Nation State Flashcards
Sovereignty
A principle that the state has absolute and ultimate power
What is the Westphalian system
Each individual state is sovereign over its own internal affairs and no other state or superior body has the legal right to interfere within its borders
Montevideo Convention
A state’s sovereignty is determined by:
-Defined Territory
-Permanent population
-Viable government
Impact of COVID-19 on nation states
President of the EU commission criticised member state for unilaterally re-imposing boarder controls to stop the spread of the virus.
Synoptic Link to Core Ideas
-Democracy
-Rule of Law
-Capitalism
-Human Rights
What is a democratic state
Free and fair regular elections which governments are elected and are accountable to the public. A democratic state derives from the popular consent of the people.
Value in liberal right and freedoms and th
Example of a democratic state
UK and US
Semi Democratic state
A state that superficially possesses the characteristics of a democracy but has underlying authoritarian features where the govt is not constrained by the rule of law.
Example of a semi-democratic state
South Africa
Authoritarian state
Places power with one individual or party usually unelected so lacks legitimacy and controls the media and judiciary
Example of authoritarian state
Russia and China
Non-democratic state
An autocratic or authoritarian state which lacks any democratic legitimacy and not accountable to its citizens.
Autocratic vs Democratic
Autocratic:
-Power is centralised in hands of single party or person
-No elections
-Judiciary lacks independence
-Heavy state control over population and political institutions
Democratic:
-Power is distributed with various checks and balances
-Free and fair elections providing govt with legitimacy
-Govt is made regularly accountable
-Rule of law ensures there are limits on what the govt can do protecting citizens rights.
Is democracy most effective to promote. Yes
-Good for political development as it empowers the populace so they are less likely to want to rebel against the system
-Democracy goes hand in hand with liberal values which encourages multilateralism and cooperation
-Democracy complements free trade and capitalism a significant factor in economic development enabling a more peaceful and sustainable development
-Democratic govt are held to account and therefore more able to uphold human rights.
Is democracy most effective to promote peace. No.
-A dictator can benefit an underdeveloped on new country through strong leadership in a country that is volatile this could create more stability.
-Democracy is unsustainable if implemented too early
-Many developing countries benefit from protectionist policies as they are a good way to stabilise economic growth
-Western Liberals often assume that democracies always provide the best form of govt and that authoritarian govt impede development. However some authoritarian states have achieved impressive growth rates, e.g By 2028 China’s economy is set to overtake the US.
Arab Spring
Beginning in Tunisia 2010 when protesters mounted against the movement of the Presidents oppressive regime sparking a revolutionary wave of support for the installation of democracy across the Arab World
Failed State
A state which has lost its ability to fulfil it fundamental security and development function, lacking effective control over its territory
Example of a failed state
Somalia and South Sudan.
Democratic Republic of Congo:
-Characterised by civil war and suffers from great ethnic divisions
-In an unstable region with deep seated corruption at the highest levels of authority and militias being prominent in the country
-Victim of Western colonialism, exploitation and interference
Rogue state
a state that does not respect other states in its international actions.
Rogue state example
North Korea:
-Readiness to threaten to use nuclear weapons poses a threat to international stability and other nation states.
-Hostile to neighbours -South Korea
-northkorea does not cooperate in the international system and has frequently broken international laws. it has one of the worst human rights record directly against the UN and has failed to uphold international agreements even when it has signed them
E.g. Treaty on the non-proliferation of Nuclear Weapons
Soft Power
Ability to persuade other states to emulate its world view
Cultural power: A state’s global outreach through television, film, food, fashion and brand names which can have influence in international relations.
Diplomacy: Reach of foreign policy and global impressions made by a state. A state should be prepared to provide global leadership on conflict resolution, environment, global economy, poverty and development
Hard Power
Threats and coercion
Economy: Levels of debt, stability of economic growth and influence over trade rules and contributions to international programs
Military power: Size of nations standing army and its ability to deploy anywhere at any time. Naval strength, air force and technological capacities
Smart Power
The use of both hard and soft power to achieve aims.
Example: Obama’s administration
-1st presidential term in the Cairo speech he focused on the benefits of islamic culture and need for cooperation
-2nd term Obama demonstrated willingness to use hard power where necessary in the Cairo speech stated the US wouldn’t tolerate extremist threats to its national security
Other powers
Structural Power: states capacity to influence intergovernmental organisations such as the UN, IMF, WTO, G7, G20, AIIB
Regional power: states may pool sovereignty to enhance their influence which may give them a greater level of diplomatic pressure.
Research & Developmental power: can provide states with a strategic advantage especially in terms of nee technology
Natural Resources: states that are resource rich can possess significant bargaining power and harder to sanction due to other state’s reliance on their resources. They may also be able to act more independently
However being resource rich has its hindrances (resource curse) as it can encourage powerful states to try to economically dominate poorer countries. Relegating them to neocolonial dependency.