Nature and Nurture Flashcards
What is nature?
- Nature is inherited disposition
- The behaviour is explained through GENES, GENETIC VARIANCE AND HERITABILITY
- GENES = aggression – MAOA
= schizophrenia = S2-DISC1
= Anorexia nervosa - HERITABILITY = This is how the genes are inherited within a family
-GENETIC VARIANCE = the extent to which behaviours are genetic
= S2 – 79%
= AN – 70%
= OCD – 29%
- In nature we can talk about anatomical differences such as brain structure (but only if they are born this way)
- INATE BEHAVIOURS = these are evolutionary explanations (survival of the fittest)
What is nurture?
- The environment influences behaviour
- FOR EXAMPLE CLASSICAL CONDITIONING, OPERANT CONDITIONING AND SOCIAL LEARNING THEORY (role models and vicarious reinforcement)
- TABULU RASA = (Locke) – that you are born a blank late and it is your experiences that make up who you are
What is interactionism?
- This is when both nature and nurture work together
Diathesis-stress model:
- These are genetic pre-disposition + environmental factors that come together and for the behaviour
Epigenetics:
- That the environment switches genes on/off to cause different behaviours
How do we study nature and nurture?
TWINS:
- We are interested into monozygotic twins and dizygotic twins (but less than MZ)
- With twins we are looking at concordance rates = the percentage of times that both twins have the same disorder/same diagnosis
- If a behaviour is completely genetic, then the concordance rate of MZ twins would be 100%
- The problem with genetic explanations is that the concordance rates of MZ twins is never 100%
ADOPTION STUDIES:
- With adoption studies you have biological parents however you are raised by people that are not your biological parents
- looking at genes from biological parents and the environment provided by adoptive parents
What are the strengths and weaknesses of the way that we study nature and nurture?
TWINS:
- STRENGTH – They are representative of all twins, and they are easy to access due to twin registries
- WEAKNESS – The equal environments assumption = this is when it is assumed that the twins had the same environment growing up and that they were raised similarly.
However, MZ twins are treated more similarly than DZ twins and they are more likely to experience identity confusion
ADOPTION STUDIES:
-STRENGTH – they show us that twin studies overestimate genetic influences
- WEAKNESS – selective placement = this is when adopted parents are often similar to a child’s biological parents (not really separating nurture from nature)
- WEAKNESS – another weakness is that it is a naturally occurring IV because the problematic children will stay in the system for longer so they are more likely to have problems
SOCIAL
What is an example of nature in social?
- Obedience to authority might be due to personality factors, which are predisposed.
- Burger looked at the personality traits of empathetic concern and desire for personal control in his replication of Milgram.
- He found that the defiant participants had a significantly higher desire for personal control.
What is another example of nature in social?
When we are ‘AGENTS’ TO THOSE IN AUTHORITY, this might be something that EVOLVED in humans because being in a society protects us and is a survival trait.
- This is seen in Charles Hoffling et al as after being asked by authority (a doctor) to administer an overdose of a drug, 95% administered it.
- This is because they were doing what they were told and not rebelling.
What is an example of nurture in social?
- The AUTHORITARIAN PERSONALITY may be due to how a person was raised.
- Adorno believed that a harsh style of parenting leads children to develop traits such as toughness, destructiveness and cynicism, which are features of the authoritarian personality.
What is another example of nurture in social?
- When exposed to SOCIAL PRESSURES AND MORAL STRAIN we are more likely to be obedient.
- This is seen in Milgram’s study as, despite instincts telling them to stop and anxiety, in the presence of a professional experimenter and prompts that told them to go on, 65% of the participants administered the full 450V shock.
- This is nurture as societal pressures lead us to do things.
COGNITIVE
What is an example of nature in cognitive?
- There is a focus on brain functioning and BRAIN STRUCTURE in the way that we remember.
- For example, it is suggested that the medial temporal lobe and the hippocampus are connected to short term memory processing.
What is another example of nature in cognitive?
- SCHEMAS are an innate mental structure that is used to make quick decisions about people and things for our survival and to save energy.
What is an example of nurture in cognitive?
- The idea of RECONSTRUCTIVE MEMORY is nurture.
- This is because Bartlett claimed that any gaps in the reconstructions of our memories and filled with our expectations and stereotypes which are based off our past experiences.
What is another example of nurture in cognitive?
- There are CULTURAL DIFFERENCES in the way words are encoded
- This is known as the word length effect
- This is seen in Sebastian and Hernandez gill as the digit span for Spanish children continued to increase until 17 whereas for Anglo-Saxon children it was 15, as it takes longer for Spanish children to rehearse the words as they have more syllables.
BIOLOGICAL
What is an example of nature in biological?
- Aggression may be caused by differences in GENES, HORMONES AND BRAIN STRUCTURE.
- For example differences in hormone levels such as high levels of testosterone may cause the aggression. - Dabbs et al in the women prisons where the degree of criminal violence used by the women was positively correlated with testosterone
What is another example of nature in biological?
- FREUD believed that we had AGGRESSIVE INSTINCTS.
- The id and the pleasure principle contain instincts, impulses and drives that are socially unacceptable, including aggressive drives.
- These unconscious instincts we are born with and therefore are innate.