Module 4: Determining the Truth Flashcards
Philosophy deals with the concept of
truth
Knowledge must be truthful to gain ________
validity and acceptance
how to justify?
through perception
appeal to authority
use of reasoning
5 theories of truth
- correspondence
- coherence
- constructivist
- consensus
- pragmatic
the Greeks understand knowledge as
justified true beliefs
there is a connection
correspondence
correspondence comes from a Latin word:
correspondentia: idea of things that go together or match
correspondentia is a combination of what latin words?
cor : together
respondere: to respond/ to answer
your statement should connect to your actions
correspondence
coherence comes from the Greek word:
cohaerentia
co: together
haerentia: adhering or sticking
something is true if it corresponds with reality of the way things are
ex. A mammal is any class of warm-blooded higher vertebrae
corresnpondence theory
the theory that is based on perspectives
ex. Muslims have a belief that certain animals like pigs are unclean.
coherence theory
hold together logically or forming a unified whole
coherence
this theory of truth is universal
correspondence theory
coherence theory promotes
relativism: no absolute truths
a belief is true if it is part of a coherent system of beliefs
coherence theory
something is true if it make sense when placed in a certain situation or context
coherence theory
a theory which always have context
coherence theory
knowledge is gained through the experience of society that requires interaction or collaboration
ex. marriage
constructivist theory
a theory that believes that reality is constructed by human beings
constructivist theory
you build the truth
constructivist theory
shaped by social forces and influenced by culture and history
constructivist theory
agreement
consensus
a philosophical POV which holds that truth is a matter of social agreements
consensus theory
majority of the society accepts
it as true, therefore, it is true
ex. Decision of the IAV in 2006 to change the planet Pluto classification to a dwarf planet
consensus
useful
pragmatic
tested to confirm validity
pragmatic theory
something is true if it works or we can apply or make it useful in real life
ex. after 6 diet
pragmatic theory
they are presented in a form of arguments, and these arguments are phrased in a way that they mae look or sound reasonable or logical
fallacy
mistake in reasoning or faulty reasoning
fallacy
defect in an argument because of false premises or false conclusions
fallacy
fallacy is derived from the Latin word:
fallo: I deceive
the three divisions of fallacy
- fallacy of language
- fallacy not of language
- fallacy of relevance
the six fallacies of language
- equivocation
- amphiboly
- composition
- division
- accent
- figures of speech
fallacy of language in which a term is used in 2 or more different senses within a single argument
equivocation
determine the fallacy of language:
Jesse Magno was a minister. Pope Francis is a minister. Therefore, Pope Francis is Jesses Magno
equivocation
a fallacy of language that occurs when there is a defect in the grammatical construction of the sentence
amphiboly
a fallacy of language that gives the argument a double interpretation due to the structural defect, mistake in grammar, or arrangement of words
amphiboly
determine the fallacy of language:
I read a book riding in a bus yesterday.
amphiboly
a fallacy of language that occurs when one argues that since each part of the whole has a certain feature, it follows that the whole has the same feature
composition
determine the fallacy of language:
specific to general
composition
a fallacy of language that argues that since the whole has some feature, each part must also have that feature
division
a fallacy of language in which the attributes of the whole is applied to a specific part
division
determine the fallacy of language:
general to specific
division
determine the fallacy of language:
Each member of the gymnastics team weighs less than 110 lbs. Therefore, the whole gymnastics team weighs less than 110 lbs.
composition
determine the fallacy of language:
The house costs 1 million dollars. Therefore, each part of the house costs 1 million dollars.
division
a fallacy of language that happens when there is a faulty or undue emphasis (accent/ tone) upon certain words or statement
accent
determine the fallacy of language:
slow men at work
accent
it is a fallacy of language that wrongly inferring similarity of meaning from similarity of word structure
figures of speech
fallacy of language that causes confusion in both senses of some words
figures of speech