Mod2_External Criticism Flashcards
__ are common enough to keep the careful historian constantly on guard
Forgeries of documents in whole or in part
“___” are fabricated for several reasons
Historical Documents
“___” are fabricated for several reasons
Historical Documents
Reason to fabricate historical documents: used to bolster a ____
false claim or title
Reason to fabricate historical documents: it is due to less __ considerations (ex: political propaganda)
mercenary
Reason to fabricate historical documents: sometimes quite genuine documents are intended to mislead ____ and hence have misled subsequent historians
contemporaries
Occasionally, misinterpretations of the nature of printed works results from the ____
editors’ tricks
To test Authenticity, historians examines the __ to see whether they are not anachronistic
materials
__ means belonging to a period other than that being portrayed
anachronistic
____ is a person, thing, idea that exist out of its time in history, especially one that happened later than teh period being shown, discussed
anachronism
___ (idiom, orthography or punctuation) can be detected by specialist who are familiar with contemporary writing
Anachronistic style
____ to early or too late or too remote; or dating of a document at a time when the alleged writer could not possibly have been at the place designated uncovers fraud
Anachronistic references to events
__ is a document that in its entirety or in large part is the result of a deliberate effort to deceive may often be hard to evaluate
Garbled documents
The first task of restoration of texts are ____
the first task is to collect as many copies of the dubious text as diligent search will reveal then compare
The problem of credibility is not that what actually happened , but that is ____ as we can learn from a critical examination of the best available sources
close to what actually happened
The elementary data of history is subject to ____
proof
A historical “_____ “ may be defined as a particular derived directly or indirectly from historical documents and regarded as credible after careful testing in
accordance with the canons of historical method
fact
___ is a method where historians either asks in relatively ____ (Did she try do it?) or may be ____but still implicit and in interrogative form (Can she be held responsible for it?)
Interrogative Hypothesis
noncommittal
full-fledged
General rule 1: Was the ___ of the detail (the primary witness) able to tell the
truth?
ultimate source
General rule 2: Was the primary witness ___ to tell the truth?
willing
General rule 3: Is the primary witness accurately reported with regard to the ___?
detail under examination
General rule 4: Is there any independent ___of the detail under examination?
corroboration
Any detail (regardless of what the source or who the author) that passes all four tests is ____
credible historical evidence
___ depends upon degree of expertness, state of mental and physical health, age, education, memory, narrative skill, etc. The ability to estimate number is especially subject to suspicion
Competence
Hearsay and Secondary Evidence Rule 1: On whose ____ does the secondary witness base his statements?
primary testimony
Hearsay and Secondary Evidence Rule 2:
Did the secondary witness accurately report the primary testimony as a whole?
Hearsay and Secondary Evidence Rule 3:
If not, in what details did he accurately report the primary testimony?