Mens Rea Flashcards
Moloney 1985
INTENTION
Drunk shooting competition
Intoxication = no intent - NEED SPECIFIC INTENT
Lipman
INTENTION
Snake
Not have happened sober
Woollen 1998
INTENTION
Virtual Certainty = Oblique Intent
Threw son
Matthews & Alleyne 2003
INTENTION
Entitled to infer intent from virtual certainty OR is is intent?
Not entitled to find intent unless…
Stein 1947
INTENTION
Assisted Enemy
Objective test - intent naturale consequences of act
Cunningham 1957
RECKLESSNESS
Foresee kind of harm and take risk regardless - subjective
Caldwell 1981
ABOLISHED
RECKLENESS
Objective - gives no though to obvious and serious risk
“a state of mind stopping short of deliberate intention, and going beyond mere inadvertence”
Parker
RECKLENESS
Telephone kiosk
So obvious - deliberately closing mind
Chief Constable of Avon v Shimmen 1986
RECKLENESS
Martial Arts
Belief in risk min - irrelevant
Morgan 1976
RECKLENESS
Reasonable person who is not drunk
Elliott 1983
RECKLENESS
14yo learning difficulties - irrelevant
R v G and R HL 2003
RECKLENESS
Correct Caldwell (young fire)
Aware of risk - unreasonable takes it
Andrews 1937
NEGLIGENCE
Overtook car, hit - manslaughter
Degree of negligence for gross neg? - ‘very high’
Adomako 1995
NEGLIGENCE
Anaesthetist - DoC + Brach + Causing death + Gross N
R v K 2001
STRICT LIABILITY
Presumption of MR
Acquitted if honest believe girl was over 16