act = adopted by tn 6. uniform principle and income act = adopted by tn