Programming & Analysis 10-11 Flashcards
How to Survey Existing Buildings
Use field measurements and site-survey techniques, or accurate as-builts if available.
Survey - Site Features
Includes: parking service access pedestrian access adjacent properties microclimate amenities (views and water features)
Survey - Building Configuration
Includes:
•buildings overall size, shape and height
•location of columns, bearing walls, beams and other major structural components
•location of partitions, toilets, mechanical rooms and other service areas should also be noted
Survey - Building Structure
Includes:
•building type, load capacity and condition
•condition of foundation and primary structural frame is most important, correcting can be expensive. Usually requires structural engineering
Survey - Roof
Includes:
•type, condition and expected remaining life
•Check for signs of water leaking
•May require core drilling for assembly or infrared testing for weakened areas.
Survey - Exterior Envelope
Includes:
- Type and condition
- Existing insulation type and R-Value
- Windows in good condition
- Infrared testing could be helpful
Survey - Mech Systems
Includes:
- Type of heating and cooling
- Capacity o central plant
- Condition of distribution system
- Mech engineer typically required for this portion
Survey - Plumbing
Includes:
- Capacity of service to building
- Capacity of sewer
- Condition of pipe and fixtures
- Quantity of fixtures
- Mech engineer typically required for this portion
Survey - Electrical
Includes:
- Capacity of service
- Condition of primary and secondary service
- Condition of wiring and devices
- Condition of lighting and electrical components
- Electrical engineer typically required for this portion
Survey - Fire Protection
Includes:
- Condition of system
- Pipe sizing
- Spacing of Heads
- Fire Protection or Mech Engineer may be required
Survey - Major Equipment
If applicable, may include:
Refrigeration equipment
Commercial Food Service Equipment
Laboratory Equipment
Survey - Finishes
Condition and expected life of major surfaces finishes
Survey - Compliance with accessibility requirements
Condition of egress system and fire-rated elements should also be evaluated
General Survey
- If building is historic structure or historic value, additional issues to be investigated
- Architect needs to discuss costs and schedule to determine if end results can be achieved.
Document Building Survey Media
Several Media types: Hand drawings Cad Drawings Notes Reports Photos Videos
Building Survey Documentation
Include:
- Building structure, Exterior and interior walls
- doors, equipment, woodwork, plumbing fixtures, other pertinent items
- Scaled determined by size of building/Project
- Elevations
- MEP components
- Items to be removed should be highlighted
Field Measuring and Recording Methods - Digital Tools
Electromagnetic Distance Measurement (EDM) - Uses laser machine and reflector, requires knowledge of user to determine points (Accuracy at +/- 1/64 per 1600’)
Reflectorless Electromagnetic Distance Measurement (REDM) - Uses the return signal of laser to measure, not as accurate (+/- 1/8 at 100’) Laser could be skewed by surroundings, requires a point to still be placed
Laser Scanning - Medium range pulsing laser to sweep over object or space to form various cad images from 2D to 3D. Does not require points for scanning. Accuracy within +/- .05 - .01%.
Field Measuring and Recording Methods - Photography
- Rectified Photography - Uses flat images with no perspective distortion to produce images that allow scaling and dimensions. Good for hard to measure spots. Uses digital photos and measured points to adjust.
- Orthophotography - Like Rectified but software corrects for optical distortion
- Photogrammetry - Survey of objects or space through photos and software
- Stereophotogrammetry - uses two overlapping photos in computer program to create accurate 3d drawing
- Convergent Photogrammetry - uses multiple photographic images at different angles to produce 3d drawing within software - slower than laser scanning but +/- .05% accuracy
Survey - Regulations
Architect must confirm regulatory requirements, which requires building construction type and occupancy, but includes:
- Building Codes
- Zoning
- Easements
- Deed restrictions
- Covenants
- Historic Preservation
- Energy Conservation
- Local agency
Analyzing Existing Structures
Includes:
- Does location and features of site for new use or can it be adapted
- Structures size and configuration work for new use or can it be adapted
- Doe appearance and character align with clients goals
- Amount of work and costs to repair, renovate, modify and add to structure and MEP systems to meet new use, including seismic upgrades and adding fire sprinklers
- Does new occupancy work with existing structure
- Additional work needed to meet current codes and regulations
- Minimum renovations needed to meet needs if no budget or schedule established
- Detailed cost analysis should be performed to determine the right path or feasibility.
Historic Structure Evaluation governing bodies
Historic Preservation Service of the National Park Service provides information and regulations on historic preservation. If landmark contact the state and historic preservation officer and National park service should be consulted
Types of Historic Preservation
Preservation - Maintain and preserve
Rehabilitation - Retention and repair of a building - more emphasis on replacement usually due to deterioration
Restoration - Focuses on most significant time period
Reconstruction - recreate non-surviving site.
Federal Historic Preservation Tax Incentive Program (36 CFR 67) General Standards
10 general standards often referred to the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation:
- Property used for historic use or new use that requires minimal change of characteristics
- Historic Character to be retained and preserved, removal to be avoided
- Recognized as physical record of time, no addition of other elements from other buildings
- Historically significant changes should be retained and preserved
- Distinctive characteristics to be preserved
- Deteriorated features to be repaired instead of replaced as possible.
- avoid Chemical or physical treatments
- Significant archeological resources affected to be protected and preserved
- New construction shall not destroy historic characteristics and should be differentiated
NPS Guidelines for preservation restoration and reconstruction
10 guidelines:
- Property used as it was historically or given new use reflective of restoration period
- characteristics of restoration period will be retained and preserved
- Recognized as physical record of time, associated work to be physically and visually compatible, identifiable upon close inspection and properly documented
- characteristics from other historical periods to be documented prior to removal
- Distinctive characteristics to be preserved
- Deteriorated features to be repaired instead of replaced as possible.
- replacement of missing features from restoration period to be substantiated by documentary and physical evidence, do not create false sense of history.
- Chemical or physical treatments that cause damage to be avoided, surface cleaning to be as gentle as possible
- Significant archeological resources affected to be protected and preserved
- Designs never executed historically will not be constructed.
Surveying Historic Structures
Same list applies as Surveying existing buildings, but also include:
- Structure survey to assess settlement, deflection and structural members previously damaged
- Determine what elements have been removed or altered and original appearance
- Define characteristics that define historic character and prioritize
- Physical survey from a restoration specialists may be required
Masonry in Historic Buildings
- Identify, Retain and Preserve - Identify unique masonry features for the period
- Protect and Maintain - provide drainage, clean when needed to prevent deterioration, avoid chemical or sand-blasting damage, Only remove paint if damaged, repaint per period.
- Repair or replace if there are signs of deterioration or damage, damaged masonry units should be repaired via patching or piecing. Only replace extremely damaged with similar pieces
- Replace with reproduction if too deteriorated, must be like for like or comparable substitute
- Remove existing features from other historic periods
- Recreate if feature is entirely missing, used as last option.
Programming Definition
State of defining the problem and establishing guidelines
Programming Phases
- Establish Goals - Clients objectives and reasons behind them
- Collecting Fact - existing conditions and requirements for meeting the clients goals
- Uncovering Concepts - Process should develop concepts, abstract solutions for clients problems
- Determining Needs - balancing desires of clients against budget or establishing budget based on defined goal and needs.
- Stating the problem - The bridge between programming and design process.
Programming Concepts
General abstract solutions to the client’s problems
Expansibility
Programming Concept - when a client’s needs may change in the future.
Four Major Programming Components
Function - People and activities within the space and relationships
Form - Relates to the site, physical and psychological environment and quality of building
Economy - Money, initial, operating and life-cycle costs.
Time - past, present and future and affect on Function, Form and Economy.
Problem Seeking by Pena and Parshall
Identified 24 programmatic concepts that recur in all types of buildings.
- Priority
Programming concept that establishes order of importance
- Relationships
Programming concept that include the affinities of people and activities
- Hierarchy
Programming concept that relates to the exercise or expression of authority through physical symbols
- Character
Programming Concept that is a response to the image that the client wants to project, combination of look and feel of environment.
- Density
Programming concept that typically rated low, medium or high and describes how a parcel of land or individual building or space is used.
- Service Groupings
Programming concept that building services that support use of building (ex. MEP Rooms)
- Activity Grouping
Programming concept that is a determination of whether activities should be integrated and grouped together or separated and compartmentalized.
- People Grouping
Programming concept concerned with how people are placed together based on their physical, social and emotional characteristics
- Home Base
Programming concept that relates to the concept of territoriality and is a place where a person can maintain his or her individuality
- Communications
Programming Concept that promotes the effective exchange of information or ideas by examining who communicates with whom and how exchanges are conducted.
- Neighbors
Programming Concept that refers to how the project will promote or prevent sociality and how the building or facility will relate to surroundings
- Accessibility
Programming concept that concerns the entry to the building and making the facility accessible to all.
- Separated Flow
Programming Concept that relates to segregating the flow of people, automobiles, service access and other activities of a building.
- Orientation
Programming Concept concerned with keeping people from feeling lost within a larger context, usually provides a point of reference.
- Mixed Flow
Programming Concept opposite of separated flow and intended to promote integration among people.
- Sequential Flow
Programming concept often needed for both people and objects for specific series of events or processes.
- Flexibility
Programming concept that includes expansibility, convertibility (allow for change) and versatility
- Tolerance
Programming Concept allows some extra space for an activity that is likely to change in the future
- Safety
Programming Concept focused on how to minimize the risk of injury or death
- Security Controls
Programming Concept for ways to protect both people and property with a degree of security based on value.
- Energy Conservation
Programming concept of using materials and components produced with little energy, recycled materials or by using recyclable materials
- Environmental Controls
Programming concept of using controls to meet human comfort needs
- Phasing
Programming Concept of completing project in stages to meet time and cost schedules
- Cost Control
Programming concept of establishing realistic preview of costs and balanced budget to meet clients available funds
Determining Space Needs
Two factors in determining size and configuration are:
- Amount of space needed for activities
- Relationships needed among spaces
Methods to determine space requirements
- Client directed requirements
- Number of people who must be accommodated
- By an object or equipment within the spaces and clearances
- By an activity that has clear specified space needs
Benchmarking
Establishing common standards based on similar facilities
Net Area
Net area of building is determined by space requirements of the building, does not include support space or general circulation