Capacity Flashcards
C v DPP 1995
INFANCY
Damage property - 12yo- knew he was in trouble
Doli Incapax
R v JTB 2009
INFANCY
Inciting under age sexual activity - 12 yo
s34 abolished Doli defence itself, not merely the presumption
Wells 2015
FITNESS TO PLEAD
Unrestricted hospital order
Trial of the facts? - can use interview with warning
R v M, Kerr and H 2002
FITNESS TO PLEAD
Understand charge, plea, challenge witness, instruct, follow, testify
Grant 2002
FITNESS TO PLEAD
Hospital - conflict HRA? - not arbitrary
M’Naghten Case 1843
INSANITY
Defect of reason caused by disease of the mind
Not know nature/ quality of act
Not know act is legally wrong
Sullivan 1984
INSANITY
Epileptic - disease of mind - protect society
Brennan 2014
DIMINISHED RESPONSIBILITY
Jury ignored psychiatric evidence - wrongly invited to enter psychiatric domain
Dowds 2012
DIMINISHED RESPONSIBILITY
Acute intoxication - medical disease but not legal - different concerns
Quick 1973
AUTOMATISM
Hypoglycemic - insanity - intrinsic
Bailey 1983
AUTOMATISM
Hypoglycemia - self induced - not A
Burgess 1991
AUTOMATISM
Sleepwalking - insanity - internal
AG Ref 2/ 92
AUTOMATISM
Driver - trace state
Loss of control needs to be complete
DPP v Majewski 1976
INTOXICATION
Specific intent - drink and drugs considered
Basic intent - recklessness - taking substances
Kingston 1994
INTOXICATION
Drugged D- assaulted boy
Paedophilic tendencies - involuntary intoxication
Had MR = no defence