Mental Health Flashcards
What are some historical explanations for mental health?
Four humours:
- the body is made up of blood, yellow bile, black bile and phlegm
- your symptoms could be related to an excess fluid (e.g. yellow bile leading to mania)
Demonic Spirits:
- possessed by an evil spirit which could be released through trepanning (drilling a hole in the head)
How have views of mental health changed throughout history?
- before and during the 1800s seen as supernatural or imbalance in the universe (e.g. demonic spirits or planetary alignments)
- then more somatogenic explanations, for example suggesting that mental health problems are an indication of disturbance in the brain structure - this led to a move towards more medical treatments
- at the same time, psychogenic explanations were starting to take place, with psychoanalysis and cognitive explanations in the 20th century
How would you define abnormality as a statistical infrequency?
A trait, way of thinking or behaviour should be classified as abnormal if it is rare
Evaluation:
- doesn’t take into account desirability of behaviour - not all rare behaviours are abnormal
- behaviours we may consider abnormal may not be rare - e.g. 4% of the population has schizophrenia
How would you define abnormality as a deviation from social norms?
A person’s thinking or behaviour is classified as abnormal if it violates the rules about what is expected or accepted in a particular social group.
Their behaviour may:
- be incomprehensible to others
- make others uncomfortable
Evaluation:
- can take into account behaviour desirability
- however social norms change over time
- definition is culturally relativist
How would you define abnormality as a deviation from ideal mental health?
Rather than define what is abnormal, we define what is normal and anything that deviates from that is considered abnormal. This includes:
- positive view of oneself
- capability for growth
- independence
- positive relationships
Evaluation:
- focuses on positive characteristics which can be used to set goals for treatment
- many criteria difficult to measure
- culturally relativist
How would you define abnormality as the failure to function adequately?
Person should be considered to be abnormal if they’re unable to cope with the demands of everyday life, e.g. if they can’t hold down a job or interact meaningfully with others
Evaluation:
- can be easily identified by others
- easy to access
- some are subjective
- difficult to determine when personal distress becomes dysfunctional as sometimes it is necessary
What is the difference between the ICD-10 and the DSM-V?
- ICD has both physical and mental disorders whilst the DSM has only mental
- the ICD is intended to be used in any culture (was trialled in 40 countries to see if diagnoses improved) whilst the DSM is mainly used in the US (does attempt to acknowledge culture by suggesting diagnosis is more challenging when the patient’s culture is different from the clinician’s)
- ICD: each disorder has a description of the main features and how many are needed for a diagnosis, DSM: decided whether the patient is showing symptoms of a clinical or personality disorder and their functioning is rated from 1-100
What were the aims of Rosenhan’s experiment?
- to test the reliability and validity of the diagnostic system
- to investigate whether a number of sane pseudopatients would be discovered
- to complete a reliable and valid observation and report on the experiences of being a patient in a psychiatric hospital
What procedure did Rosenhan carry out?
- 8 pseudopatients were given fake names and fake occupations to protect their identities
- called hospitals and complained of hearing unfamiliar voices of the same sex saying “empty”, “hollow” and “thud” - all other information was completely honest
- all symptoms of existential psychosis, of which there were no reported cases, so there was more likely to be a diagnosis of schizophrenia
- once they were admitted they stopped showing symptoms and behaved normally
What evidence of powerlessness and depersonalisation can be found in the way hospital staff treated patients?
Powerlessness - staff were violent towards patients and abusive behaviour only stopped when another member of staff was present
Depersonalisation - despite being concerned that the staff would notice their note taking, no one ever asked what it was about; they were treated like they were invisible
Why did the staff act the way they did towards the patients?
- product of generally held prejudices against mentally ill people
- product of the inverse relationship between power and the amount of time spent with patients
What was the type 2 error in Rosenhan’s study?
The patients were being diagnosed with schizophrenia when they were actually perfectly healthy
What is the stickiness of labels?
The idea that someone will be prejudiced against because it is very difficult to shake the label of being mentally ill - even on release they are only “in remission”, suggesting their condition will never truly go away
What provided evidence of the effects of labelling in the hospital?
- If a patient “went beserk” because they’d been mistreated by an attendant, the nurse who dealt with it would simply pass it off as a symptom of their condition
- Because the hospital is so boring, patients planned days around mealtimes, which doctors saw as a symptom of their conditions when really they were just bored
What happened when staff at a large hospital heard about Rosenhan’s study?
- they doubted the validity and said that they’d be able to spot any pseudopatients
- Rosenhan said in the next three months he would send at least one pseudopatients and to rate each patient on a scale from 1-10 on the likelihood of them being a pseudopatient
- 193 patients were presented
- 41 were judged to be a pseudopatient by at least one member of staff, however none were actually sent
- Demonstrates that the likelihood of a type one error is also high
Was Rosenhan’s study reliable?
- Low inter rater reliability: no coding system and pseudopatients weren’t given any guidance on what to observe
- Pseudopatients were from different backgrounds so may have interpreted behaviours differently
Was Rosenhan’s study valid?
- High ecological validity: participants were not aware they were being observed so would behave naturally
- High face validity: observes the accuracy of diagnosis by presenting patients
- High criterion validity: the follow up study supported the results of the first study
Was Rosenhan’s study ethical?
- Negative impact on pseudopatients, but protected them by using fake names
- Telling those who questioned the pseudopatients that they were wrong may have caused them further harm through paranoia
Was Rosenhan’s study socially sensitive?
- Reduces prejudice against people who have been diagnosed with a mental health illness but are non-symptomatic
- Causes prejudice against people working in the mental health industry
How does Rosenhan’s study contribute to the individual vs. situational debate?
Shows that situational factors have a significant impact on diagnoses - being in the mental hospital meant that behaviour was labelled as abnormal when it was in fact “normal”
What is an example of a psychotic disorder and how is it diagnosed?
Schizophrenia
- two or more positive symptoms must be experienced for one month to be diagnosed
Positive:
- persistent hallucinations/voices giving a running commentary
- delusions of control, influence or passivity
Negative:
- social withdrawal
- significant and consistent change in overall quality of some aspects of behaviour
What is an example of an affective disorder and how is it diagnosed?
Depression
- depressed mood/loss of interest in daily activities for more than two weeks
- impaired function: social, educational, occupational
- symptoms such as: change in sleep, weight change over 5%, guilt/worthlessness, concentration and suicidality
What is an example of an anxiety disorder and how is it diagnosed?
OCD - obsessive compulsive disorder
Obsessive thoughts: ideas, images or impulses entering the mind again and again in a stereotyped form
Compulsive acts: stereotyped behaviours repeated again and again
- both must be present on most days for two weeks to make a diagnosis
- must be a source of distress and be unpleasantly repetitive
- must be at least one thought or act that is still resisted unsuccessfully
How does the biochemical model explain depression?
- the monoamine hypothesis proposes that depression is caused by low levels of a group of neurotransmitters called monoamines (including serotonin, noradrenaline and dopamine)
- monoamines are important in regulating the function of the limbic system in the brain, which controls emotion and drives states such as appetite